Spare us the lecture.
Have respect for others opinions. You know you dont have to click on the android threads. Just an idea.
Now I will step away and think of how I can ruin this world.
Last edited by a moderator:
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Posting information about non-iOS phones in this forum.
- Thread starter VulchR
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Spare us the lecture.
Have respect for others opinions. You know you dont have to click on the android threads. Just an idea.
Now I will step away and think of how I can ruin this world.
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPod; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_3_3 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8J2 Safari/6533.18.5)
I personally think the "Apple, industry and internet" boards is the best place to discuss alternative or competing products.
There are people here who have some excellent opinions and discussions on that part of the forum.
I personally think the "Apple, industry and internet" boards is the best place to discuss alternative or competing products.
There are people here who have some excellent opinions and discussions on that part of the forum.
People that say it's ok to post about Android here because of freedom of speech, censorship and bla bla bla are forgetting something very important:
Macrumors is a dedicated Apple Products site and specifically this sub forum is for iPhone discussion, it is not a general smarphone forum. There are even subforums in the iphone forum like accessories, apps, tips and hacks. I find it very well organized to have relevant discussions.
It is perfectly ok if someone has a question on how to sync an Android phone with OSX and posts in the Mac software seccion.
But when some trolldroid comes here to our own forum and calls us iphone users uneducated, naive, and fanboys just because we did not choose Android it is unacceptable.
Macrumors is a dedicated Apple Products site and specifically this sub forum is for iPhone discussion, it is not a general smarphone forum. There are even subforums in the iphone forum like accessories, apps, tips and hacks. I find it very well organized to have relevant discussions.
It is perfectly ok if someone has a question on how to sync an Android phone with OSX and posts in the Mac software seccion.
But when some trolldroid comes here to our own forum and calls us iphone users uneducated, naive, and fanboys just because we did not choose Android it is unacceptable.
Ridiculous. Every post about Android phones in this forum has been posted to compare with iPhones. So you're saying you should never compare the iPhone to any competitors and just blindly buy whatever Apple pushes out? Real smart advice right there.
Let me tell you, OP. The only reason why there are this many posts about a certain Samsung smartphone in the iPhone forums is because it is truly a beautiful handset that destroys the iPhone 4. All the posters here with a SGS2 are switchers from iPhones, and that's why we were part of this forums in the first place. It makes no sense that we shouldn't be allowed to post about our switching process since we've been iPhone users for so long
Never before has there been such a general consensus between every online reviewer, critic and user about what the ultimate smartphone is. The SGS2 is that handset right now and it is only natural that there will be threads about it.
Let me tell you, OP. The only reason why there are this many posts about a certain Samsung smartphone in the iPhone forums is because it is truly a beautiful handset that destroys the iPhone 4. All the posters here with a SGS2 are switchers from iPhones, and that's why we were part of this forums in the first place. It makes no sense that we shouldn't be allowed to post about our switching process since we've been iPhone users for so long
Never before has there been such a general consensus between every online reviewer, critic and user about what the ultimate smartphone is. The SGS2 is that handset right now and it is only natural that there will be threads about it.
This!
Is why we need a separate forum section. I don't really get why you post comparison threads, and then bash the 'fanboys' that don't agree with you. If we wanted comparisons, YouTube has EXCELLENT head to head video reviews. Much better than anything you could type out.
This is the "iPhone" section.
I think if it ends up being so bad then people should just talk in another forum about this.
Key thing guys, if you see something you don't like, then don't post on it and it'll die out.
I think if it ends up being so bad then people should just talk in another forum about this.
Key thing guys, if you see something you don't like, then don't post on it and it'll die out.
Last edited by a moderator:
That's what I thought would happen... Turns out the trolls just keep bumping their own threads. So they never die.
If you go back on a few of those Android threads, you'll see they die for a few days, and then the OP will go bump the thread. Multiple times if he has to.
Temporarily closed for clean-up.
...and now reopened.
The thread will be allowed to live if it stays on topic and stays civil. We won't spend another hour cleaning it up again.
...and now reopened.
The thread will be allowed to live if it stays on topic and stays civil. We won't spend another hour cleaning it up again.
Last edited:
So do I [agree that there should be a sub-forum for non-iOS/iPhone information].
https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1144999/
Last edited:
I think that we should be able to post about how other phones work under Mac OS X. Nothing else. There are many Mac users who don't necessarily have an iPhone, but still are looking for advice how to use their devices with their Macs.
Discussing about the competition is certainly good but only if there are certain rules. I just dont see how someone could abide to these rules, so I prefer to have no discussions about these phones here in Macrumors. Do we talk about windows laptops here? If not, then why should we talk about other phones.
Discussing about the competition is certainly good but only if there are certain rules. I just dont see how someone could abide to these rules, so I prefer to have no discussions about these phones here in Macrumors. Do we talk about windows laptops here? If not, then why should we talk about other phones.
XDA Developers is a great example of this. Windows Phone, Android, Bada & webOS forums all under one roof with the minimum trolling/bickering from what I've seen. They even have a dedicated iPhone community.
I don't know if the levels of maturity in the user demographic at XDA plays a part but I rarely see anything like I do here with unsatisfied members.
I think in it's own forum, but to stop Phandroids from spamming the forum (since it may look like an open invite) make it where you have to have 50-100 posts to post in that section like Community Discussions.
You want to know something? The answer is yes. I have my phone jailbroken with a HTC theme. I would have gone with the Droid Incredible II, if it wasn't for one thing. I don't have a credit card, so I wouldn't be able to purchase apps. I go to the local retail store and buy iTunes gift cards for my account. That is why I bought an iPhone.
