This was a surprise to read. Under Tim Cook, I have bought so very few Apple products, and I'm a huge Apple fan. Under SJ, I bought almost every iteration of products because there were valuable feature improvements. Under Tim, it seems more like fashion based updates, but lack of staying ahead of the competitors, and even reduction like getting rid of the MagSafe concept... 3rd party companies can make USB C MagSafe connectors, but Tim knows removing MagSafe means more tripping over cords and breaking laptops which equates to expensive repairs and more share holder profit. I'm trying to be sincere here... please let me know where my logic is flawed with the MagSafe concept.
First off, I think it’s an extremely ridiculous assertion to make that Apple deliberately removed MagSafe with the express intention of hoping that users would send their laptops crashing to the ground more often, in turn forcing them to upgrade.
For the simple reason that if this were indeed the case, my next laptop most assuredly would not have been the exact same product that caused me so much problems and frustration in the first place.
My theory is a much simpler one. Thunderbolt 3 is easily the most versatile port ever shipped, and they are likely the most powerful as well. By doubling down on Thunderbolt 3 in one of the best-selling notebooks available, Apple is essentially forcing the hand of manufacturers and consumers everywhere to adopt and support it. Essentially solving the classic “chicken and egg” problem of each side waiting for the other party to make the first move before committing.
Sure, this “usb-c purity” mentality means no sd-card slot, no MagSafe, no hdmi, and no usb-A ports. And I say good riddance to all of them, even as I confess to loving MagSafe, and still using usb-A on a regular basis.
The new i/o selection in the MacBooks is a lesson in long-term gain for short term pain. In the short term, we are disadvantaged by having to carrying adaptors everywhere we go (though I maintain that this issue has been largely overblown). In the long term, we can look forward to more usb-c peripherals and support.
Think about it. With usb-c, there is potential to run a 5k display, connect multiple usb 3 external drives, connect to the internet via Ethernet, charge your laptop, and link external GPU modules all through a single cable! In fact, you can already do all this right now with a LG 5k display and a thunderbolt dock.
The future looks so very bright for thunderbolt 3, and I can’t wait to see the potential it unlocks. And if MagSafe had to go in exchange for this, then so be it.