Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The only reason why I'd change my vote to Ucfgrad/comagain? would be scepticalscribe scanning Koodauw the next night since Koodauw is more contributing than the other two. But since I can't know what ss is doing and if she even survives the night (fingers crossed) it's up to Roric. You may be the executioner. :D

I have zero ideas about who's the RedMan so no real preferences.
 
Well, ain't this special! By my count we have a 5-5-2 vote count. Since majority lock is 7, my vote will not completely condemn anyone, but could push someone to the forefront.

Do I vote for Koodauw or Comeagain? and let someone else switch to lock the majority? Or do I vote for someone else and try to convince everyone else that I am right? With a deadline over 14 hours away this could be a long grueling day, unless we lock before the esteemed chrmjenkins starts work and he decides to post the next narrative before his day long meeting.

Although Scepticalscribe was wrong yesterday, I will follow once again and vote for Koodauw, mostly because twietee seems to have a plan to find those traitors.

So did any of you really read what I wrote or did you just skip to the bold?
 
The only reason why I'd change my vote to Ucfgrad/comagain? would be scepticalscribe scanning Koodauw the next night since Koodauw is more contributing than the other two. But since I can't know what ss is doing and if she even survives the night (fingers crossed) it's up to Roric. You may be the executioner. :D

I have zero ideas about who's the RedMan so no real preferences.

I feel the same way - I've not really suspected comeagain? as much but maybe that's because he's been way under the radar. So if he's a bad guy, it's working. I've always assumed that bad guys will at least make some effort so they don't get killed for being too quiet - but my assumptions have been wrong more than once.

I'm more inclined to switch to ucfgrad, just because of how the votes came down yesterday. Just think it may give more info.
 
mostly because twietee seems to have a plan to find those traitors.

Suuuuure. I've got it all figured out.

dog_with_glasses_tie_pipe_zpse28a9dcb.jpg


----------

I'm more inclined to switch to ucfgrad, just because of how the votes came down yesterday. Just think it may give more info.

Deal? ucfgrad. Edit: But voting info would suggest he wasn't the RedMan, wouldn't it? Back to Koodauw...pheww, that was close!
 
Hm. The latest (lost) votes of Comeagain?would fit within the role of the RedMan actually since he, the RedMan, knows the other two Traitors but not vice versa. Have to have another, closer look again at the last two days before final decision. ucfgrad93 again for the moment to avoid majority lock.
 
Very well; I'll readily concede that both Koodauw and Comeagain? are each pf them individuals whom I would like to see scrutinised a little more closely.

However, from what I have been able to observe, it seems to me that an old and rather experienced hand is driving some of these moves.

Thus, for now, Koodauw....

After careful review of posts, this strikes me as good reasoning. Thus for the first time this game, I'm changing my vote to Koodauw

Anyone who has played with me as a traitor knows when I have I role I am very detailed orientated. I clarify anything I need with the GG. When I am a villager, I usually die within the first few days, which is why I didn't put in a lot of effort for the first few days. When I was alive I began thinking and had questions. I would not have asked all those questions if I was a traitor.

I will say it just once, I am only a pheasant. If you choose to lynch me so be it.

This sounds fairly desperate to me.

Koodauw, since I know I'm not a traitor, but I don't know about Koodauw. He's been a good wolf in the past, and knows this game well.

That is very true.

If you want to look for someone with cunning expertise, I do not believe UCFgrad93 is new to these games.

I have played a couple of times in the past, but I'm not a regular to these games. I haven't played the last few times they have happened.
 
Although Scepticalscribe was wrong yesterday, I will follow once again and vote for Koodauw, mostly because twietee seems to have a plan to find those traitors.

As you can see Twietee having a plan is probably about the furthest thing from the truth, but I do thank him for his most recent vote change. Its a step in the right direction.

I have to say one thing the village can benefit from in this case is willingness to change votes. You can see what happens when every just locks in. (IE Costabunny.)

And to SS, who I know is away from the thread, a lynching of myself will only bring you a greyed out post with lots of taunting from your former cohort.
 
Phesants do have a somewhat reddish plumage, right? Tempted to switch back to Koodauw..
 
You can see what happens when every just locks in. (IE Costabunny.)
Of course you would, because you only hop on whatever train is going at the moment.

Funny that you've mentioned costabunny, because it was you who jumped last on said train while I must have missed that somehow completely and voted for you instead.
That was Day4, an interesting day because it was the last day before we narrowed down the list of potential Traitors (except the Sneak) quite down a bit thanks to the impact of SilentPanda and woodNUFC. The voting record of this day makes me actually believe you two, Koodauw and Comeagain?, plotted together, what makes it unlikely that one of you really is the RedMan. Not sure if we shouldn't hang one of you two still.

Edit:
@ Roric "You have received a beump on the head." :)
 
Last edited:
Some interesting overnight changes. I was about to put up a finally vote tally but then I re-read the deadline and it's 8PM not 8AM like I was thinking when I got up so we still have another 11 and 1/2 hours to majority lock Koodauw our change or minds.

