Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I never understood the appeal of Boba Fett as a baddie. I know he was made into some sort of really cool character in the expanded universe.

But objectively, looking at what he's done on film, he's not very impressive. He has a really cool looking armor, sure. But other than that his only accomplishments are getting lucky (picking the right star destroyers trash) and then getting shot in the back by a blind man :D

Every time I see his demise, I think this:

c48ed4ee395660c859c9ef6e461609974e72a7668b6b282f31eb029b7c7fea71.jpg


Same for his "father" too :p
Rocket launcher, jetpack and nearly takes down a Jedi.

Pretty cool if you ask me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rhett7660
Rocket launcher, jetpack and nearly takes down a Jedi.

Pretty cool if you ask me.
Luke is not a Jedi at that point ;)

Quote from RotJ:

Yoda: No more training do you require. Already know you, that which you need.
Luke: Then I am a Jedi.
Yoda: No. Not yet. One thing remains. Vader. You must confront Vader. Then, only then, a Jedi will you be. And confront him you will.

:D
 
I never understood the appeal of Boba Fett as a baddie. I know he was made into some sort of really cool character in the expanded universe.

But objectively, looking at what he's done on film, he's not very impressive. He has a really cool looking armor, sure. But other than that his only accomplishments are getting lucky (picking the right star destroyers trash) and then getting shot in the back by a blind man :D

Every time I see his demise, I think this:

c48ed4ee395660c859c9ef6e461609974e72a7668b6b282f31eb029b7c7fea71.jpg


Same for his "father" too :p

He's the unfortunate victim of he needs to be covered more...but doesn't sadly.


Also he gets out of the pit. Not covered in movies but in print/comic stuff. here enters nitpicking about canon versus non canon. Too tired for that lol....
 
Luke is not a Jedi at that point ;)

Quote from RotJ:

Yoda: No more training do you require. Already know you, that which you need.
Luke: Then I am a Jedi.
Yoda: No. Not yet. One thing remains. Vader. You must confront Vader. Then, only then, a Jedi will you be. And confront him you will.

:D

Well technically he has already confronted Vader in ESB. Didn't win and ended up losing a hand. But he still confronted him. :)
 
I recently watched Rogue One a second time, and although I still think the franchise needs to move forward into a new post-Death Star Chapter, I really enjoyed RO this time and have deemed it worthy, to such an extent I believe it should now be viewed as the Episode 4 Prequel. :D

RogueOneStandeeBar640.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: EnderBeta
I recently watched Rogue One a second time, and although I still think the franchise needs to move forward into a new post-Death Star Chapter, I really enjoyed RO this time and have deemed it worthy, to such an extent I believe it should now be viewed as the Episode 4 Prequel. :D

RogueOneStandeeBar640.jpg
Episode 3.8. Thats how I see it. Will be picking it up on Blue Ray to add to my collection.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn
I recently watched Rogue One a second time, and although I still think the franchise needs to move forward into a new post-Death Star Chapter, I really enjoyed RO this time and have deemed it worthy, to such an extent I believe it should now be viewed as the Episode 4 Prequel. :D

RogueOneStandeeBar640.jpg
It is the episode 4 prequel.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn
Episode 3.8. Thats how I see it. Will be picking it up on Blue Ray to add to my collection.

Me too. :)

It is the episode 4 prequel.

Would that not be amazing if they remade the transformation of Annakin Skywalker? It could be done in a single movie and I'd watch it. It might wash the bad taste of Episodes I-III out of my mouth. :)
[doublepost=1489496685][/doublepost]
Flicking through the TVs channels tonight came across this very old Two Roonies sketch/song.
How did they not get sued?


Parady?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mac'nCheese
Me too. :)



Would that not be amazing if they remade the transformation of Annakin Skywalker? It could be done in a single movie and I'd watch it. It might wash the bad taste of Episodes I-III out of my mouth. :)
[doublepost=1489496685][/doublepost]

Parady?
I wouldn't mind if they rebooted all the prequels.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn
Although the prequels aren't as good as the original trilogy, I'd not want a reboot.

