Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Would You Ever Switch To Android?


  • Total voters
    551
No.
In 2010, I was still with T-Mobile who was not yet carrying iPhones. I got one of their branded Android phones- made by HTC.
From the day I got it, I wanted to run it over with my car.

First, the operating system just sucked. I was still teaching and the wifi in my school required a URL and password for the proxy server. Android at that time only gave the option for a port entry (8008 for example). That meant I couldn't use the wifi in the building. Being a bit of dead spot, my phone was basically a paperweight at work. But it gets worse.

Because the phone could see the network, it would keep trying to fetch mail, etc. So if I didn't turn the wifi off, the phone battery would go from 100% to basically zero within an hour or so. I remember a Google message board with something like 20,000 messages screaming about this insanity.

Then we get to the Android update process itself.

So, Google announces a new version of Android...yea! No...sorry, you're going to have to wait until HTC plays around with it. Oh, then you'll wait until T-Mobile plays around with. So EIGHT months after a new version was released I finally am able to update my OS. And a couple months later...Google introduces another update...that HTC and T-Mobile never released for that phone. (Yes, I finally did a jailbreak to get it).

Then of course, you had seemingly a hundred apps that you had no use for that you can't delete- unless you jailbreak the phone.

Finally, in the fall of 2012, after 16 years with T-Mobile, I switched to Verizon. Yes, more expensive, but much better coverage and stronger signal and I got my first iPhone- a 32gb iPhone 5. This was a year after getting an iPad (Series 2) which was my first experience with iOS. The great experience with the iPad was the final push to the iPhone. I just had to wait until the T-Mobile contract was up and number portability was possible.

I'm sure Android is better today than it was eight years ago. But I'd never go back. First, without an iPhone, my Apple Watch is useless. But having my iMac, iPad, Apple TV, and iPhone all talk to one another (so to speak) is something Android will never be able to do.

No matter how much better Android might be today than it was in 2012, it still can never match the Apple ecosystem.
 
  • Like
Reactions: compwiz1202
Can you define what you mean by "Gimped by Android"?

I have a Google Pixel 3a XL and it runs Android 10. So far, in the last year and three months I haven't found anything that's 'gimped' the Android OS running on it, nor anything that's slowed it down.

Or did you just mean Android is Gimped on that particular model?
Android is definitely NOT gimped on the OnePlus 7 pro as Oxygen OS is the most optimised and polished version of android after stock. On top of that OnePlus regularly push out updates/security patches to their users. Everyone has the right to their own opinion, but it’s not fair to just put all Android phones in the same basket.
 
Then we get to the Android update process itself.
This is one of the reasons I went straight to a Pixel last year. I get updates and don't have to wait.

I have a 2009 HTC Touch Pro that's still waiting on the next Windows Mobile update. :)

However, I long ago just went and modified it to run non-stock stuff so there was that.
 
don’t iPhones work with any provider?

No. In my carrier's case, they built their service around the use of a patented method of blending WiFi and cell service. That method that requires an app. For that app to work, it needs the underlying OS to provide access to certain APIs. For a long time iOS did not. That said, times are changing. Either the carrier found a way to rework their app or iOS eventually introduced the needed APIs, because the carrier is doing a limited beta program with certain iPhone models now. I still don't have plans to switch in the near future, but it's nice to know I'll probably have the option if I decide to do so down the road.
 
  • Like
Reactions: malkovich87
I would never switch to anything Google - or Facebook - as I despise them as a company. If Ubuntu ever releases their own phone software and OnePlus allowed you to completely uninstall Google... maybe.

Using iPhone and dislike Google? Stop supporting them.

  1. Start using iCloud or Proton Mail as your primary/only email service
  2. Use Duckduckgo as your search engine
  3. Use Safari or Opera as your browser
  4. Use Apple Maps as your sole navigation app
  5. Use Amazon Photos or iCloud as your photo storage app
  6. Start transitioning apps to "Sign in With Apple" instead of Google or Facebook SSO
 
  • Like
Reactions: jlwarlow and yui4
I have been a fan of the iPhone since the beginning.