You want to know something? The answer is yes. I have my phone jailbroken with a HTC theme. I would have gone with the Droid Incredible II, if it wasn't for one thing. I don't have a credit card, so I wouldn't be able to purchase apps. I go to the local retail store and buy iTunes gift cards for my account. That is why I bought an iPhone.
Last edited by a moderator:
The problem with that is that many new members come because of the iPhone. New members often spend their first months reading and not posting much, in order to get the feel of the place. Unless they spam themselves to access, they would be confined to the regular, original iPhone forums sections and would end up posting there anyway.
I also think that the terms Apple fanboy and Phandroids and the equivalent aren't particularly constructive elements in any discussion. People sometimes have brand loyalty, that's all, and there's nothing wrong with that. And who is better qualified to discuss the merits of different platforms than those who are passionate about them and use them?
If the issue is trolling and bickering, all that needs to be done IMO is to report the problem posts. The moderating team sees and discusses patterns of trolling, and we're greatly helped by post reports from members who frequent the various forum sections.
That's not true. I will soon have an SGS2 (and am coming from an HTC), but I've never had an iPhone. I'm probably not the only forum member who has been using Apple products for years, but went from an older cell phone type directly to Android.
I agree with InsanelyApple here; for me, the answer is yes. I consider myself a bona fide member, having been around since 2004, and I am definitely interested. That doesn't mean I'm not equally interested in iPhone discussions - even though I don't have one.
The problem is most Android users are ex-iPhone users. Other Android forums can be helpful but has less trash talking. And generally speaking, Apple does attract millions of attention whores and poseurs. They want to show off and brag about having the best device. Current Apple lovers get a taste of their own medicine of trying to look cool with these ex-iPhone users who love to troll. I personally don't care as long as the thread compares it to iPhone. I like phones in general and have no preferences. Having its own subforum would be nice.
MacRumors has already went down the crapper even before these Android phones came out. Just a bunch of little dorks who would make fun of people with a disability like they did to Justin in Dallas when he went out to campout. Being associated with Apple fans is not a compliment. If the forum is quiet, it is dead and nobody shows up. If it gets crowded, expect trolling and trash talking. Expect other posters wanting to make others feel bad and jealous. It is the "Look At Me" generation we live in when we tweet to get a laugh or have women post hot pics on Facebook for self-esteem.
The root of the problem lies on this instant-gratification society we live in and how it thinks. Yet, nobody really cares. So what happens? You try to become very obnoxious to be noticed.
MacRumors has already went down the crapper even before these Android phones came out. Just a bunch of little dorks who would make fun of people with a disability like they did to Justin in Dallas when he went out to campout. Being associated with Apple fans is not a compliment. If the forum is quiet, it is dead and nobody shows up. If it gets crowded, expect trolling and trash talking. Expect other posters wanting to make others feel bad and jealous. It is the "Look At Me" generation we live in when we tweet to get a laugh or have women post hot pics on Facebook for self-esteem.
The root of the problem lies on this instant-gratification society we live in and how it thinks. Yet, nobody really cares. So what happens? You try to become very obnoxious to be noticed.
The issue here is not what is being discussed but where.
Sure it is ok to compare platforms and have a preference. But there are multiplatform forums for that. This section is an iPhone forum. It does not look nice when someone comes here to proclaim how superior his/her Android phone is and then calls everybody that does not agree and Apple fanboy or worst.
I love the Nissan 370z and consider it the best sports car. Now would it be ok to go to a Ford only forum and start proclaiming the 370z superiority and bashing the Mustang? Definitely not.
Sure it is ok to compare platforms and have a preference. But there are multiplatform forums for that. This section is an iPhone forum. It does not look nice when someone comes here to proclaim how superior his/her Android phone is and then calls everybody that does not agree and Apple fanboy or worst.
I love the Nissan 370z and consider it the best sports car. Now would it be ok to go to a Ford only forum and start proclaiming the 370z superiority and bashing the Mustang? Definitely not.
Not true. Most of the topics here in Macrumors are either the next-gen iPhone rumors or issues with the iPhone that people need help on. Only some are "Post your (whatever)"
I like to see conversation about a new competitor in the smartphone world
that said, I only like to see intelligent, respectful conversation...not flame wars. And I also only need to see one conversation per new phone. I don't want (nor do I think we need) 8 different threads on the GS2, for example
that said, I only like to see intelligent, respectful conversation...not flame wars. And I also only need to see one conversation per new phone. I don't want (nor do I think we need) 8 different threads on the GS2, for example
I don't mind treads that are based on any device or OS. But it's the obvious trolling that is screwing it up for the rest of us.
IMO .... There should be a subform labeled "Versus" ..... cause it's very clear that the iPhone is the main phone that everyone else weights against.
IMO .... There should be a subform labeled "Versus" ..... cause it's very clear that the iPhone is the main phone that everyone else weights against.
If macrumors wants a "community" forum for off-topic threads, I'm fine with that. But I'd rather not read about the latest and greatest android on here. In my experience, allowing fans of other phones to post about their phones only leads to accusations of "fanboys" and "brainwashing" on both sides. It never seems very productive.
I come to this forum because I'm interested in the iPhone...notice the name of the forum is iPhone?
I don't mind the occasional post where people honestly have questions versus other phones, but there have been way to many flaming, trash-talking Droid/other posts lately...which is similar to someone taking a dump in the middle of the breakfast table.
Agree that maybe a different forum should be created, for those who wish to discuss the merits of and compare different phones, but lately this forum has had a lot of pollution.
I don't mind the occasional post where people honestly have questions versus other phones, but there have been way to many flaming, trash-talking Droid/other posts lately...which is similar to someone taking a dump in the middle of the breakfast table.
Agree that maybe a different forum should be created, for those who wish to discuss the merits of and compare different phones, but lately this forum has had a lot of pollution.