After all the Spider-Man franchise is doing enough of that for the entire movie industry.
 
Although the prequels aren't as good as the original trilogy, I'd not want a reboot.

After all the Spider-Man franchise is doing enough of that for the entire movie industry.

The first two Toby Mcquire Spider-Man movies were the best of the series. When they rebooted it, I dropped out.
 
Although the prequels aren't as good as the original trilogy, I'd not want a reboot.

After all the Spider-Man franchise is doing enough of that for the entire movie industry.

The first two Toby Mcquire Spider-Man movies were the best of the series. When they rebooted it, I dropped out.

Agreed on both accounts. Although, I am excited to see the new one coming out, "Home Coming".
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn
Rogue One is available on Netflix for streaming. Just watched it for the third time, and I have to say this episode harks back to the glory days of the franchise and embodies the essence of Star Wars much better than Episode 7. Now maybe I should rewatch Episode 7 and give it another chance. :D:p

Rogue-One-Rebel-Dossier-Cover-Featured0-1222017.jpg
 
Last edited:
Rogue One is available on Netflix for streaming. Just watched it for the third time, and I have to say this episode harks back to the glory days of the franchise and embodies the essence of Star Wars much better than Episode 7. Now maybe I should rewatch Episode 7 and give it another chance. :D:p

Rogue-One-Rebel-Dossier-Cover-Featured0-1222017.jpg
Definitely. It will tide you over until December and episode 8.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn
Since Sky Movies is endlessly running the Star Wars movies now in the lead-up to Episode 8, I tried rewatching the prequels. To be honest, previously I never really hated them as others did. But I just couldn't get through the first one - every single scene with Jar Jar Binks is just godawful slapstick trash, and almost all dialogue throughout is so cringy. I don't know if they've just aged badly or I'm just slow in picking up how bad those movies were! :)

Rogue One I've now watched multiple times, and I really love it.
Same universe, but feels fresh due to new characters, slightly more serious and less silly interactions, FAR better dialogue, edgier plot. It makes the Alliance/Rebels into more of a nuanced group (far less clean-cut, more violent). Seeing the Death Star's destruction from the planet's perspective makes it seem a far more evil and scary prospect. (My favourite scene is the one where Krennic looks up and sees the Death Star hovering above with the weapon aperture pointed towards him). By comparison, The Force Awakens wipes out the Republic in one go and it seems a bit glossed over. Ok, billions of people died, but it's over in a few seconds..

The only real downsides to Rogue One were.. (cough) the unlikelihood of a sequel. And it's a traditional, self-contained story unlike the original trilogy which felt much more like small windows in time and space into a massive, ongoing universe. Ok, it also feels like Halo Reach stolen, but in movie form!
 
  • Like
Reactions: D.T.
Since Sky Movies is endlessly running the Star Wars movies now in the lead-up to Episode 8, I tried rewatching the prequels. To be honest, previously I never really hated them as others did. But I just couldn't get through the first one - every single scene with Jar Jar Binks is just godawful slapstick trash, and almost all dialogue throughout is so cringy. I don't know if they've just aged badly or I'm just slow in picking up how bad those movies were! :)

Rogue One I've now watched multiple times, and I really love it.
Same universe, but feels fresh due to new characters, slightly more serious and less silly interactions, FAR better dialogue, edgier plot. It makes the Alliance/Rebels into more of a nuanced group (far less clean-cut, more violent). Seeing the Death Star's destruction from the planet's perspective makes it seem a far more evil and scary prospect. (My favourite scene is the one where Krennic looks up and sees the Death Star hovering above with the weapon aperture pointed towards him). By comparison, The Force Awakens wipes out the Republic in one go and it seems a bit glossed over. Ok, billions of people died, but it's over in a few seconds..