We used to have blackberry then android based phones for work, What a disaster.

Then they got with the program and switched to both and wouldn't you know most employees preferred the iPhone.
 
I would never switch to anything Google - or Facebook - as I despise them as a company. If Ubuntu ever releases their own phone software and OnePlus allowed you to completely uninstall Google... maybe.

Using iPhone and dislike Google? Stop supporting them.

  1. Start using iCloud or Proton Mail as your primary/only email service
  2. Use Duckduckgo as your search engine
  3. Use Safari or Opera as your browser
  4. Use Apple Maps as your sole navigation app
  5. Use Amazon Photos or iCloud as your photo storage app
  6. Start transitioning apps to "Sign in With Apple" instead of Google or Facebook SSO
Uninstall Google on Android? You mean uninstall Android itself then…'cause that's a Google OS.

PS. I've used Google services on every iPhone I've ever owned (since 2011). It's hard to use Apple services when Apple won't sync with a PowerBook G4. But Google will (and still does). Google's services are cross platform.

Vivaldi Browser, or on my PowerPC Macs, TenFourFox. I hate Safari. You also didn't mention Dropbox.
 
No, here’s why.

Literally nothing comes close to the Apple Watch.
Literally nothing comes close to the iPad Pro. (Or iPads in general)
CarPlay is much better than android auto (IMO)
Accessory manufactures prioritize Apple devices over competitors.
App are more polished and get new features/exclusives first.
iPhone shoots the best video.
5+ years of support.
Having Apple stores nearby is a huge plus.
Security/privacy.

There is definitely more, but these are the top things for me.
 
No.

Constantly updated OS
Best security among all mobile phones
Most trusted privacy platform
Works excellently with macOS devices
Best Messages app. Cross platform Messages in iCloud syncing
Simple interface for FaceTime Video and Audio
Best apps in general
iCloud syncing for all my documents, passwords, Keychain, mail accounts, calendar, contacts, photos, music, news
ARMed future for all apple devices will bring additional benefits
Best warranty, best range of authorised repair shops
With apple its easy to keep a phone for 3 to 4 years, or even 5 years if you just want to keep the same phone
All of the above the last is quite apt as I am in no financial position to upgrade my phone right now.
 
I tried Android. I found it to be buggy and I resented having to run anti-virus/malware software. I also didn't like the way updates were handled. There are times when I want to smack Apple but I can't see myself going back to Android - at least not if I have a choice.

On separate but related subject, I found Windows Phone to be a decent operating system and the hardware very good as well. That's because Microsoft bought Nokia's phone business. A pity it never caught on. I thought Windows Phone was a worthy challenger to the iPhone.
 
On separate but related subject, I found Windows Phone to be a decent operating system and the hardware very good as well. That's because Microsoft bought Nokia's phone business. A pity it never caught on. I thought Windows Phone was a worthy challenger to the iPhone.
I can remember back in 2010 when I was using copy/paste on my WinMo phone (HTC Touch Pro) and able to send MMS. Neither of those things were possible at the time for my iPhone friends.
 
No, here’s why.

Literally nothing comes close to the Apple Watch.
Literally nothing comes close to the iPad Pro. (Or iPads in general)
CarPlay is much better than android auto (IMO)
Accessory manufactures prioritize Apple devices over competitors.
App are more polished and get new features/exclusives first.
iPhone shoots the best video.
5+ years of support.
Having Apple stores nearby is a huge plus.
Security/privacy.

There is definitely more, but these are the top things for me.
I can say after using Android auto wireless on S10, S20 and latest kenwood unit every time I would get under toll gates it would disconnect, tried everything to fix this and nothing worked.
Tried it with my daughters XR iphone wireless CarPlay no disconnects no issues.
One of reasons I switched as well I wanted it to just work and start up once car is stated and music to play.

Android has come a long was as others said oneui is great but much more work is needed yet to get to Apple level.
 
My experience of android is via other peoples phones and gadgets, my own is through my android powered TVs, it's not something I would actively go out of my way to get or use, I recently cancelled interest in the Polestar 2 as it's in-car system is android.
Its a mess and feels like a really good hobby of someone, or a group of people, no unified goal or level of quality.
 