Potential Traitors
Koodauw: 6 Moyank24, Scepticalscribe, rick snagwell, Comeagain?, Roric, ucfgrad93
comeagain?: 4 ravenvii, FenrisMoonlight, Sythas, WoodNUFC
ucfgrad93: 3 Koodauw, Queen of Spades, twietee

Accusations
Post 1032 rick snagwell accused ucfgrad93
Post 1043 twietee accused Koodauw
Post 1044 FenrisMoonlight accused comeagain?
Post 1045 ucfgrad93 accused comeagain?
Post 1049 FenrisMoonlight accused twietee replacing previous accusation in post 1044 for comeagain?
Post 1051 Moyank24 accused Koodauw
Post 1053 ravenvii accused comeagain?
Post 1054 Scepticalscribe accused Koodauw
Post 1055 rick snagwell accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1032 for ucfgrad93
Post 1057 Queen of Spades accused Koodauw
Post 1059 Koodauw accused ucfgrad93
Post 1060 FenrisMoonlight accused comeagain? replacing previous accusation in post 1049 for twietee
Post 1064 Sythas accused comeagain?
Post 1065 WoodNUFC accused comeagain?
Post 1068 Comeagain? accused Koodauw
Post 1073 Queen of Spades accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1057 for Koodauw
Post 1077 Roric accused Koodauw
Post 1079 twietee accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1043 for Koodauw
Post 1081 twietee accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1079 for Koodauw
Post 1082 ucfgrad93 accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1045 for comeagain?

FenrisMoonlight - Squire in service to the King's Justice
 
Funny that you've mentioned costabunny, because it was you who jumped last on said train while I must have missed that somehow completely and voted for you instead.
That was Day4, an interesting day because it was the last day before we narrowed down the list of potential Traitors (except the Sneak) quite down a bit thanks to the impact of SilentPanda and woodNUFC. The voting record of this day makes me actually believe you two, Koodauw and Comeagain?, plotted together, what makes it unlikely that one of you really is the RedMan. Not sure if we shouldn't hang one of you two still.

Edit:
@ Roric "You have received a beump on the head." :)

I am deffo starting to get the gist of this game now. :) The plot does thicken after a few days.
 
Funny that you've mentioned costabunny, because it was you who jumped last on said train while I must have missed that somehow completely and voted for you instead.

Apples and oranges.

jimN I feel your pain ;)
 
Last edited:
Apples and oranges.

jimN I feel you're pain ;)

Not as much as he does, I'll wager.

Just now, I am quite literally straddling two continents, and shall be airborne for several hours again tomorrow. However, a brief opportunity has presented itself to attend to arrears of correspondence and catch up by paying a fleeting visit to our very own Game of Thrones.

Yes, of course I have erred, as have we all.

However, death grants one a fresh perspective on life. While I regret the unjust demise of those whom I have helped kill, each name removed from the pool makes it easier to successfully identify the miscreants who remain. Put simply, as dictatorships down the ages have argued, sometimes the common good requires individual.......sacrifice.....

In the absence of revelations, scans, evidence and logic, reducing those who remain by dint of lynching or slaughter means that the miscreants become easier to find, and deal with. A crude cudgel of an argument, I grant, lacking the finesse of anything elegant......but it is all I have.

So, to stir things a little, I shall focus my spotlight elsewhere for now: ucfgrad93
 
Lady scepticalscribe I'll join with ucfgrad to tie him to Koodauw.

----------

Potential Traitors
Koodauw: 5 Moyank24, rick snagwell, Comeagain?, Roric, ucfgrad93
ucfgrad93: 5 Koodauw, Queen of Spades, twietee, Scepticalscribe, FenrisMoonlight
comeagain?: 3 ravenvii, Sythas, WoodNUFC


Accusations
Post 1032 rick snagwell accused ucfgrad93
Post 1043 twietee accused Koodauw
Post 1044 FenrisMoonlight accused comeagain?
Post 1045 ucfgrad93 accused comeagain?
Post 1049 FenrisMoonlight accused twietee replacing previous accusation in post 1044 for comeagain?
Post 1051 Moyank24 accused Koodauw
Post 1053 ravenvii accused comeagain?
Post 1054 Scepticalscribe accused Koodauw
Post 1055 rick snagwell accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1032 for ucfgrad93
Post 1057 Queen of Spades accused Koodauw
Post 1059 Koodauw accused ucfgrad93
Post 1060 FenrisMoonlight accused comeagain? replacing previous accusation in post 1049 for twietee
Post 1064 Sythas accused comeagain?
Post 1065 WoodNUFC accused comeagain?
Post 1068 Comeagain? accused Koodauw
Post 1073 Queen of Spades accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1057 for Koodauw
Post 1077 Roric accused Koodauw
Post 1079 twietee accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1043 for Koodauw
Post 1081 twietee accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1079 for Koodauw
Post 1082 ucfgrad93 accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1045 for comeagain?
Post 1091 Scepticalscribe accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1054 for Koodauw
Post 1092 FenrisMoonlight accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1060 for comeagain?
 
