Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The desire for this larger Model Y seems to be currently met by the Hyundai Ioniq9. It’s here, it’s available in most areas, it’s priced well, and the reviews have been quite positive. I’ve met a few owners at charging stations and they uniformly love their vehicle having come from a variety of similar 7-pax ICE vehicles and one from a Rivian R1S.
 
The desire for this larger Model Y seems to be currently met by the Hyundai Ioniq9. It’s here, it’s available in most areas, it’s priced well, and the reviews have been quite positive. I’ve met a few owners at charging stations and they uniformly love their vehicle having come from a variety of similar 7-pax ICE vehicles and one from a Rivian R1S.
Not really. The new model y fully loaded will be almost 50 thousand, the bare base model Ioniq9 starts at 59 thousand and can go up to 77 thousand for the calligraphy model. Dont get me wrong i like Hyundai a lot but price wise and what one gets feature wise, it will be very difficult to compete with the new model y.

To get something like a panoramic glass roof, 2 captain chairs and power folding chairs which all come standard on the new Y, one would need the Ioniq9 limited model which cost 71 thousand dollars. Thats give or take 20 thousand to just become comparable. That not even touching the tech or the sound system on the Y. The only thing that will hold this car back is the CEO. With that said, the GV70 EV looks great, i wonder when Hyundai/Genesis will come out with a GV80 EV.
 
  • Like
Reactions: russell_314
Maybe it is a USA thing but a lot of people I know in the midwest (middle of USA) want a truck or large people mover and it's gotta be able to drive in snow/ice/gravel.

Probably the #1 complaint out of people I talk to is that EVs aren't "big enough" and can't haul enough. Guess I can see why some think that this larger Model Y is going to sell so well because isn't the Y better selling than the Model 3?

My partner and I don't have kids and we're happy with our Model 3s - but I can imagine if we had kids, a Model Y would be nicer.
 
Not really. The new model y fully loaded will be almost 50 thousand, the bare base model Ioniq9 starts at 59 thousand and can go up to 77 thousand for the calligraphy model. Dont get me wrong i like Hyundai a lot but price wise and what one gets feature wise, it will be very difficult to compete with the new model y.

To get something like a panoramic glass roof, 2 captain chairs and power folding chairs which all come standard on the new Y, one would need the Ioniq9 limited model which cost 71 thousand dollars. Thats give or take 20 thousand to just become comparable. That not even touching the tech or the sound system on the Y. The only thing that will hold this car back is the CEO. With that said, the GV70 EV looks great, i wonder when Hyundai/Genesis will come out with a GV80 EV.
Agreed, not comparable given price difference. But the China Model Y isn’t here yet, and I would have thought Tesla would go for the large Y in the US first with our propensity towards hugemobiles. And I wonder if it ever will be.
 
Not really. The new model y fully loaded will be almost 50 thousand, the bare base model Ioniq9 starts at 59 thousand and can go up to 77 thousand for the calligraphy model. Dont get me wrong i like Hyundai a lot but price wise and what one gets feature wise, it will be very difficult to compete with the new model y.

To get something like a panoramic glass roof, 2 captain chairs and power folding chairs which all come standard on the new Y, one would need the Ioniq9 limited model which cost 71 thousand dollars. Thats give or take 20 thousand to just become comparable. That not even touching the tech or the sound system on the Y. The only thing that will hold this car back is the CEO. With that said, the GV70 EV looks great, i wonder when Hyundai/Genesis will come out with a GV80 EV.
so the Ioniq 9 is 199.2" long and the current Y is 187" and the rumored Y L is supposedly 189".
So I would probably call the Ioniq 9 a full size vs the Model y (and Y L) a mid-size, thus not really comparable ...
And whether or not, and at which price the Y L will be offered in the US remains to be seen ...
Does the new Y L have an 800V architecture?

But whatever, reality today is that large cars/trucks/SUVs sell better in the US than "smallish" vehicles and more competition in that area will be great.

The new Leaf has a starting price of $29,999 (though that is without the delivery fee), it remains to be seen how GM will position the new Bolt, and I for one would love to see a Kona on the egmp platform ...
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigMcGuire
Maybe it is a USA thing but a lot of people I know in the midwest (middle of USA) want a truck or large people mover and it's gotta be able to drive in snow/ice/gravel.

Probably the #1 complaint out of people I talk to is that EVs aren't "big enough" and can't haul enough. Guess I can see why some think that this larger Model Y is going to sell so well because isn't the Y better selling than the Model 3?

