Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I got one just because I'm too curious of a person to have at least tried one myself.

I guess I liked it. It was kinda convenient to have the time and whatnot on my wrist. It didn't do anything life changing. I didn't like how it looked. 98% of the time it was just a black screen on my wrist. The breaking point came when I was at a mall that has an Apple Store and I saw other people wearing them. Listen, I have no problem having the same phone as so many other people. But I am WEARING the watch. This will sound kinda mean, but the other people I saw wearing it...I don't want to wear the same thing as them. It's petty or whatever, but it really bothered me.

Also, I was kinda digging it for the fitness tracking but I realized that it has no idea what I'm doing. At all. It's a pedometer with a kinda accurate heart rate monitor. And it's not even actually taking your heart rate, it's taking your pulse, which isn't the same thing. It knows nothing else unless I tell it.

I just didn't feel like it was worth the money to wear a semi-useful device on my body. I don't know what they could do to make it worth it to me.


Your pulse is the rate at which your heart beats. Your pulse is usually called your heart rate, which is the number of times your heart beats each ...
 
I got mine three days ago. The Steel one with Classic Buckle. But today I setup a return. I liked the physical design, I think it really looks gorgeous and the interchangeable strap system is absolutely genius.

But I just feel that for the price (£600) that it should do more. Now don't get me wrong, I know it has a small screen because it is a watch and that will always limit what it can do. But I feel like the limited functionality you can pack in to this small device should be reflected in the price and it just isn't.

£330 for the sport version, £519-£600 for the Steel. These prices are just bonkers for the limited functionality on offer. This watch whilst beautiful is a mass produced product with very little resale value once the 2nd version is released.

I think it's fair to say I'm disappointed that it didn't live up to the price. I really think the Steel should be £199 and the Sport £99. That may sound crazy to some of you but just look at the iPod Touch. The Watch and the iPod Touch share many of the same class of component. Display, WiFi+Bluetooth, Battery, Motion Processor, Light Sensor etc

But the iPod Touch is much larger. That battery costs more, that display surely costs more, there is more aluminum used in its construction, it comes with an 8 Megapixel camera sensor and yet it's cheaper, in-fact it's less than half the price of an Apple Watch Sport. That's just ridiculous. The iPod Touch does way more and is incredible value.

So yeah, I'm returning mine. I did enjoy trying it out but it just isn't good enough. Maybe in a few generations. I'd be surprised if it catches on. I'm sure there are a lot of people who bought it and have buyers remorse, this isn't the kind of device like an iPhone where it just made sense from the first moment you used it, this watch is a very tough sell in my opinion.

Well said. It should do more for the price. Hopefully os2 will revive the spark.
Maybe I'm too hopeful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ArizonaAnnie
I got mine three days ago. The Steel one with Classic Buckle. But today I setup a return. I liked the physical design, I think it really looks gorgeous and the interchangeable strap system is absolutely genius.

But I just feel that for the price (£600) that it should do more. Now don't get me wrong, I know it has a small screen because it is a watch and that will always limit what it can do. But I feel like the limited functionality you can pack in to this small device should be reflected in the price and it just isn't.

£330 for the sport version, £519-£600 for the Steel. These prices are just bonkers for the limited functionality on offer. This watch whilst beautiful is a mass produced product with very little resale value once the 2nd version is released.

I think it's fair to say I'm disappointed that it didn't live up to the price. I really think the Steel should be £199 and the Sport £99. That may sound crazy to some of you but just look at the iPod Touch. The Watch and the iPod Touch share many of the same class of component. Display, WiFi+Bluetooth, Battery, Motion Processor, Light Sensor etc

But the iPod Touch is much larger. That battery costs more, that display surely costs more, there is more aluminum used in its construction, it comes with an 8 Megapixel camera sensor and yet it's cheaper, in-fact it's less than half the price of an Apple Watch Sport. That's just ridiculous. The iPod Touch does way more and is incredible value.

So yeah, I'm returning mine. I did enjoy trying it out but it just isn't good enough. Maybe in a few generations. I'd be surprised if it catches on. I'm sure there are a lot of people who bought it and have buyers remorse, this isn't the kind of device like an iPhone where it just made sense from the first moment you used it, this watch is a very tough sell in my opinion.

