Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Status
Not open for further replies.
That's the biggest problem with a stylus. They get lost, and if you don't have another, your phone becomes a brick. Second biggest problem is that the stylus picks up grit and ends up scratching the screen.

If you had even bothered to research the thing you're bashing you'd know none of that is an issue with the Note. 1. It has a feature that plays a sound if you walk away with it without the stylus inserted. 2. It's just as useable as any other phone even without the stylus. Also, I personally never had a problem with the stylus scratching the screen.
 
Very classy, Apple. ;)

Image

though we all know the truth!

PC-MAC-Amigaaaa-300x238.jpg
 
Seems to me these ads were created mostly for trolling and flame wars on the internet than for general consumers. Samsung knows that all the major tech sites would write about them as they'd drive page views.

What amazes is me is how much attention other companies give to a company they seem to think is so inferior. I mean how often does Coke mention Pepsi in their commercials? Or McDonalds mentioning Burger King? It's not like Samsung is some scrappy upstart that needs attention. Heck, last year they spent $14B on advertising. The last thing Samsung is lacking is attention. But for some reason they seem to want to give Apple more (free) attention. Odd.
 
Actually, those were pretty funny ads. At least what Samsung is saying in the ads is true: The iPhone screen is too small by today's standards (or at least there should be a choice of larger iPhones!), and the lack of true multitasking on the iPad is another fair point, though to be quite honest with only 1GB of RAM on the iPad Air it can barely handle ONE task... *cough*....Safari....*cough*

Absolutely agreed. Anyone stating the lack of windowed multitasking on the iPad is absolutely unnecessary and the windowed / pane-based multitasking on both Samsung's devices and Windows RT / 8 devices is totally, absolutely useless should just be ignored.
 
I've never understood the point of these adverts.
Sure, it shows how Samsung differentiates, but surely just laying into your opponent like that is weak minded marketing?

But hey, I'm a university student with an iPhone. What do I know?
Hi. I'm a PC!
 
Anyone dismissing the stylus: note taking in schools, believe or not, if you go to school/college you'll be taking notes and if it's something like science/math you'll need a stylus for formulas/symbols etc, keyboard doesn't cut it.

Sure it's time time for schools to have holographic projection, interactive immersive oculus rift educational content etc, but come back to reality, note taking is pen-based.

Trust me I tried using a macbook/keyboard to take notes in graph theory class, it was not pretty.

iPad has the most elegant and stylish apps, though I wish it had built-in tech to make a stylus work best, (you can buy stylus for iPad but it's not "native" so the accuracy isn't optimal)

Exactly. Wacom support is also sorely missing from iPads. All the capacitive pens suck and are incomparably worse than a true Wacom pen. Anyone stating the opposite doesn't have any clue about what a Wacom pen is and how it operates in practice.
 
But isn't a big part of Apple's marketing about being thinner and lighter?

How is that relevant to my question? Can you discern something being thinner than two pieces of paper? And if it's indistinguishable, and it's a selling point of the ad campaign, isn't it a bit pathetic? Is there one person that would buy it solely because it's 0.2 mm thinner than the Air? Especially if that extra thinness didn't buy you a lighter product?

That being said, I think the Tab Pro 10.1 looks like a fine tablet and look forward to getting my hands on one to demo. I just question Samsung's need to continually compare its products to Apple's. They should stop acting like little brother and let their products sell themselves. If they are indeed better, it will all get sorted out.
 
All of this is meaningless BULL until Google fixes the ridiculously horrible keyboard in Android. For work, I have had the Galaxy SIII for over a year and and HTC before that. I have yet to type a complete email, text, note entry without having to back up and correct 50% of the words typed. Horrible. Android has no idea what I am typing and does not properly correct on the fly. This is something I do not experience with my personal phone which is iPhone.

There are plenty of 3rd party keyboards to choose from. Even the stock Note 3 keyboard is very customizable. Google even released their stock keyboard to the play store. Android is the one platform that has many keyboard options.
 

The jailbreaking community made it into one ;)..But I do not see any reason why note 3 users should stay with the note 3 and not go in for a 12" tab pro..It just makes more sense give the price difference between the two..I wish my firm had given us the choice between the note 3 and the tab pro..I'd lapped the tab pro up in a minute, used it for netflix and used bluetooth to make calls when out of the country..
 
Absolutely agreed. Anyone stating the lack of windowed multitasking on the iPad is absolutely unnecessary and the windowed / pane-based multitasking on both Samsung's devices and Windows RT / 8 devices is totally, absolutely useless should just be ignored.

Or it's just their opinion because it's not relevant to them.

That's one thing I hate about all these back and forth arguments, it's all so very personal. It's like people completely insistent that small phones are the best vs people who are completely insistent that bigger is better, etc.

It's why I hate it when people ask me what smartphone they should buy - it's become a very personal, very intimate decision and that's why so many of these back and forths are pure garbage, tbh. What works for you will not work for me, and what works for me will not work for Joe Schmoe.

That's why competition and variety is great.
 
I'm an Apple person to the core (no pun intended) but if I was a complete newbie to computers and the like, knowing nothing at all, looking at the second ad, I'd buy the Samsung. The script and the voiceover was the first Samsung ad I've seen that is actually well made.