My partner and I don't have kids and we're happy with our Model 3s - but I can imagine if we had kids, a Model Y would be nicer.
There are (unfortunately imho) too many "big EVs" available today, eg Cadillac's offering, the Hummer EV, F150/Silverado EV, the Vivian's, the new Lucid SUV just to name some. We have imho plenty choices in that segment.
I think what we're missing is an EV Jeep, built for off-roading, that people can use for commuting, I'm being sarcastic of course but I see way too many (big) trucks/SUVs on the fwy with single occupancy commuting ...
 
Agreed, not comparable given price difference. But the China Model Y isn’t here yet, and I would have thought Tesla would go for the large Y in the US first with our propensity towards hugemobiles. And I wonder if it ever will be.

China seems to get the newest models and features first (other than FSDs). The Highland TM3 and the Juniper TMY both came out in China first. I personally believe it is because it is easier to retool the factory there, and once done, it has the ability to ship to more places vs US produced Teslas.

China had the power trunk retrofit for earlier TM3’s before the US (the retrofit was first released in China), which I did on my 2019 TM3 once it was available in the US. China had ambient lights in the outgoing Gen1 TMY which has never made it to the US (I would do the retrofit if it came out). I don’t remember, but I think there are/were other cool things that we never got or got after China.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SalisburySam
There are (unfortunately imho) too many "big EVs" available today, eg Cadillac's offering, the Hummer EV, F150/Silverado EV, the Vivian's, the new Lucid SUV just to name some. We have imho plenty choices in that segment.
I think what we're missing is an EV Jeep, built for off-roading, that people can use for commuting, I'm being sarcastic of course but I see way too many (big) trucks/SUVs on the fwy with single occupancy commuting ...
Land Rover Range Rover EV 🥰
 
  • Like
Reactions: jz0309
Maybe it is a USA thing but a lot of people I know in the midwest (middle of USA) want a truck or large people mover and it's gotta be able to drive in snow/ice/gravel.

Probably the #1 complaint out of people I talk to is that EVs aren't "big enough" and can't haul enough. Guess I can see why some think that this larger Model Y is going to sell so well because isn't the Y better selling than the Model 3?

My partner and I don't have kids and we're happy with our Model 3s - but I can imagine if we had kids, a Model Y would be nicer.

Chevy has the Silverado EV..... but those do not qualify for the 7,500 tax credit. I think the car has to be under 50-60k

they are 70k.... also for a "work" truck. Having to spend hours charging seems like a massive problem. A level 2 charger does 30 miles/ hr charging... so leaving over night works for most people. But if you have to drive around all across the state for jobs or are super far away that is not going to be ideal. Range is also an issue tho isn't as annoying as I thought it would be tho I did go with the car with the most range outside of Tesla.

for me I think the opposite is true. Not enough EV sedans. Give us a 25k Chevy Cruze. Tho the Chevy Equinox EV(which I have is 25k for AWD after all incentives. It is super super small compared to normal SUVs. I say it feels like a Mazda CX-3 or a Honda HR-V. Love the car even tho doesn't have car play and charges super super slow.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigMcGuire
Chevy has the Silverado EV..... but those do not qualify for the 7,500 tax credit. I think the car has to be under 50-60k

they are 70k.... also for a "work" truck. Having to spend hours charging seems like a massive problem. A level 2 charger does 30 miles/ hr charging... so leaving over night works for most people. But if you have to drive around all across the state for jobs or are super far away that is not going to be ideal. Range is also an issue tho isn't as annoying as I thought it would be tho I did go with the car with the most range outside of Tesla.

for me I think the opposite is true. Not enough EV sedans. Give us a 25k Chevy Cruze. Tho the Chevy Equinox EV(which I have is 25k for AWD after all incentives. It is super super small compared to normal SUVs. I say it feels like a Mazda CX-3 or a Honda HR-V. Love the car even tho doesn't have car play and charges super super slow.
The credit is up to 80k for trucks and suv's so some trims of the Silverado EV should qualify.
 
Maybe it is a USA thing but a lot of people I know in the midwest (middle of USA) want a truck or large people mover and it's gotta be able to drive in snow/ice/gravel.

Probably the #1 complaint out of people I talk to is that EVs aren't "big enough" and can't haul enough. Guess I can see why some think that this larger Model Y is going to sell so well because isn't the Y better selling than the Model 3?

My partner and I don't have kids and we're happy with our Model 3s - but I can imagine if we had kids, a Model Y would be nicer.
The Y was the best selling car in 2023, not just of EV's but all cars, so think it is safe to say it is outselling the 3. Both are great cars with different purposes. We have 3 model 3's in our fleet plus my Y.

No matter what the other car companies put in their cars they all just feel bleh without FSD. Anyone can put in more screens and clutter things up, the coolest tech really is the self driving which no one is doing in N. America.

