Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I think my rationale, at this point, would be his voting. There really isn't much to go on. He seems to show up only right after appleguy posts, and then disapprears (I could be wrong about that). And last round he was one fo the few to not change his vote. It could be a matter of keeping low profile or just not spending a lot of time online.

I still wouldn't rule out Don't Panic or Nathan either.

17 credits can do that to you.
 
I have her on the list but what makes both you and Jav so sure she is a WS ?

There is still time to switch our votes if you can give a compelling reason why. Otherwise, it looks like it's ucfgrad.

definitively nothing compelling and no frizzling electron ram, just a hunch derived from multiple little things:

like
- the original vote for chrmjenkins
- the vote for eldiablo when he started hinting he was the seer
- the late switch to nies
- the newbie wolf argument
- the fact that she pushes (in two posts) for Nathan and me as main suspects because we voted early for Nies (a wolf), thus securing him getting a majority. I just don't see how a peasant would find that the MOST suspicious event in that round of vote, unless she is trying to generate random suspicion.
but as I said, nothing very strong per se.

aggie, what is the molecule in your new avatar?
 
definitively nothing compelling and no frizzling electron ram, just a hunch derived from multiple little things:

like
- the original vote for chrmjenkins
- the vote for eldiablo when he started hinting he was the seer
- the late switch to nies
- the newbie wolf argument
- the fact that she pushes (in two posts) for Nathan and me as main suspects because we voted early for Nies (a wolf), thus securing him getting a majority. I just don't see how a peasant would find that the MOST suspicious event in that round of vote, unless she is trying to generate random suspicion.
but as I said, nothing very strong per se.

aggie, what is the molecule in your new avatar?

My point in stating that neither you nor Nathan could be completely cleared was that we could read a ton of things into that vote. Not only that Aggie and I were more suspicious than everyone else because of our timing. As Aggie said, how is switching late worse than not switching at all?

If I was trying to rally anyone against either of you, I would have started with a vote.
 
Vote Tally as I see it so far:

Jav6454 (Nathan Muir, Don't Panic, Plutonius, Eldiablojoe)
Ucfgrad93 (Melrose, Ravenvii, -aggie-)
Plutonius (Jav6454)
Moyank24 (ucfgrad93)
Ravenvii (Moyank24)

I realize my vote on lbro was doing nothing, so I have switched it. I'm not sure why, I have nothing concrete to go on, but I'm not convinced ucfgrad93 is a W. I'm going to tip the scales in favor of ucfgrad93 simply because he is putting up such a weak defense, almost like he doesn't have one.
 
Vote Tally as I see it so far:

Jav6454 (Nathan Muir, Don't Panic, Plutonius, Eldiablojoe)
Ucfgrad93 (Melrose, Ravenvii, -aggie-, moyank24)
Plutonius (Jav6454)
Moyank24 (ucfgrad93)
I realize my vote on lbro was doing nothing, so I have switched it. I'm not sure why, I have nothing concrete to go on, but I'm not convinced ucfgrad93 is a W. I'm going to tip the scales in favor of ucfgrad93 simply because he is putting up such a weak defense, almost like he doesn't have one.

I actually changed my vote to ucfgrad93...Honestly, Im not convinced either, but it looks like a 2 horse race. (My change is bolded)
 
Vote Tally as I see it so far:

Jav6454 (Nathan Muir, Don't Panic, Plutonius, Eldiablojoe)
Ucfgrad93 (Melrose, Ravenvii, -aggie-)
Plutonius (Jav6454)
Moyank24 (ucfgrad93)
Ravenvii (Moyank24)

I realize my vote on lbro was doing nothing, so I have switched it. I'm not sure why, I have nothing concrete to go on, but I'm not convinced ucfgrad93 is a W. I'm going to tip the scales in favor of ucfgrad93 simply because he is putting up such a weak defense, almost like he doesn't have one.

Your vote tally is way off:

Ucfgrad93 (Moyank24, Melrose, Ravenvii, -aggie-, Eldiablojoe)
Jav6454 (Nathan Muir, Don't Panic, Plutonius,)
Plutonius (Jav6454)
Moyank24 (ucfgrad93)

Unless the earlier tally about Moyan voting for ucf is wrong.

I’d assume jav is going to change his vote if he needs to, as well.

Edit: Moyan was posting as I made this.
 
Your vote tally is way off:

Ucfgrad93 (Moyank24, Melrose, Ravenvii, -aggie-, Eldiablojoe)
Jav6454 (Nathan Muir, Don't Panic, Plutonius,)
Plutonius (Jav6454)
Moyank24 (ucfgrad93)

Unless the earlier tally about Moyan voting for ucf is wrong.

I’d assume jav is going to change his vote if he needs to, as well.

Edit: Moyan was posting as I made this.

I wonder if UCF will change his vote. His lack of any type of defense is weird. I imagine if he is a wolf, the 3rd wolf is annoyed that he got stuck with 2 wolves who haven't been much help.

But, Nies didn't put up much of a defense either. I'm just having a hard time choosing between Jav and UCF, because there isn't a smoking gun for either of them. For now, I guess I'll stay with my first choice.
 
Your vote tally is way off:

Ucfgrad93 (Moyank24, Melrose, Ravenvii, -aggie-, Eldiablojoe)
Jav6454 (Nathan Muir, Don't Panic, Plutonius,)
Plutonius (Jav6454)
Moyank24 (ucfgrad93)
Lol- you're right, I was wayyyy off. I even put my own vote on the wrong guy. D'oh! Good think I'm good looking, cuz I can sure be stupid :D

My vote is properly shown for ucfgrad93. Hope I'm right.
 
I wonder if UCF will change his vote. His lack of any type of defense is weird. I imagine if he is a wolf, the 3rd wolf is annoyed that he got stuck with 2 wolves who haven't been much help.

But, Nies didn't put up much of a defense either. I'm just having a hard time choosing between Jav and UCF, because there isn't a smoking gun for either of them. For now, I guess I'll stay with my first choice.

Well, supposedly it’s 9 minutes or so from the deadline, and jav if he’s watching could easily change his vote.
 
Ravenvii, a well known ornithologist, barged into Ucfgrad93's tailor shop.

"I need a fairy costume, pronto! " Ucfgrad93 gave him an introspective look. "It's for...err my daughter's play," he paused, noting the bandage on the tailor's hand.

"How did you get that?" asked Ravenvii

Sewing accident, needle straight through the finger. he said calculatingly.

"Word around the street is that the hunter shot a wolf last night. In the hand!" He approached the tailor.

"No, no, it's nothing of that sort" said ucfgrad93 unconvincingly.

There was no stopping the paranoia that had its hands firmly around MRVille at this point. Within the hour, the town's tailor was swinging at the gallows an untransformed villager.

It is now night. I need those PM's by 10 PM tomorrow, though earlier is always better.
 
If I get eaten tonight, it's Jav who did it. Please revenge me.

Trying to use a text, out of context, as a pretext aren't we? Clever but as much as you annoyed me this round, I would not take you out. Why? Like you hinted on your post, too much suspicion would be drawn to me. So that being said I bet that's what the wolves will actually do. That way you'll all lynch me. Clever.
 
Sorry for not really being able to participate properly in the last two rounds. I was really busy the last two days but tommorow I should have more time so I can pitch in more :eek:
 
Switching or not switching votes is damned if you do, damned if you don't.

I don't even bother these days. Just relaaaaaaax, sit back, stick with your gut feeling unless you have a change in gut feelings, and watch it happen man.

:cool:
 
Sorry man. :(

I never like seeing any player get lynched, wolf or not it's less chatter in the thread.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.