Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
It's a tradeoff between size and function. With the Samsung, you get LTE, longer battery life. But compare the sizes:
Apple Watch 38mm: 38.6x33x10.5mm, 25g (Sport), 40g (Watch)
Apple Watch 42mm: 42x35.9x10.5mm, 30g (Sport), 50g (Watch)
Samsung S3 Classic: 49x46x12.9mm, 57g
Samsung S3 Frontier: 49x46x12.9mm, 62g
The Frontier is more than twice as heavy as the 42mm Apple Watch Sport.


My Omega Seamaster weigh 154g with bracelet. it's light like a "feather"!
 
Last edited:
Great looking watch with a fantastic bezel rotating UI. The most important addition is Samsung pay now with MST! Buying two on launch day. This is how you make a watch - sans Mickey and Minnie Mouse watch faces.
 
I quite like the look of it, but I really don't feel the need for a smart watch.
I thought the same thing until I got one. Since I wear a watch anyway the added features make it a no brainer for me. Just not having to take my phone out of my pocket many times per day for notifications, control music and podcasts would be enough. But wait there's more ;)
 
Damn, I have to admit it. The Korean design masters at Samsung just wiped the floor with Apple's multicultural elite design team. Wow. Got to give credit where credit is due.

Meh.

The LG Watch Urbane looks kinda nice. The Withings Activité looks nice.

This? This mostly just looks bulky. And it is. It's huge compared to the Apple Watch, which is already on the large side.

Listen, dummies at Apple, a circle looks nicer and list view UIs work just as well as on rectangular displays. Tech is about function over form.

Huh? Are you simultaneously arguing that a circle is the "nicer" "form" and yet that the UI should be about "function"?

This makes me want to stash my iWatch in a drawer along with the useless iPad, iPod, and MacBook Air.

I bet that would be true if you owned any of those products, and if you had far more money than sense.

For example, the rotating dial is a far, far more clever design than the Digital Crown.

That may well be.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Night Spring
Benchmarks do nothing for real world use. The S1 is far more efficient and optimized for the software, in comparison to the phone-designed SD 400 that is completely un-optimized for Android Wear that is nowhere near as efficient.

You're speculating. Give me data.

What we do know is that it's built on a 28nm process, like the A7 was, which means plenty of potential for a die shrink — thus, lower energy usage, taking up less space, more room for performance. I expect a massive boost with the S2.

But I'd still like some more data.
 
I
Meh.

The LG Watch Urbane looks kinda nice. The Withings Activité looks nice.

This? This mostly just looks bulky. And it is. It's huge compared to the Apple Watch, which is already on the large side.



Huh? Are you simultaneously arguing that a circle is the "nicer" "form" and yet that the UI should be about "function"?



I bet that would be true if you owned any of those products, and if you had far more money than sense.



That may well be.
I think he's being sarcastic honestly, but I'm still not 100% sure
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jax44
The size and OS does me no good but I like the design. Cool w/o the geek baggage. Of course it's a video so wonder if the display looks that good in daylight or if it has a decent screen refresh. I wish Apple would come out with something similar, but smaller. Maybe.
 
It's easy to have superior battery life when you have twice the thickness, twice the internal volume, and twice the weight. Plus, for many, it will be way too chunky which isn't people's favorite style. In my personal opinion, Apple did not just get pwned.

The Apple Watch sucks. You have a semi thin device which has a crap battery life span. You don't have Samsung pay MST. You can't use Apple Pay everywhere you want. You can with Samsung pay even at gas stations but having to use a trick method.

The watch is ROUND which is already a winner. The rotating bezel UI is fantastic and if you think this watch is heavy have you ever tried on a Fenix HR? LOL, that's a $600 watch that has the worse junk "color" spinach screen display and the entire UI is slow. Sure it's fantastic as a sports watch mother of all metrics but that thing is a beast compared to any gear S watch. Apple got pwned is accurate way to say it.
 
It looks less amazing on real pictures.

iFAmurg.jpg



88UPdZD.jpg


ZqNNaPl.jpg


dnDnjRv.jpg
 
Looks nice head-on. From the side it kind of resembles a Double Stuf Oreo with wings. I still prefer a square screen over a round one for usability. Always good to see stiff competition though!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Night Spring
boring - watches arent the next big thing.

That includes the Apple Watch.

A lot of people I see have their phones always in their hand. Just how much effort is it to turn the wrist vs. looking at the phone?

The few seconds it takes to take my phone out of my pocket is nothing compared to:

Get sweaty wrist
Protect watch from accidental "clonk" damage
(Compared to my phone with case this one is out in the open and moves.
Don't forget to charge
Update when watchOS is updated

A lot of added tasks which I do not need.

As I get older reducing things to do is top on my priority list.
 
You're speculating. Give me data.
Since no benchmarking software is available for smartwatches, the closest I can give you is to go compare the iPhone 4s (A5 chip, supposedly similar processing power to the S1) to an Android phone with the SD 400 like the 2014 Moto G LTE. The 4s is still the better performer in this scenario. Also, reading the Anandtech review of the Apple Watch can be of some use to determine processing power I'd imagine.
 
Touché. Still don't think rugged look = copying though. There are a very limited type of watch looks. Like 3-4 different main types. I think their S2 was one of the more original looking ones.

To be honest, the first impression I got was it felt like a Garmin Fenix because of that rugged look. It was my gut reaction.
Upon closer inspection, the S3 is much cleaner (i.e. no screws).
 
Really like the look of this watch.

I'm not a fan of square watches, but the biggest thing that prevented me from buying the Apple Watch was it not being waterproof.
 
The LTE only turns on when the watch is disconnect from the phone. When LTE is running on the S2, it will run 2-6 hours, depending on what else you have turned on (WiFI, GPS, NFC, etc). I don't know what the S3's bigger battery does.

So its a maximum of 4 days. If you use LTE then you won't get 4 days, you'll get 4 hours.

Devil is always in the detail.
 
Heck, if this paired with iOS, I would love to add a circular smart Watch with my Apple Watch. I like to mix and match depending on the day. It looks good.
 
You know what goes great with a phone's data plan? A separate one for your watch! PASS
 
The e-sim is probably the most important advantage of this device, so it can be used as a phone - standalone.
I do not know if the lg watch urbane 2 with android wear 2.0 is the better one or the gear s3 but both of them are able to work compleately independently from a phone/
I hope apple will step up to this/
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.