Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Praise lord the priest is here. I take back what I say about lynching you and throwing your body out as an offering to our local night dwellers.

Bring on the answer, we've got hunting to do.
[cue scene of me loading a bandolier up with progressively larger and more outlandish weaponry until I finally keel over, stuck turtle like on top a large rocket launcher. "Help please."]
 
Last edited:
As mscriv chanted the prayer to the gods, the clear skies started to turn pitch black. No one had ever seen dark skies in the middle of broad daylight.

Thunder and lighting could be seen and heard from the now furious skies. Winds picked up and the villager coward ravenvii ran behind iBlue's bakery stand.

Three brave villagers joined in with the Priest. They joined by hands asked the favor from the gods.

"Hear my plea almighty Gods! Hear ME!!!!" shouted mscriv a top of his lungs. "Are our friends NathanMuir, jimN, Plutonius, Stonyc, Rodimus Prime, and moyank24 faithful to our cause and village?"

A figured appeared in the sky. Formed by clouds and light. Such figure had the shape of a spaghetti plate and two meatballs on it's sides. However, before the deity could answer, another god in a rapid swop ate the deity away.

This new deity turned to the now frightened villagers and proclaimed "No! Now bow down to me!" However, before anything was done, Jav6454 and Intell together speared the new deity into death. Such rapid fight did nothing but throw in more lightning and thunder. Both in unison proclaimed "Oh MRVille of our dreams, keep the fight. For your time is nigh. Take warning of our ex-fellow god's answer."

The figures started vanishing. The darkness started lifting and the prayer had just been answered amidst a War of Gods.


The Gods answered No to the Priests question. Deadline is 11PM Central time. Read below because why the change.



Side note - I'm extending voting time to 11:00 PM Central. This way you can all have time to debate on who to kill. Also, this is given as a bonus from me not answering sooner. Please note, I will have three deaths besides the lynchee due to inactivity. This was already stated before. Roles will NOT be reassigned. Questions, a PM will suffice. Happy Hunting!

EDIT - PLEASE see post #627 for details...
 
Last edited:
I was posting and I kept getting interrupted at work so I was never able to submit before Jav's post.

I was afraid that 6 was too many people, especially as I was a name on the list. The chances that 0/6 would all be clear was just too small. Now we have to a longer list to thread through to try and find the baddie.
 
With us 6 cleared, 3 dead and mscriv known to be uninfectable that leaves 9 to choose from. 3 of those are going to get booted for inactivity, question is do we vote for one of them to minimise our losses or allow them to go to minimise our pool of potential suspects?

I'm holding on Cboss for now as he is dead anyway and I haven't had many doubts about the others.
 
Well, the answer is kind of cryptic, but I think I got it right. I asked:

Gracious gods of our realm, it is with a heavy heart that I ask, is there an evil minion amongst these six listed villagers?

Jav appears to have rephrased the question to say:

"Are our friends NathanMuir, jimN, Plutonius, Stonyc, Rodimus Prime, and moyank24 faithful to our cause and village?"

....

The Gods answered yes to the Priests question.


So, I interpret that to mean, "Yes, they are faithful to our village", meaning no there is not a baddie amongst them.

Is that how you guys see it as well?
 
Well, the answer is kind of cryptic, but I think I got it right. I asked:



Jav appears to have rephrased the question to say:



So, I interpret that to mean, "Yes, they are faithful to our village", meaning no there is not a baddie amongst them.

Is that how you guys see it as well?


wow, I honestly didn't even notice. I'm kind of an idiot. That's what I get for trying to multitask while at work. But rereading, it appears there are no baddies.

Like I said, 6 was the perfect number. :D
 
Well, the answer is kind of cryptic, but I think I got it right. I asked:



Jav appears to have rephrased the question to say:



So, I interpret that to mean, "Yes, they are faithful to our village", meaning no there is not a baddie amongst them.

Is that how you guys see it as well?

The way he worded it, I don't see any other answer than yes. You got the answer you were hoping for. *prepares to die of dysentery*
 
So, here's where we stand then:

Player List
1. Melkorr - ???
2. jimN - cleared by priests prayer
3. Mexbearpig - Lynched, was a Werewolf
4. Melrose - ???
5. Don't Panic - Lynched, villager
6. chrmjenkins - will be lost to inactivity
7. stonyc - cleared by priests prayer
8. -aggie- - ???
9. ravenvii - ???
10. NathanMuir - cleared by priests prayer
11. Appleguy123 - dead, half his body hanging froma rope due to a WW. (possible executioner)
12. mscriv - the handsome, brave, wise, compassionate, and eloquent priest
13. CBoss - ???
14. iBlue - ???
15. philbeeney - will be lost to inactivity
16. Rodimus Prime - cleared by priests prayer
17. renewed - will be lost to inactivity
18. Plutonius - cleared by priests prayer
19. Moyank24 - cleared by priests prayer

We must assume that Mexbearpig infected someone and if so we are looking for 3 baddies (2 WW's and 1 vamp) amongst a list of 6 people. 50/50 odds are pretty good.

