Well everyone, I have been away, playing with my new toys! My Galaxy Book arrived and I haven’t been able to put it down! Here are my impressions and a comparison to my Surface Book.
- First, the build quality is outstanding. There are no loose, or fragile dodgy parts. (I am looking at you Apple) It is solid and perfectly machined. The blue color is beautiful, not garish, and not dull. The keyboard is low travel, but very pleasant to type on. The back lighting is quite easy to see on the dark blue keys, however the Surface Book is the better keyboard in this area. The key travel is better, and the feel is softer on your fingers.
- The colors on the screen are brilliant. They are full and rich, without being cartoony. It is not a 4k screen, but it is a clear and sharp HD. The Book is no slouch. It too has a nice and bright screen with accurate colors, and it is close to 4k. Both screens are very bright around 354 plus nits, but… The Galaxy wins with its separate outdoor mode, that goes up to 600 nits, and yes, it really works.
- Tablet mode: The Surface Book is the clear winner. The Yoga style is nice, and the tent mode is convenient, but Microsoft has nailed the Two and One with the detachable keyboard. This makes using it as a tablet easy to hold and work with. The Galaxy Book with the folded back keyboard is much heavier and more awkward to put into tablet position, especially with the larger 15-inch size. In addition, you have the weird “squashy” feeling of the keyboard on your hand when holding it.
- The Pens: There is a lot of “noise” going on in YouTube land claiming the Wacom EMR is better than nTrig. This is the first time that I have had an opportunity to make a direct comparison between the two. I might add at the point that most of the issues that are reported with nTrig most likely have to do with using the wrong driver. There is a tendency for many applications to default to the WinTab driver which is not the best driver for nTrig. The Windows Ink driver is the one that should be used. In my use with Painter, Rebelle, and Sketchbook Pro, I found the overall performance to be nearly equal. Wacom does really will with line drawing and inking, which is why so many cartoon artists (no disrespect, I admire all art), this sort of art plays well to Wacom EMR strengths. The fine pointed tip also works well for this sort of work. On the other hand, I found nTrig to be superior in Painter and Rebelle. It was smoother and more natural to use for smearing paint on the canvas. In addition, nTrig comes with a variety of nibs for different applications. Now it goes without saying, but I will say it. For the ultimate painting and drawing experience Wacom’s stand-alone tablets Intuos, and Cintiq are the premium options, and for portable use Wacom’s own Studio Two and One. At the end of the day, both pen technologies worked well enough for any kind of art. For note taking they were equal.
- Battery was excellent on both devices. Samsung won out with 12 hours on balanced settings. The Book went to about 10, but the book runs an additional GPU as well as having a higher res screen. Samsung was burned by using a high res display on their Galaxy Chrome Book, because shorten the battery life in that device considerably. They decided not to take the chance with the Windows variant.
- Extras – Well the Galaxy comes with the S-Pen and a adapter for USB-C to USB-A and fast charger. It also has the ability to wireless charge various accessories using its track pad. The Book comes with a charger. The pen must be purchased separately.
Overall I am extremely happy with both machines. Which one for you depends on your use case. The Book has the advantage of being about to do everything extremely well, with it’s separate GPU, it wins for video editing, 3D work, and gaming. The Galaxy has the slightly more powerful CPU’s inside, and its outdoor mode option. It will do most things very well.
Well that wraps it up. I hope all of you find this helpful.