Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This broken Mac was broken through negligence. Apple is not responsible for their decision to take apart a brand new fully-working machine and wrecking it in the process. This would encourage everyone to take apart their machines for fun and end up costing Apple a lot of money.

FALSE.

If consumers are willing to pay for it, as Linus is, then there is NO money to be lost. Stop posting lies, it's disrespectful to the readers of this forum.
 
Did any of you silly people actually watch this damn video... they refused to service even after he made it well known he was willing to pay for every thing! all the parts and all of the "genius" "help."

The whole point was that apple had not even created SKU's for the replacement parts. Not even third party authorized repair places can order parts and do the friggin' repair. In the end it is stated that there are no replacement part available and the only option is to wait and see if apple will ever make part available to be serviced.

And frankly who would ever what to ya know service an expensive piece of equipment that broke.

What if it was just some Joe dingy who's kid decided it was a good idea to draw really vigorously on the monitor and damaged it.

what is he supposed to do just buy a whole new all in one computer... seems pretty dumb to me why in the age of replaceable part would you not be able to replace a silly screen...

also for whom ever says "oh he has enough money why doesn't he just go buy a new one." that far from the point. yes he could. yes it might hardly effect his bottom line. but the point is apple doesn't have anyway for a "professional service person" to even fix this thing thats the issue. Linus made it clear in the first video he thought this thing was great and apple was going in a positive direction with this product.

But to not create any sort of repair path for someone who out right said yeah we fudged up and we are willing to pay for it to be fixed and then not have anyway for it to be fixed is down right stupid.

AASPs can repair it. Parts are available for AASPs
 
Probably not a lot of spare parts available yet - they may be using them all to make machines and for authorized repairs.

And it sounds like the broke a bunch of parts, not just the screen.


valid point but what is someone who didn't pull it apart and break it supposed to do if it truly did break by accident. just wait it out...
 
AASPs can repair it. Parts are available for AASPs

If i recall correctly he said in the video he went to an apple store:denied. they told his to go to an AASP' they had nothing, then he even explored a whole third/fourth party and no luck. no one has parts
 
If this was a broken PC that was getting repairs refused by the OEM you all would be taking the piss and going on about how bad PC support is and how much better Apple's support is.

But when Apple has bad support suddenly its the user's fault. God tier double standards.


There's the rub. Apple has EXCELLENT support, it's among the best in the business. I've never had trouble fixing broken machines, in and out of warranty. This isn't a broken PC, this is a computer that the USER destroyed. Wouldn't matter the brand, it's all on the user.
 
Did any of you silly people actually watch this damn video... they refused to service even after he made it well known he was willing to pay for every thing! all the parts and all of the "genius" "help."

Blame whoever wrote and posted this article for Macrumors. It's clearly SPIN to make Linus look bad eventhough those who watched the video know better.

Actually, I respect Linus far more than Macrumors or any other tech enthusiast out there, I didn't even need to watch the whole video to know that it'd be a legit complaint... he's easily the most credible tech guy out there and yet MR still tries to smear the guy.. and now you have a legion of MR members making up ludicrous complaints defending Apple for being EXTREMELY petty.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Thomas Crandall
I can imagine the out of warranty repair fees must be insane.....either way I am sure this is just for clicks.

Edit: Additionally, i really hate myself for watching 20 seconds of this video. I hate this guy and the fact he is famous and probably makes more money than I do really makes me want to rethink my life.

Replacing the screen on a 2017 27 inch 5K is about $650.00. I know because my screen needed to be replaced and they quote you the price even though my issue was under warranty.

The genius/moron who fixed mine used a kit for a 2015 iMac 5K the first time. Guess what? The internals of the 2015 are different than the 2017 and he ended up gluing over my microphone array.

I am sure the cost to replace the iMac 5K is perhaps more expensive and complicated than a normal iMac because the internals are different. Who knows what it is glued to?
 
I am honestly baffled by the responses here, just a bunch of Apple ****suckers. Yes he is rich and yes he can afford to buy a new one, but what if that problem happens to you, are you gonna throw your 2+ thousand dollar computer away because apple doesn't wanna fix it ? This is completely unacceptable by apple and the people here lack the sense to call them out for it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: contractcooker
If i recall correctly he said in the video he went to an apple store:denied. they told his to go to an AASP' they had nothing, then he even explored a whole third/fourth party and no luck. no one has parts

Either the AASP isn’t keeping up to date with certifications or just wanted to dodge the repair. Parts are available.
 
Anytime Linus makes a video about an Apple product, he does so in a negative light. So this whole thing isn't surprising. Most of the time, official parts can be found on eBay and such, so let him shop there and repair it himself since he was so eager to take it apart.

Actually, the video for the now broken iMac Pro was pretty positive:
 
Blame whoever wrote and posted this article for Macrumors. It's clearly SPIN to make Linus look bad eventhough those who watched the video know better.