The challenge in this game is going to be finding the vampire before he/she turns a villager. However, it's possible that someone was turned last night.

EDIT:
I apologize, but I don't have a strong feeling yet about who among the remaining 6 is a baddie. As the priest I was focusing all of my deductive skills on looking for clues that people were innocent since I knew that's how I wanted to use the prayer. I'll now start looking over things to find clues about potential baddies. Hopefully the secret society and the seer will be of great help now as we proceed. The undertaker will also be important due to us losing 4 total players at the next lynching.
 
Last edited:
Good job picking who to ask the question about mscriv. This should help the village out a lot if the vampire doesn't infect someone in that list.

I'm just a normal villager so I can't prove the I'm a good guy. I still think ravenvii has a good chance of being a baddie, I think the seer should scan ravenvii tonight.

@ executioner and sorcerer: I'm not a huge help to the village but fill free to bring me back after I'm lynched today. :)
 
Thanks Mscriv, that makes it all seem a lot clearer.

Assuming we have no baddies leaving through inactivity there could be as many as 4 beasties amongst those 6 and we'll be left with 9 active goodies from after the lynching (potentially losing 2 overnight if we don't manage to snag someone).

Of the 6 that are left it's pretty tough to call. Melkorr has been pretty helpful in terms of trying to spot baddies, iBlue has been predominantly obsessed with pastries, aggie and melrose have been themselves, Cboss has been pretty quiet and Ravenii has been very random and then became somewhat inactive.

Based on that appraisal of things I'm going to move my vote to Ravenii and I think we need the seer to start looking through that group. I'm pretty confident that we've both hunters still in play so 2 individuals can be protected indefinitely if special roles need to be looked after. I'd say we're well placed to wrap this up in a couple of days.
 
So, here's where we stand then:

...
12. mscriv - the handsome, brave, wise, compassionate, and eloquent priest
I see what you did there. ;)

There is a better than even chance that one of chrmjenkins, philbeeney, or renewed is going to be a baddie I think... so there's a good chance that we'll have just two baddies to deal with after the next lynching.

Among Melkorr, Melrose, -aggie-, ravenvii, CBoss and iBlue, I don't have any strong reads on them one way or the other. But my intuition says there are two baddies possibly hidden among them.
 
There is a better than even chance that one of chrmjenkins, philbeeney, or renewed is going to be a baddie I think... so there's a good chance that we'll have just two baddies to deal with after the next lynching.

Do you really think so? Jav said people that are sending him PM's are still active whether they actually post or not. This would lead me to believe that it is unlikely any of them could be either a WW or the original vampire because those roles are consistently sending PM's. It could be that one of them was turned by the vampire last night and that they were just keeping a low profile.

However, I find it difficult to think that a first time storyteller like Jav would stick to his guns and take out a baddie in such a situation as opposed to finding a compromise. This leads me to think that there are probably no baddies in that list as taking out a baddie due to inactivity in the first game with an inactivity rule instituted would be highly controversial. I could easily be wrong and there might be a whole mess of PM's flying around arguing about this behind the scenes.

I tend to think the players getting eliminated probably had more minor roles if not just simple villagers and that being the case it was easier for them to get distracted and miss the deadline. It is a busy time of year for most. As usual, all will be revealed in the end.
 
Well, I have to admit that once I found out I was being kicked out for inactivity, I felt bad. Not for me, but for the village. I've tried to make it up with what time I have, but unfortunately the only information I can give you is that Melrose is a plain ol' villager. Yup, I'm the seer. Was trying to lay low and forgot about time limit. Sorry guys, but you can eliminate him from your immediate lynching tonight.
 
Melrose changed his message #620 when he realized it was too revealing :). Melrose is an infected WW,

Or you're riding high by supposedly being cleared by joining mscriv's prayer, which really doesn't make sense.

I told you, I am the seer and Melrose is a villager. Don't believe me? You'll see that you lost me as a villager and him as a villager if you hang him. Then your head should number 1 on the chopping block.

Your choice.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.