You raise an excellent point with the iPod Touch. So much more device for less than 1/2 the price. Though a fashion statement is not about value for money.
 
You raise an excellent point with the iPod Touch. So much more device for less than 1/2 the price. Though a fashion statement is not about value for money.

There is a solution ...

latest
 
  • Like
Reactions: Benjamin Frost
I just dropped off my 42mm SS Watch at my local UPS store a couple minutes ago and here I am now writing up my thoughts about my honest experiences with it and why I returned it.

First off, I pre-ordered my watch at 12:03 AM PST. After an exciting 2 weeks, it finally arrived on the 24th. My friend, who preordered but wasn't as "lucky" as me, was just as excited about the watch as I was so I immediately drove to his house to show him the watch. Being a nice friend, I decided to unbox it when I went to his house. After around 20 seconds of tearing open packaging, my watch was in my hands. I got synced up in a couple minutes, no sweat.

The first day or two, the Apple Watch saw lots of use. Way more than normal. After the dust settled, the watch integrated with my daily life. I'd get notifications from things that used to come from my phone which was very convenient. Obviously Apple didn't want you to fiddle with the watch all day, it should be an extension of your phone, and it was.

After a week, I started feeling conflicted about the watch. Sure, I had a little buyers remorse about the ~$750 I just spent on the watch, but the price alone isn't what put me off. I believe that I'm in the market for a $750 watch, but for some reason I just couldn't justify the cost of spending $750 on this watch in particular.

What I did like:

The software. Configuring this thing is pretty straightforward. You enter in your details, set up your apps and glances and enter in your physical info and goals into Activity so that you can start tracking various metrics throughout the day. It's great. Notifications are consistent, the haptic feedback response is nice (though it could be a little stronger), and the activity tracking features are really nice, though if you don't do a lot of cardio you may not use it as much as you think. Sometimes the UI can be a little confusing at times (force touch doesn't feel intuitive at times being one example), but I think that the Apple Watch blows away its competitors in this department.

Fit and finish. All of the materials used in the SS watch feel expensive, even more expensive than what I paid for it (for some reason). The leather strap has a nice feel to it and the stainless steel case looks classy. The digital crown is smooth as butter and the heart-rate monitor on the back looks really cool. Apple has always paid a great attention to detail and the Apple Watch is no exception.

What I didn't like:

Third-party apps. All of the third-party apps are slow. In fact, it's so slow, that I avoided using them whenever possible. We all know why they're slow, but it still is an issue. It takes, for me at least, the same amount of time to grab the phone out of my pocket and open up an app then it takes for me to load it on my Watch. As a result, I found myself sticking mainly to notifications.

Fitness tracking. I'm 50/50 on this. On one hand, it's pretty good, but on the other hand, I feel like it's a compromise. You don't have to run with your phone, but it's recommended; workouts are limited to cardio; and the constant heart-rate monitoring can burn through the battery (this is a problem with photo HR monitors in general). Getting everything stored into HealthKit is nice, but honestly the UP does a better job in this department. The benefit of having fitness tracking on the Apple Watch is that it's part of the Apple Watch—you don't need to have a separate device to track workouts—but it still feels like a giant compromise.

The overall appearance. I'll admit, this is a first world problem at best, but despite the exceptional fit-and-finish of the Watch, it's still very bulky. It feels like I strapped a rock onto my wrist. Seriously. I know that Apple tried their best to cram everything into the Watch, but it's still pretty thick.

Overall:

I think that Apple is leading the category at the moment, but the category itself is still relatively new and trying to figure itself out. I think that the Watch has a lot of great features, but falls short on software and technological fronts. In my opinion, the Watch is a true v1 Apple product and they will learn from this release with the second one. With that said, I could probably justify a Sport Watch at the very most, but the SS feels like you're sort of overpaying for this piece of tech, even if it's for status-related reasons.
I'm sorry you had to return the watch. I agree that it's an expensive investment, and not for everyone. This is why we have so many other brands that people can choose to buy that are thinner, less bulky or whatever the issue is. There's always Samsung, LG, Nokia. Hopefully you'll find one.
 
I'm sorry you had to return the watch. I agree that it's an expensive investment, and not for everyone. This is why we have so many other brands that people can choose to buy that are thinner, less bulky or whatever the issue is. There's always Samsung, LG, Nokia. Hopefully you'll find one.

