Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
And you are obviously not in involved in stress testing systems using devices actually used by customers.

The blame is on AT&T.
Actually, I am a QC engineer for one of the largest online gaming companies so I am pretty familiar with stress testing and elasticity of systems. It's on both Apple and the carriers.
 
I am buying mine outright without commitment. Hopefully, I don't need to activate it when I get it in 4 weeks and just a matter of popping in my old SIM.
 
Actually, I am a QC engineer for one of the largest online gaming companies so I am pretty familiar with stress testing and elasticity of systems. It's on both Apple and the carriers.

Incorrect. It's on AT&T to have capable servers, should AT&T decide to handle a load of a few million simultaneous activations. I can understand why AT&T might not want to invest for that unusual peak capability.

Ultimately it's an AT&T business decision.
 
  • Like
Reactions: marioguarneros
Same here. I called AT&T for help and they had me give them the IMEI/MEID and ICCID numbers for the new phone and according to them everything in their system shows that the new phone is activated. My old 7 now shows "no service" so I'm pretty much without a phone line right now.

so annoyedddddddddd
 
I wish the only problem I had was activation of the iPhone X. I was able to activate on AT&T and then the phone started going crazy -- jumping from screen to screen, dialing my emergency contact number and then 911. Apple Support had me to do a restore and I was finally able to get back to the "Hello" screen, but the screen wasn't responding at all to my fingers. They determined I had some sort of hardware failure. I've been on the phone with them all day and still can't even get my old phone reactivated as the SIM needs to be replaced because AT&T deactivated it. This has been the worst experience I've ever had with Apple. They said they'd expedite a replacement, but who knows when I'll get it and in the meantime I have no working phone. You'd think they'd offer some sort of compensation for all the trouble, but nothing. Off to AT&T Store in a few minutes to see if they can get my old phone back up and running while I wait forever for a replacement.
 
There's nothing new under the sun.

I got my first iPhone on release day 2007. It took over 24 hours to activate it and a further week to get my number assigned correctly.

Keep in mind: during that 24 hours, the phone was basically a pretty brick. Could make emergency calls, but not use ANY of the features of the phone, cellular or no.

It's good handset designers have dragged carriers kicking and screaming into the 21st Century. But boy.
 
I had to try about 20 times to connect to the iTunes server.

Also had to swap my t-mobile SIM card back to my old one, as the new one couldn't connect. No errors or messages, just all data, sms, and voice calls didn't work. even though it showed it connected to LTE
 
Incorrect. It's on AT&T to have capable servers, should AT&T decide to handle a load of a few million simultaneous activations.
Right, but if you're apple, wouldn't you stress test the server to 5x the number of units a carrier was getting to ensure seamless activation or ensure that the carrier provides evidence that they did the testing? They're partners with all their carriers - partners means jointly successful or fail together.
 
Not sure if this is right or not, but I ended up just swapping in my sim from my 7 Plus, also on AT&T and it seems to be working fine.
 
What I am being told is that device being activated right now are over running the activation servers. That is why we are getting the message that it cannot activate. I know you want the phone up and running, for right now, we are going to have to wait.
 
Same here. I called AT&T for help and they had me give them the IMEI/MEID and ICCID numbers for the new phone and according to them everything in their system shows that the new phone is activated. My old 7 now shows "no service" so I'm pretty much without a phone line right now.
I had to turn off both my phones and turn the X back on for it to activate
Tried that - also turned off "find my iPhone" as someone in post suggested. trying over wifi, cellular, nada. AT&T says they'll call me back in an hour - had to show them this page.... No cell on either phone. Will keep "Trying Again"
 
Not sure if this is right or not, but I ended up just swapping in my sim from my 7 Plus, also on AT&T and it seems to be working fine.

I was contemplating this too - did it bypass the activation?
 
Network issues are not really that surprising on launch day as buyers want to activate their shiny devices ASAP. This happens all the time since 10 years ago. I blame the network carriers.
 
Right, but if you're apple, wouldn't you stress test the server to 5x the number of units a carrier was getting to ensure seamless activation or ensure that the carrier provides evidence that they did the testing? They're partners with all their carriers - partners means jointly successful or fail together.

Sure, in a perfect world where cost is not a factor.

Apple is somewhat of a partner. And, no doubt Apple gave AT&T a heads-up on what to expect. But... Ultimately, AT&T decides whether to invest for that once-a-year peak activation capacity. Or not.
 
My iPhone X showed up about a half-hour ago, and I've been staring at this error ever since. iTunes just shows a blank screen that says, "iPhone"; at one point it loaded an AT&T screen where I could enter my zip and social but after clicking "continue" it never went anywhere.
Same thing here
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.