I have Apple Music, and I love it. There are some interface issues (that are being remedied). But seeing as how they've picked up quite a number of paying subscribers, I'd say people like it.
I would say so too, but it had all sorts of teething problems at launch, with the interface and user experience (not to mention that horrible launch segment by Cue whenever it was). And even today, lots of users are complaining about conflicts between their local libraries and their Music libraries (have you had any of those?)
I own one. 3rd party apps are mostly slow. But the performance of stock apps is good. You've already called this a great product though, so I'm not sure what point you're making.
The watch is compromised, and it had to be. The way they presented the compromise, and the actual choice of allowing 3rd party apps on such a performance compromised watch, is one of those head-scratch-inducing decisions i mentioned. I'm sure you enjoy yours, and I don't doubt I'd enjoy it if I had one too.
For people wanting a smaller iPad Pro or smaller iPhone, the event was probably fine. The only people disappointed were people that expected something more than what rumors were saying.
I'm not sure about that - the iPhone SE and 10" iPad Pro were well received, but I felt like the event lacked polish, and it lacked content. (maybe this is my rMBP-depraved bias showing though, I can't tell).
Other than that, all macs need an update, but we know that. We'll see some next month surely. But you've already acknowledged that Apple has continued to make great products. So why the lack of confidence?
All macs need an update, but still. Choices. They could have chosen to update the 15" to Broadwell (at the cost of a 3 month wait), the whole philosophy of the rMB is questionable at times to me, some of the hardware choices on the rMB are also debateable (don't want to beat a dead horse, but the camera and no TB3 just to name a couple).
The lack of confidence is probably a coalescence of all of these things. Less assuredness, wonky hardware/design choices, slight misrepresentations in earnings calls... it all adds up I guess. :/
No, the Apple Watch is the only new product category. There is a difference.
While I agree with that, i wouldn't call the rMBP refreshes "new products" either - I would argue the same for S generation iPhones.