Are you saying Samung, LG or Nokia has a thinner or less bulky smart watch than Apple"s? If so, please post links. I'd love to know if any other company makes a smart watch I can actually wear!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Benjamin Frost
I just dropped off my 42mm SS Watch at my local UPS store a couple minutes ago and here I am now writing up my thoughts about my honest experiences with it and why I returned it.

...
ut the SS feels like you're sort of overpaying for this piece of tech, even if it's for status-related reasons.


You had a sweet SS 42mm with a leather strap and you returned it? I feel sorry for you man.

Back to your digital Casio I suppose.

Meanwhile I cant wait to get mine. I'll swing past your place and show it off to you. Just don't be jelly.
 
Well, I had a SS 42mm with a Milanese loop, and yesterday I returned it to the Apple Store on Miami Beach, not because of the price but because I wasn't receiving the notifications that came to my iPhone, especially mail, and I was only inconsistently getting haptics and no sound at all with notifications. I had the watch for a month, but they took it back anyway, However, the manager urged me to take a new one. I did, and it's having exactly the same problems. I suppose I won't return this one but wait for OS 2. Perhaps things will go better. I wonder if this is not more of an iPhone problem than an Apple Watch problem. Few people seem to be complaining about it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Benjamin Frost
So...IF I want to, can I??? I bought a Watch at Apple Upper West Side NYC a week and a bit ago. I am back in Australia. Can I return it via an Apple Store here?
 
So...IF I want to, can I??? I bought a Watch at Apple Upper West Side NYC a week and a bit ago. I am back in Australia. Can I return it via an Apple Store here?

I doubt it. Among other issues, you bought it with US dollars, so how are they going to refund you???
 
After two days I think mine is going back. I am a tester of mobile technology for my company and use both platforms. As of now, I have a bad taste in my mouth with Android, so I put my m360 away, switched back to my iPhone 6. Decided to get the Apple Watch.
For my use case, the watch simply isn't worth $428 (after tax). I use these watches simply for notifications. I don't care about ANY of the health stuff. Therefore, for it to tell me I have a text or call/email isn't worth the more than double the price of my m360. I have no desire to go back to AW, so I rather just go back to my Movado's.
The whole notification piece on this watch is complicated...show notification....glances, mirror watch, custom, etc. Yesterday, it just decided to alert me of what it wanted to. I tend to mute my phone and get notified from watch. I missed several texts....it wasn't doing anything. I grabbed another phone and sent test texts and calls...nothing. I ended up resetting it from the settings. Now it's working again.
I have several watches just under 1000 bucks, so spending the money isn't the issue. It's that Apple price pointed the watch all wrong to me. Then have the nerve to charge 150 for a band!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Benjamin Frost
Well, I had a SS 42mm with a Milanese loop, and yesterday I returned it to the Apple Store on Miami Beach, not because of the price but because I wasn't receiving the notifications that came to my iPhone, especially mail, and I was only inconsistently getting haptics and no sound at all with notifications. I had the watch for a month, but they took it back anyway, However, the manager urged me to take a new one. I did, and it's having exactly the same problems. I suppose I won't return this one but wait for OS 2. Perhaps things will go better. I wonder if this is not more of an iPhone problem than an Apple Watch problem. Few people seem to be complaining about it.

You probably know all of this but you won't get notifications if the display of your phone is on. Be sure to turn your phone display off before putting it away so you don't miss anything. Mine has been very reliable in that respect. I did set up a VIP list for emails so I only get notified on emails form senders on my VIP list.
 
I returned my SGS to the Apple Store…

…and then bought an open box from Best Buy for $20 off - 10% movers coupon - $25 off $250 Amex offer - misc Best Buy reward points :D
 
Just got the Sport model yesterday, already thinking of returning it. Can't remember ever being this underwhelmed by an Apple product. The UI is clunky and unintuitive, the fitness features are VERY basic, and for $400 I expected more than just an intermediary device that allows you to deal with iphone alerts/notifications.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Benjamin Frost
Just got the Sport model yesterday, already thinking of returning it. Can't remember ever being this underwhelmed by an Apple product. The UI is clunky, the fitness stuff is very basic, and for $400 I expected more than just an intermediary device that allows you to deal with iphone alerts/notifications.
Not trying to convince you of anything, but once app developers can get access to the sensors and can make native app in OS2 a lot of your concerns should be addressed.
 