Nah. I’m definitely drinking the Apple kool-aid. I love the way all my Apple products work together, and I also turn off anything I can that tracks me (although I’m sure I still have some things that do), have most location services off, etc.

I know I can’t escape it fully while using a smart device of any kind, but I do my best.
 
After many years with Apple I am now preparing to go to a S20+

I could take the continuous increase in price and lower spec due to the simplicity, service and camera quality of Apple, but I think now things are at a tipping point.

The S20+ is such a beautiful well balanced device, super fast, lovely screen, great camera, excellent battery and even a SD card upgrade if you need the storage. Plus of course it starts at 128gb which is much more reasonable.

The final straw has been some controversial donations Apple has made. I don't expect a tech company to take a political stance on my behalf thank you
 
I wouldn't as the max useable life for an Android Phone seems to be two to three years whereas iOS is five.
 
Would you ever switch to Android?
At this point: NO, I'd rather go to a dumb phone than an Andriod based one.

What would have to change to that:
- Google and its resellers/repackagers would have to adopt a whole different approach to privacy (almost the opposite of what they stand for now)
- A far more clean install default to start from, without all the crud added on top by the maker of the hardware
- A far more aggressive upgrade of the OS stance, including all the resellers/repackagers to actively support their stuff on the newest OS version all the time.
- An app store that is at least as strict as Apple's, preferably even more so, and no way to avoid the app store to start with.
- A far more uniform way of doing things. I've had the unfortunate task to help a few Android users in the past. So yes, you figure out how to configure corporate email on one of them, and you think the next Android will work the same: NOPE, even the menus are hidden in different spots.

+

- Apple would have to drop the ball badly.
 
I've been fortunate enough over the years to impulse buy most all new Android Phones when released, I've had way too much of this crap honestly and I'm done wasting money. It seems I'm always enticed by the hardware I see Android manufacturers creating. I've always wished that iOS could run on some of this hardware, but that's just a dream. No matter what I always end up back on an iPhone. Android just can't touch iOS in all the areas that are important to a modern smartphone IMO. Two things literally off the top of my head: Battery optimization & Smoothness of UI, I could go on all day. If I absolutely had to use Android for some reason it would be a Pixel, I admittedly mostly enjoyed using a Pixel 4 as a daily but there is just too much sacrifice to continue using it. So, my final is answer is no! LOL
 
I wouldn't as the max useable life for an Android Phone seems to be two to three years whereas iOS is five.
I'm sitting here in my living room with an iPhone 3GS, an iPhone 4, an iPhone 4s, an iPhone 5, an iPhone 6s and an iPhone 6s+. All of which work. PS, my daughter uses an iPhone 5 on an active line as her primary phone.

I think you may need to revise your max useable life criteria for the iPhone. ;)

Also, right next to my Android phone is my 2009 HTC Touch Pro. Granted, it's WinMo and not Android, but it is 11 years old and still functioning.
 
After many years with Apple I am now preparing to go to a S20+

I could take the continuous increase in price and lower spec due to the simplicity, service and camera quality of Apple, but I think now things are at a tipping point.

The S20+ is such a beautiful well balanced device, super fast, lovely screen, great camera, excellent battery and even a SD card upgrade if you need the storage. Plus of course it starts at 128gb which is much more reasonable.

The final straw has been some controversial donations Apple has made. I don't expect a tech company to take a political stance on my behalf thank you

I’m with you on that last part, but unfortunately, they all do it. I’m typically one to stop giving my money to companies that support things I don’t stand for, but since so many do these days, it’s difficult to know what to do. I’ve decided maybe I’ll just buy used as much as possible. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: colonelbutt
Not unless something drastic happens. Last time we tried was for S8+ shortly after launch. They still drug their feet on updates so we came back to Apple again. And now they are adding more features I like from Android, so there is less reason to want to switch.
 
Sometimes I like the things that they are doing, however, to be totally honest I'm too embedded into the Apple ecosystem now (not that that is a bad thing). I also really like what Apple "appears" to be doing on the privacy and security front.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.