The Y is a great size, I think for families the Y L will be perfect. Went to a play on Saturday that was about 2 hours away with a friend and his 2 girls plus myself and my nephew. Fit comfortably in the Y. My Y has the extra back row but that is pretty much useless and I keep those seats down all the time for a larger truck area.

Some friends I have talked to would like the Y L if they had two rows of 3 seats rather than the cockpit seats.
 
There are (unfortunately imho) too many "big EVs" available today, eg Cadillac's offering, the Hummer EV, F150/Silverado EV, the Vivian's, the new Lucid SUV just to name some. We have imho plenty choices in that segment.
I think what we're missing is an EV Jeep, built for off-roading, that people can use for commuting, I'm being sarcastic of course but I see way too many (big) trucks/SUVs on the fwy with single occupancy commuting ...
This so much. I have no hate on the Cybertruck, F150 or EV9 but most people in the USA drive solo or with one passenger. Using a 3-5 ton machine to transport 300 pounds doesn’t make sense.

In the USA we have way too much road rage and part of that is people buying larger vehicles to intimidate and purposefully crash into other drivers. IDK if there’s a fix to that but a vehicle that transports 1-2 people should weigh less than one ton.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jz0309
This so much. I have no hate on the Cybertruck, F150 or EV9 but most people in the USA drive solo or with one passenger. Using a 3-5 ton machine to transport 300 pounds doesn’t make sense.

In the USA we have way too much road rage and part of that is people buying larger vehicles to intimidate and purposefully crash into other drivers. IDK if there’s a fix to that but a vehicle that transports 1-2 people should weigh less than one ton.
Part of the problem is marketing that the car industry does to incentivize theses types of cars. In general the bigger the car the more they can charge.

Road rage is a factor but I think safety is more of a driving force for the bigger cars. Some of those trucks look like tanks size wise and in an accident, nothing will happen to them but the other car is toast.

Another thing that mitigates road rage is FSD, it makes the drive less stressful, less tense. When we finally get to fully self driving, people wont really car much about road rage because they will be entertained reading/watching something on a screen or even taking a nap, but it all depends on how far real self driving goes.
 
Part of the problem is marketing that the car industry does to incentivize theses types of cars. In general the bigger the car the more they can charge.

Road rage is a factor but I think safety is more of a driving force for the bigger cars. Some of those trucks look like tanks size wise and in an accident, nothing will happen to them but the other car is toast.
There is a theory that safety devices contribute to unsafe driving and I believe this. If the steering wheel had a big metal spike instead of an airbag in the middle, there’s a good chance people would be more careful with how they drive. People feel they are invincible in these big vehicles, but unfortunately that’s not the case. They think nothing will happen to them, but even in a big vehicle you can easily die. Most crash test are done at 45 mph. In the USA most people drive significantly faster than that. Even at 50 mph the damage will be substantially higher than what’s seen in a crash test. In the USA over 40,000 people die each year in car crashes. I’m not sure if there are numbers but I bet 2 to 3 times that many suffered life-changing injuries. I guarantee you the majority of these deaths and injuries were not in small cars. I’ve seen crashes that I wish I could unsee.

Another thing that mitigates road rage is FSD, it makes the drive less stressful, less tense. When we finally get to fully self driving, people wont really car much about road rage because they will be entertained reading/watching something on a screen or even taking a nap, but it all depends on how far real self driving goes.
I think this is the answer. I’ve always thought manually driving a vehicle was the craziest thing people do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigMcGuire
Part of the problem is marketing that the car industry does to incentivize theses types of cars. In general the bigger the car the more they can charge.

Road rage is a factor but I think safety is more of a driving force for the bigger cars. Some of those trucks look like tanks size wise and in an accident, nothing will happen to them but the other car is toast.

Another thing that mitigates road rage is FSD, it makes the drive less stressful, less tense. When we finally get to fully self driving, people wont really car much about road rage because they will be entertained reading/watching something on a screen or even taking a nap, but it all depends on how far real self driving goes.
Really? I think FSD will just be another excuse people use for road rage.
People who rant at people over who gets to be in what lane or whatever, will always find a reason to hate others.

Not really an issue here due to FSD not being enabled in the UK.

As for cars getting wider and wider, that really is an issue. Especially in car parks.
 
We got FSD with our Used Tesla in 2022. I was able to transfer it to my 2024 for free when I got it last year. FSD on the 2024 is night and day better vs the 2018 (I believe due to camera quality).

FSD on the 2018 felt like a high school student learning to drive - for the most part it was ok but it made some bad mistakes now and then.

FSD on the 2024 is crazy good - rarely makes a mistake and makes driving significantly more relaxing/less stressful especially on long trips. I’ve used it for 3.5+ hours without any intervention at least a handful of times. Going to work when I don’t feel like it? - Brightens my day.