Just got the Sport model yesterday, already thinking of returning it. Can't remember ever being this underwhelmed by an Apple product. The UI is clunky and unintuitive, the fitness features are VERY basic, and for $400 I expected more than just an intermediary device that allows you to deal with iphone alerts/notifications.

Brah, I'm loving it. First and foremost it's a watch, but on steroids. The UI is different from the iPhone but it's not clunky or unintuitive. Just read the manual and you'll be fine. Calendar, weather, sunrise/sunset times, activity tracker, etc... all awesome.

What do you expect from the fitness app? I appreciate it tracks distance, calories, heart rate, time, etc.

I like being able to quickly read text messages and emails. Even answering phone calls on the watch.

Back to my original point, it's still just a watch man. I got mine to replace my old watch and loving it. Huge fan of the watch face that allows you to display your anagram.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hellenek
"I was expecting more."

What? What exactly are you people expecting? Did you not do any research on it? Of course you did, because a lot of you have been posting about the watch since it was announced.

It's not a replacement for the phone. Repeat: IT'S NOT A REPLACEMENT FOR THE PHONE. Never will be. Never intended to be. It's a convenient add-on; a satellite device.

Is it worth the asking price? Subjective... and everyone has their own uses and the right to decide what they spend their money on, but that "I just expected more" line is ridiculous at this point.
 
Brah, I'm loving it. First and foremost it's a watch, but on steroids. The UI is different from the iPhone but it's not clunky or unintuitive. Just read the manual and you'll be fine. Calendar, weather, sunrise/sunset times, activity tracker, etc... all awesome.

What do you expect from the fitness app? I appreciate it tracks distance, calories, heart rate, time, etc.

I like being able to quickly read text messages and emails. Even answering phone calls on the watch.

Back to my original point, it's still just a watch man. I got mine to replace my old watch and loving it. Huge fan of the watch face that allows you to display your anagram.

It's not that I need to read the manual, it's that navigating the interface is clunky and frustrating. Feels nothing like an Apple product should. Remember the first iPod? iPhone? The ease of use was its killer feature. The watch is a beautiful piece of aluminum, but it's annoying to actually use. Every single thing is done better and easier on the phone. The watch just adds an unnecessary and clunky middle man.

I'd love to use it for the next 12 days and fall in love with it, see the light, and change my mind. But i don't think it's going to happen.
 
It's not that I need to read the manual, it's that navigating the interface is clunky and frustrating. Feels nothing like an Apple product should. Remember the first iPod? iPhone? The ease of use was its killer feature. The watch is a beautiful piece of aluminum, but it's annoying to actually use. Every single thing is done better and easier on the phone. The watch just adds an unnecessary and clunky middle man.

I'd love to use it for the next 12 days and fall in love with it, see the light, and change my mind. But i don't think it's going to happen.

Sorry to hear that man. Personally I haven't had any issues with the UI after reading the manual.

Ultimately it's of no concern to anyone else but yourself, but I think you'll be losing out man.

I don't think they could have done the UI anymore elegantly than what they have done. Look at what samsung were doing, put the Phone OS on the watch. Now they're coming out with a twisting dial around the watch face but this is just a variation on what apple has done with the crown.

It's an exciting time as hardware becomes smaller and wireless protocols will enable even cooler things to happen in the future. Stay on board man... it will be fun.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hellenek
Seeing another peson around the base here that has a watch (and doesn't find it particularly useful) led me to this thought: the people who somehow don't get the benefit of the Watch or see its usefulness since "my phone does all of the same things" are the ones who have their phones in their hands/face at all times. We all know those types, and yes - you're probably one of them. This dude has his phone in his face every time I see him; scrolling, typing, etc. He answers messages before the notification finishes dinging. Makes sense then... the Watch would be pretty pointless there, particularly at its price point. No sarcasm... I think, because I go hours of the day without looking at my phone or wanting to be bothered with notifications all day, I definitely can appreciate the convenience of the Watch.

Seriously, people considering getting one: really look at your phone usage/attachment. I think people who aren't quite so connected to their phones, or those trying to get a little less connected, are quicker and more open to seeing some of the inherent benefits.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.