Actually, I respect Linus far more than Macrumors or any other tech enthusiast out there, I didn't even need to watch the whole video to know that it'd be a legit complaint... he's easily the most credible tech guy out there and yet MR still tries to smear the guy.. and now you have a legion of MR members making up ludicrous complaints defending Apple for being EXTREMELY petty.
I agree it's a legit complaint. At least sell and ship him the parts to fix it.
 
I put my iPhone in a blender. Apple won't fix it. I'm gonna make a You Tube video and try to get rich. Stupid people will whine and say that Apple is corrupt.

that's exactly how stupid this seems.

Did he asked for repairs? No.
Is he willing to pay? Yes

So yes, Apple is courrput and Apple absolutely should provide parts for him.

And yes, if you put your iPhone in blender, your warranty is void. Apple should absolutely provide you the part to fix your iPhone. I smashed my iPhone’s screen using hammer, if I am willing to pay for the new screen, Apple should absolutely fix it for you.

This just show how ignorant Apple is. Made me think Apple refuse change iPhone battery even people willing to pay for it.
 
FALSE.

If consumers are willing to pay for it, as Linus is, then there is NO money to be lost. Stop posting lies, it's disrespectful to the readers of this forum.

The reality here is that there is ongoing right to repair litigation and they are simply not going to let a YouTuber strongarm them into capitulating due to making a lot of noise on social media.

If Apple sells Linus logic boards, displays and other parts then they would have to do the same for independent repair shops.
 
I suppose an overreaction here was inevitable. He said he knew he'd have to pay for the repair, and was fully willing to pay for it, completely uncovered by warranty, but they outright refused to repair it, regardless. Makes no sense to me.

His YouTube videos are pretty entertaining, imo. I don't get the hate.

Do you think every Apple Store has the ability to repair any damage you cause? They are set up to fix dead hard drives, or other part failures. They're not going to be able to fix damage done by a sledgehammer. They're not an auto body shop.
 
Apple provides a service still... The fact the user would pay he should be allowed to.

Apple should repair products that fail on their own (meaning not disassembled) during the warranty period, free of charge. And be responsible for those repairs.

Apple should repair products that fail on their own outside of the warranty period, for a charge. And be responsible for those repairs.

Apple should not be obligated to repair products that have been willfully disassembled. How could Apple possibly be responsible for (and warrant) such repairs? No one would take on that responsibility.
 
This broken Mac was broken through negligence. Apple is not responsible for their decision to take apart a brand new fully-working machine and wrecking it in the process. This would encourage everyone to take apart their machines for fun and end up costing Apple a lot of money.

How so? It is not covered by warranty, people will pay for out of warranty services. How does that costing Apple lots of money. Funny most important thing for someone here is how much money Apple will loss.
 
I suppose an overreaction here was inevitable. He said he knew he'd have to pay for the repair, and was fully willing to pay for it, completely uncovered by warranty, but they outright refused to repair it, regardless. Makes no sense to me.

His YouTube videos are pretty entertaining, imo. I don't get the hate.

It's because he's not a Mac guy. The disrespect from the forum members here is as petty as Apple denying a customer to pay for a repair.

PATHETIC.
 
There's the rub. Apple has EXCELLENT support, it's among the best in the business. I've never had trouble fixing broken machines, in and out of warranty. This isn't a broken PC, this is a computer that the USER destroyed. Wouldn't matter the brand, it's all on the user.

yes it is, and he admits that but shouldn't some one be able to fix it. he is willing to pay for it. no warranty nothing....
 
Read my signature. I already voted with my wallet. Years ago.

And no, if the customer wants to PAY for an item to repaired, voided warranty should have ZERO impact. The guy is willing to PAY for the repairs. How much blind faith do you have in Apple to just let that kind of disrespect to consumers slide? My god, STOP IT.

So what if he's willing to pay for repairs? What makes you think the local Apple store is equipped to fix this kind of deliberate physical damage to the machine? If you crash your car, it's quite likely the dealer won't be able to fix it. You'll have to go to an independent body shop.
 
There's the rub. Apple has EXCELLENT support, it's among the best in the business. I've never had trouble fixing broken machines, in and out of warranty. This isn't a broken PC, this is a computer that the USER destroyed. Wouldn't matter the brand, it's all on the user.

Yeah except I broke the fan on one of my old ASUS laptops and ASUS had no trouble repairing it in exchange for payment despite the fact that I was the one who broke it. If I redline the engine on my car until it blows I'm sure GM would happily take my cash to put a new engine in it.

This is just Apple trying to discourage anyone from doing their own repairs/upgrades and not lining Apples pockets with their overpriced parts&service.
 
Apple should not be obligated to repair products that have been willfully disassembled. How could Apple possibly be responsible for such repairs? No one would take on that responsibility.

Then you are not obligated to have anything repaired EVER because every tech company SHOULD assume how your device was damaged, ignore your story of how it happened and favour their own assumptions.

Jesus christ... how can you cheer for a company this hard?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.