May switch to Verizon
I bought an iPhone 3GS in June last year. In August my iPhone was stolen, I used "Find my iPhone" to locate and wipe the data. I phoned AT&T and was informed that I could purchase a new iPhone for $399 as the customer service rep noticed I have over 10,000 roll over minutes as coverage in the SoCal area is so bad no one can talk on their phones 75% of the time, everyone texts. I asked if this would effect my eligibility for a new iPhone come June 2010. I was informed that it would not as my contract would not be renewed, that this is a one time offer as I've been a Cingular/AT&T customer since 2006.
Now comes the fun part. I attempted to pre-order an iPhone 4, and was informed that I am not eligible until March 2011! I phoned AT&T three times regarding the matter, to which they stated my contract was renewed as the $399 price was an "early upgrade" (I thought $199 was the price, but $399 is an UPGRADE?!). I informed the AT&T rep that both the customer rep on the phone and in the store in which I purchased the iPhone reassured me that my contract would not be renewed as a one time courtesy. AT&T's response: "Sorry, can't help you". I spoke with the "higher up" management who put in an "urgent" case, but stated I would most likely be denied. It seems I was mislead in order to keep me as a customer as I stated I was considering switching to Verizon in August. I can't even buy an iPhone 4 at full price! Had I been fully informed in August I would have paid $600 for a replacement.
Interestingly, I was able to reserve a 16 GB iPhone 4 through the new Apple Store application for $199. It verified my account, which left me perplexed. I phoned Apple today and spoke with a rep who informed me that many customers who are NOT eligible for an upgrade were erroneously allowed due to server overloads. Regardless, I have the $199 price reserved and if Apple states there was a mistake, they HAVE to honor the price commitment (used to work at Apple as a Genius).
So if any one else is in this situation, Apple's policy states that the $199 price must be honored if the customer was erroneously allowed to pre-order/reserve their iPhones.
If this doesn't turn out well, I will take my family to Verizon. The only reason I'm with AT&T is because of the iPhone, but the reality is, what good is a phone IF YOU CAN'T MAKE CALLS?