The only real downsides to Rogue One were.. (cough) the unlikelihood of a sequel. And it's a traditional, self-contained story unlike the original trilogy which felt much more like small windows in time and space into a massive, ongoing universe. Ok, it also feels like Halo Reach stolen, but in movie form!

I never read the books, there were multiple Rogue Squadron books (?), but I think if they wanted to, they could do more Rogue Squadron stories. The problem and reason this probably would be an issue is that strory has already been told, i.e. defeat of the Emperor and his second Death Star, and the redemption of Annakin Skywalker.

My repeat critique- :rolleyes: It's time to move on with a new ark and if anything discourages me it's the story telling disappointment known as Episode 7. Granted it was not the abomination of episodes 1-3, but the chance to launch into new and fresh, something original apparently required some imagination that Abrams either lacked or he calculated his retread story would be a huge hit with a new unfamiliar generation, and that those of us with a memory would not mind the repackaging of the original story.

For anyone who is critical of Episode 7, this is worth a few chuckles. :) It's gotten 124k likes on You Tube:

 
  • Like
Reactions: whooleytoo
My repeat critique- :rolleyes: It's time to move on with a new ark and if anything discourages me it's the story telling disappointment known as Episode 7. Granted it was not the abomination of episodes 1-3, but the chance to launch into new and fresh, something original apparently required some imagination that Abrams either lacked or he calculated his retread story would be a huge hit with a new unfamiliar generation, and that those of us with a memory would not mind the repackaging of the original story.

That's why I really liked Rogue One. It just felt like a fresh start, while still staying true to the canon and characters. Ok, it wasn't entirely original (the end battle was very reminiscent of the battle of Endor) but it was a huge step forwards.

I liked Eps. 7, but it was just a cut 'n' paste of concepts / storylines / action from the previous films.

I'd love to see something leftfield for Eps. 8:
Kylo Ren is trained by Snoke, but something good in him stirs and he rebels and vows to fight for the rebellion. Luke finishes Rey's training, and gives her a lecture on how it's up to her to save the galaxy. When he's about to initiate her as a Jedi Knight, she goes down on one knee and he proclaims "Welcome Rey.... to the New Order". She looks up, with evil Sith-like eyes. Fade to (very) black. Cue evil choral music.

We've had several female protagonists/heroes in the series, but no strong female villians (other than the incredibly weak Captain Phasma). Rey appears much stronger than Kylo Ren, which is odd as the hero is typically set up as the plucky underdog.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huntn
That's why I really liked Rogue One. It just felt like a fresh start, while still staying true to the canon and characters. Ok, it wasn't entirely original (the end battle was very reminiscent of the battle of Endor) but it was a huge step forwards.

I liked Eps. 7, but it was just a cut 'n' paste of concepts / storylines / action from the previous films.

I'd love to see something leftfield for Eps. 8:
Kylo Ren is trained by Snoke, but something good in him stirs and he rebels and vows to fight for the rebellion. Luke finishes Rey's training, and gives her a lecture on how it's up to her to save the galaxy. When he's about to initiate her as a Jedi Knight, she goes down on one knee and he proclaims "Welcome Rey.... to the New Order". She looks up, with evil Sith-like eyes. Fade to (very) black. Cue evil choral music.

We've had several female protagonists/heroes in the series, but no strong female villians (other than the incredibly weak Captain Phasma). Rey appears much stronger than Kylo Ren, which is odd as the hero is typically set up as the plucky underdog.
Yeah, a recycled story. :D :p
 
I recently watched Rogue One a second time, and although I still think the franchise needs to move forward into a new post-Death Star Chapter, I really enjoyed RO this time and have deemed it worthy, to such an extent I believe it should now be viewed as the Episode 4 Prequel. :D

RogueOneStandeeBar640.jpg

I really liked Rogue One. It is better than episodes 7 & 8.
 
  • Like
Reactions: panzer06 and Huntn
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.