Therefore while these ads will sway people to buy Samsung, that is the whole point of advertising. But knowing Apple as I do it's their OS and quality and design that is infectious and in the long term they will always be in front of the game.
 
"What we said at the very beginning was, if you need a stylus you've already failed.."

Steve Jobs at D8 - 2010

Nuff said!
 
Multitaksing on any tablet,if t has the capabilities, is a bi**h.
Now, here are the specs the late 2011 macbook air 13 inch:

http://support.apple.com/kb/SP683

I have this model and let me tell you that navigating through Nike.com's sight is a nightmare. So just imagine trying to do 'REAL" MT on a tablet.
Samsung is desperate and boring.
I have the 1st gen iPad mini and it blows anything I have seen from competitors away.
 
A huuuuge number of people have switched from iOS to other brands because they wanted something bigger. Even "I" dabbled with an HTC One for a while. The screen and speakers on the HTC One are truly excellent. HEAVEN forbid we should have a choice.

Remember, consumers are what keeps Apple in business. Sure, Apple is doing fine. But imagine how much MORE fine they'd be doing if they gave people the choice over the size of their handsets. I'm pretty sure "adult hands" vary from person to person. My hands are much, much larger than my wife's, so clearly we need smaller phones, - by your logic.

Let's give people the choice, and then work from there, yes?

hey buddy, apple doesn't force you to sign your life away when you buy an iPhone. I was only commenting on you remark about it not being big enough in todays market versus the before. Your argument makes a lot of sense and it would make a lot of sense that Apple sells even more phones if they released a cheaper plastic phone but the results didn't follow through. Even Tim Cook came out and said they underestimated the demand for the 5S thinking people would opt for the cheaper 5C.
 
I got rid of a stylus on my smartphone since HTC Tytan II .... And don't want to come back for ANY REASON.
I want to use my smartphone single handed.

The HTC TyTN II, as did all phones of that age (2007) except for the iPhone, had a resistive screen. It's just incomparable to a Wacom-based pen. The latter is much-much better than a resistive touchscreen used with a pen. Also, Samsung's (or, for that matter, Microsoft's) Wacom-friendly tablets also have a capacitive touchscreen, allowing for seamless touch operations: the best of both worlds, as opposed to an outdated and neither pen- nor touch-optimized resistive touchscreen of the HTC TyTN II.
 
Multitaksing on any tablet,if t has the capabilities, is a bi**h.

You haven't ever handled multipane-enabled Windows RT / 8 / Pro or Samsung tablet, I take it. Otehrwise, you wouldn't write such nonsense.

FYI: on Windows RT / 8, it takes only some very simple gestures to display two apps next to each one. No need to size them with a pen or anything. Everything can be done with simple and quick gestures.

This is what is sorely missing from iOS.

----------

"What we said at the very beginning was, if you need a stylus you've already failed.."

Steve Jobs at D8 - 2010

Nuff said!

Lolz... tell this to the Wacom folks :) You'll be simply laughed at. Imagine having to draw a hi-res drawing with touch - and compare how easy it is to do the same with a Wacom pen.

You obviously don't have a clue.
 
Oosh, did you see the interface steps to get the cropped image sent to his imaginary friend?
That sort of clunky UI hell is why I have an iPhone.
 
It is funny seeing so many people getting all bent out of shape over commercials, isn't it? You'd think someone was insulting their mother or family.

And it is equally funny seeing so many posts from people that resort to name calling those that have criticized the ad or the Samsung products in the ad. You'd think someone was insulting their mother or family.

See what I did there.
 
You mean like Retina?

Apple actually crams those individual pixels in to a smaller form factor while preventing color bleeding using a resin coating on the transistor layer.

Samsung's display just throws in double the green pixels. So on any color that doesn't use green you lose any of the benefits, as well has get a non accurate representation of just about all images.
 
I have an iphone5s but recently got a Nexus4 for a project at work. I personally don't like the way the larger phone fits in my hands and I have fairly large hands.

Also, the larger screen doesn't make text easier to read; it's still a small device compared to a tablet or laptop.

I've been messing with Android and I like the ability to pin a contact to the home screen...that's about all that I've found useful so far.

Overall the ios experience is much more polished and the size if the phone is fine.
 
If Apple suddenly ceased to exist, Samsung wouldn't have a clue how to operate. I mean, who could they copy and be obsessed with then?! :eek:
 
You haven't ever handled multipane-enabled Windows RT / 8 / Pro or Samsung tablet, I take it. Otehrwise, you wouldn't write such nonsense.

FYI: on Windows RT / 8, it takes only some very simple gestures to display two apps next to each one. No need to size them with a pen or anything. Everything can be done with simple and quick gestures.

This is what is sorely missing from iOS.

----------



Lolz... tell this to the Wacom folks :) You'll be simply laughed at. Imagine having to draw a hi-res drawing with touch - and compare how easy it is to do the same with a Wacom pen.

You obviously don't have a clue.

Why are you comparing smartphones and tablets to Wacoms? Obviously not the same thing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.