I spent a lot of my life driving to/from work ( had a job that was almost 2 hours away for most of my life (one way) ). I put 240,000 miles on my first car in no time doing this. I CANNOT wait to be able to read, relax, do something other than drive when FSD becomes ACTUALLY full self driving. I can only imagine how many books I could have read / people I could have talked with during all those years.

That and I feel significantly safer with FSD on - my watching + every part of the car being watched - it is absolutely amazing. I really hope the 2018s get an update…

FSD has prevented me from getting into several really nasty wrecks.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Student of Life
Part of the problem is marketing that the car industry does to incentivize theses types of cars. In general the bigger the car the more they can charge.

Road rage is a factor but I think safety is more of a driving force for the bigger cars. Some of those trucks look like tanks size wise and in an accident, nothing will happen to them but the other car is toast.

Another thing that mitigates road rage is FSD, it makes the drive less stressful, less tense. When we finally get to fully self driving, people wont really car much about road rage because they will be entertained reading/watching something on a screen or even taking a nap, but it all depends on how far real self driving goes.
It is marketing in general. Look at the people upgrading their phones every year, their computer, their iPad with every new model. The western culture is consumerism and most people drink that right up. Look at the stampedes for black Friday sales. The culture is messed up.
 
I don’t know how people afford those big pickups or SUVs… absolutely crazy.

When I was looking for a commuter car for myself last year I couldn’t get anything for under $800/mo and anything under a 6% interest rate (most were 8%) - my credit is not bad (north of 700).

Tesla was offering me a $500 monthly payment and a 1.9% interest rate. Yeah. That did it for me. One big reason why I went with another Tesla last year (that and we really like our 2018).
 
It is marketing in general. Look at the people upgrading their phones every year, their computer, their iPad with every new model. The western culture is consumerism and most people drink that right up. Look at the stampedes for black Friday sales. The culture is messed up.
It was easier when things weren’t so dang expensive. I remember getting an iPad Pro for $600. Now … it’s more expensive than MBPs. Same for my iPhone - I remember it being free to upgrade via the carrier for the longest time, then all of a sudden, $1000, now … $1800+.

The Black Friday sales are absolutely amazing - most of that stuff was cheaper during other parts of the year and anything worth getting is only a few bucks less, but people will line up for days (or hours) for it. Maybe I’m too old but that makes no sense to me.

Prices have gone up so much only the rich can afford to do this anymore.
 
Agreed. Never had a car loan. Never plan on one.
I genuinely envy you. That is really cool. All my cars have been loans. I’ve paid off 3 of them (over the years) and my two Teslas are almost half paid off each. lol.

My wife and I have iPhone 15 Pro Maxes and we paid off the phones late last year - the feeling of being payment free is so nice I don’t think we’re going to upgrade this year, from that fact alone lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: russell_314
I don’t know how people afford those big pickups or SUVs… absolutely crazy.

When I was looking for a commuter car for myself last year I couldn’t get anything for under $800/mo and anything under a 6% interest rate (most were 8%) - my credit is not bad (north of 700).

Tesla was offering me a $500 monthly payment and a 1.9% interest rate. Yeah. That did it for me. One big reason why I went with another Tesla last year (that and we really like our 2018).
The trick in general would be to make it a work truck/car (certain criteria needs to be met) then one can use it as a tax deduction, this also includes depreciation write off. Taxation is always a game of cat and mouse so laws do constantly change but loops holes are always there to be exploited. Thats how a lot of people work the system to get the vehicles at minimal real cost to them. You still have to pay for the car but having that deducted from ones tax liability makes a word of difference.

A perfect example of this was a while back with the way tax laws where passed one could basically get a Hummer at a bargain price when factoring the full depreciation for the year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigMcGuire
I genuinely envy you. That is really cool. All my cars have been loans. I’ve paid off 3 of them (over the years) and my two Teslas are almost half paid off each. lol.

My wife and I have iPhone 15 Pro Maxes and we paid off the phones late last year - the feeling of being payment free is so nice I don’t think we’re going to upgrade this year, from that fact alone lol.
Always bought my iPhones as well. Still using an iPhone 12. Will replace it when the battery becomes a problem
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigMcGuire
Really? I think FSD will just be another excuse people use for road rage.
People who rant at people over who gets to be in what lane or whatever, will always find a reason to hate others.

Not really an issue here due to FSD not being enabled in the UK.

As for cars getting wider and wider, that really is an issue. Especially in car parks.
Eventually they won’t have control over the car. They can roll down the window and scream at the other car but why. Most people will be just staring at their phones
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigMcGuire
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.