Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Looks like you have made your decision!

But also I couldn't have put it any other way...

I definitely appreciate the feedback. In stating I am used to wearing larger watches, I wasn't necessarily stating that I do so correctly haha. I don't want it to be as flashy as some of my other normal watches. I want it to be sleek and fashionable but since I am accustom to wearing larger watches I am struggling to tell if this looks as it should.
 
I don't want it to be as flashy as some of my other normal watches. I want it to be sleek and fashionable.

So you want it fashionable, BUT sleek, but not sure if the size is correct?
I say it looks good! Could be Amazing and perfect... you could change that, the white band on the SS doesn't really go well with being Sleek and Fashionable. After all its a sports band. I understand that its your mothers. its just a thought. Color makes a huge difference.

I imagine if it was a BSB or a CB it would fit your criteria.

In short: I tell all my clients who go for things that they aren't accustom to buying... E x p a n d your wardrobe and go for something different. It defiantly doesn't look small on your wrist.

And after all
However, I don't want one that screams smart watch.
 
So you want it fashionable, BUT sleek, but not sure if the size is correct?
I say it looks good! Could be Amazing and perfect... you could change that, the white band on the SS doesn't really go well with being Sleek and Fashionable. After all its a sports band. I understand that its your mothers. its just a thought. Color makes a huge difference.

I imagine if it was a BSB or a CB it would fit your criteria.

In short: I tell all my clients who go for things that they aren't accustom to buying... E x p a n d your wardrobe and go for something different. It defiantly doesn't look small on your wrist.

And after all


I put in an order for a 38mm CB. The white isn't really my thing. I also have an order for a 42mm BSB (with an Milanese Loop coming separate) but who knows when that will arrive. I agree a different band can change how it looks so I will have to wait until those arrive to make my final decision.

Thanks for all your help and this wonderful thread.
 
Just got the 38MM Classic buckle yesterday, and I'm having seconds thoughts thinking the 42 would be a better fit?
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    1.7 MB · Views: 326
Here's another pic of my 38mm. I didn't wanna go for the "big smart watch" look. Other people before have said it looks good. Wrists are about 175mm. What do y'all think?
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    1.2 MB · Views: 339
Here's another pic of my 38mm. I didn't wanna go for the "big smart watch" look. Other people before have said it looks good. Wrists are about 175mm. What do y'all think?

I think it looks good... but it might be a tad bit too small. That's just my personal opinion though.

Honestly, it's very borderline. Either one would look good on you!
 
Having major dilemma deciding between 38mm or 42mm.... the 38mm in person seems so small, but in pictures look okay. Maybe I'm just not used to it, but what do you guys think?

My wrists are 160mm I think.

38mm:
VY0KNod.jpg

5rv8ibw.jpg

ue4RPhm.jpg

55PMeB3.jpg

1efhzP1.jpg

cHraIZL.jpg



And the 42mm:
UWoP8Jz.jpg

OlcHsib.jpg
 

Attachments

  • 11256486_10101221438615247_728662783_n.jpg
    11256486_10101221438615247_728662783_n.jpg
    40.8 KB · Views: 150
  • 11256406_10101221438665147_136198511_n.jpg
    11256406_10101221438665147_136198511_n.jpg
    41.6 KB · Views: 140
  • 11215992_10101221438660157_218925686_n.jpg
    11215992_10101221438660157_218925686_n.jpg
    47.2 KB · Views: 145
  • 11245152_10101221438675127_1990328952_n.jpg
    11245152_10101221438675127_1990328952_n.jpg
    42.8 KB · Views: 138
Having major dilemma deciding between 38mm or 42mm.... the 38mm in person seems so small, but in pictures look okay. Maybe I'm just not used to it, but what do you guys think?

My wrists are 160mm I think.

38mm:
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image


And the 42mm:
Image
Image

The 38 looks perfect for you actually. The 42 seems to overpower your wrist and like it might get in the way from day to day activities.

All of this is subjective though!

My personal view is a traditional watch can be larger, but in a smart watch if it looks too big on you, it looks rather techy.
 
The 38 looks perfect for you actually. The 42 seems to overpower your wrist and like it might get in the way from day to day activities.

All of this is subjective though!

My personal view is a traditional watch can be larger, but in a smart watch if it looks too big on you, it looks rather techy.

thanks! I think I'm leaning more towards the 38mm now... also because it ships much faster than the 42!
 
Judging by your card pic, it looks like your wrist is very similar in width to mine. You're in the "B" category. Therefore I would suggest you pick whichever one appeals to you most. I think both look fine. It's totally personal preference at this point. We're lucky in that we can wear either size and pull it off.

For me, the 42 just didn't feel right and the 38 looked better to me. But I'm more of a traditional kind of guy and not too trendy.

After reading about so many people getting the 42, I second-guessed myself and made a second trip back to the Apple store and tried the two sizes again. All I did was confirm that the 38 is what I wanted. Then I found this thread and it confirmed my decision.

I'm not sure if you're looking at the same picture as me, but that T-Mobile card hides his wrist completely, making him an A, definitely not a B
 
I'm not sure if you're looking at the same picture as me, but that T-Mobile card hides his wrist completely, making him an A, definitely not a B

If you read carefully, category B is described as:
Your wrist matches or just a tad smaller, or just a tad larger.
Just because it covers the wrist doesn't automatically make it an A. It's a bit subjective. For example in my case the card covers my wrist, but not greatly so. A 38 or 42 both work for me.

Also you'll notice closer to his forearm it widens rather quickly, much more so than mine. The card at his forearm end is smaller than his forearm, so he doesn't have small arms overall, rather just a small wrist if that makes sense. So either a 38 or 42 will do well.
 
Here's my 38mm, think it's about the right size. I also think the bright sport bands make the watch appear smaller due to being so bright. Have a classic buckle on order which I think will make the watch seem the right size.

Don't want it to look tiny on my wrist, but at the same time don't want it too overbearing which I think the 42mm would be.

What do people think?
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    1.6 MB · Views: 1,015
Sizing Guide

I found the sizing guide to be very useful as I was on the fence between the 38 mm and 42 mm. I decided to go with the 42 mm.
 
I think I'm finally ready to order one. I finally measured my wrist for band size and its about 175mm. From using the watch sizes on the phone app the 42 just looks too big. I'm going to go with the 38. I don't really care about the look. There is no apple store near me so I won't get the chance to try on the 42 until we go on vacation at the end of June. If I don't like it out of the box I have two weeks to return it anyway.
 
I think I'm finally ready to order one. I finally measured my wrist for band size and its about 175mm. From using the watch sizes on the phone app the 42 just looks too big. I'm going to go with the 38. I don't really care about the look. There is no apple store near me so I won't get the chance to try on the 42 until we go on vacation at the end of June. If I don't like it out of the box I have two weeks to return it anyway.

I switched my order from 42 to 38. Haven't tried it on in the store, but I have 175mm / 60mm wide wrist and by looking at others with similar wrist sizes, I thought I'd rather have something that looks like a watch vs a screen with a band attached. I put the cutouts of the faces of other wrist watches that I wear now and can see the 38 is just fine. I really wanted a Fitbit or similar to replace my everyday watch, so the smaller Apple watch stays in tune with what I was originally thinking about wanting a heart rate monitor on wrist, and something that also gives notifications. Plus I stay in the Apple ecosystem.
 
Looks good

Here's another pic of my 38mm. I didn't wanna go for the "big smart watch" look. Other people before have said it looks good. Wrists are about 175mm. What do y'all think?

It looks perfect. I hope mine looks that good. Depends on the look you want. I messed up and ordered sport band.
 
I switched my order from 42 to 38. Haven't tried it on in the store, but I have 175mm / 60mm wide wrist and by looking at others with similar wrist sizes, I thought I'd rather have something that looks like a watch vs a screen with a band attached. I put the cutouts of the faces of other wrist watches that I wear now and can see the 38 is just fine. I really wanted a Fitbit or similar to replace my everyday watch, so the smaller Apple watch stays in tune with what I was originally thinking about wanting a heart rate monitor on wrist, and something that also gives notifications. Plus I stay in the Apple ecosystem.

My 38mm SS arrives tomorrow. I'm 180mm/60mm. I've never seen one in person, but I expect to be quite happy with the Apple Watch mini. I want to wear the watch, not have it wear *me* :)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.