Not as much as he does, I'll wager.

Just now, I am quite literally straddling two continents, and shall be airborne for several hours again tomorrow. However, a brief opportunity has presented itself to attend to arrears of correspondence and catch up by paying a fleeting visit to our very own Game of Thrones.

Yes, of course I have erred, as have we all.

However, death grants one a fresh perspective on life. While I regret the unjust demise of those whom I have helped kill, each name removed from the pool makes it easier to successfully identify the miscreants who remain. Put simply, as dictatorships down the ages have argued, sometimes the common good requires individual.......sacrifice.....

In the absence of revelations, scans, evidence and logic, reducing those who remain by dint of lynching or slaughter means that the miscreants become easier to find, and deal with. A crude cudgel of an argument, I grant, lacking the finesse of anything elegant......but it is all I have.

So, to stir things a little, I shall focus my spotlight elsewhere for now: ucfgrad93

Lady scepticalscribe I'll join with ucfgrad to tie him to Koodauw.

----------

Potential Traitors
Koodauw: 5 Moyank24, rick snagwell, Comeagain?, Roric, ucfgrad93
ucfgrad93: 5 Koodauw, Queen of Spades, twietee, Scepticalscribe, FenrisMoonlight
comeagain?: 3 ravenvii, Sythas, WoodNUFC


Accusations
Post 1032 rick snagwell accused ucfgrad93
Post 1043 twietee accused Koodauw
Post 1044 FenrisMoonlight accused comeagain?
Post 1045 ucfgrad93 accused comeagain?
Post 1049 FenrisMoonlight accused twietee replacing previous accusation in post 1044 for comeagain?
Post 1051 Moyank24 accused Koodauw
Post 1053 ravenvii accused comeagain?
Post 1054 Scepticalscribe accused Koodauw
Post 1055 rick snagwell accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1032 for ucfgrad93
Post 1057 Queen of Spades accused Koodauw
Post 1059 Koodauw accused ucfgrad93
Post 1060 FenrisMoonlight accused comeagain? replacing previous accusation in post 1049 for twietee
Post 1064 Sythas accused comeagain?
Post 1065 WoodNUFC accused comeagain?
Post 1068 Comeagain? accused Koodauw
Post 1073 Queen of Spades accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1057 for Koodauw
Post 1077 Roric accused Koodauw
Post 1079 twietee accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1043 for Koodauw
Post 1081 twietee accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1079 for Koodauw
Post 1082 ucfgrad93 accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1045 for comeagain?
Post 1091 Scepticalscribe accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1054 for Koodauw
Post 1092 FenrisMoonlight accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1060 for comeagain?

back to where i started this day! ucfgrad93
 
ok since Rick's vote saves Koodauw, lets recreate the tie and see what others do.

----------

Potential Traitors
ucfgrad93: 5 Koodauw, Queen of Spades, twietee, Scepticalscribe, rick snagwell
Koodauw: 5 Moyank24, Comeagain?, Roric, ucfgrad93, FenrisMoonlight
comeagain?: 3 ravenvii, Sythas, WoodNUFC


Accusations
Post 1032 rick snagwell accused ucfgrad93
Post 1043 twietee accused Koodauw
Post 1044 FenrisMoonlight accused comeagain?
Post 1045 ucfgrad93 accused comeagain?
Post 1049 FenrisMoonlight accused twietee replacing previous accusation in post 1044 for comeagain?
Post 1051 Moyank24 accused Koodauw
Post 1053 ravenvii accused comeagain?
Post 1054 Scepticalscribe accused Koodauw
Post 1055 rick snagwell accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1032 for ucfgrad93
Post 1057 Queen of Spades accused Koodauw
Post 1059 Koodauw accused ucfgrad93
Post 1060 FenrisMoonlight accused comeagain? replacing previous accusation in post 1049 for twietee
Post 1064 Sythas accused comeagain?
Post 1065 WoodNUFC accused comeagain?
Post 1068 Comeagain? accused Koodauw
Post 1073 Queen of Spades accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1057 for Koodauw
Post 1077 Roric accused Koodauw
Post 1079 twietee accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1043 for Koodauw
Post 1081 twietee accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1079 for Koodauw
Post 1082 ucfgrad93 accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1045 for comeagain?
Post 1091 Scepticalscribe accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1054 for Koodauw
Post 1092 FenrisMoonlight accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1060 for comeagain?
Post 1093 rick snagwell accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1055 for Koodauw
Post 1094 FenrisMoonlight accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1092 for ucfgrad93
 
ok since Rick's vote saves Koodauw, lets recreate the tie and see what others do.

----------

Potential Traitors
ucfgrad93: 5 Koodauw, Queen of Spades, twietee, Scepticalscribe, rick snagwell
Koodauw: 5 Moyank24, Comeagain?, Roric, ucfgrad93, FenrisMoonlight
comeagain?: 3 ravenvii, Sythas, WoodNUFC


Accusations
Post 1032 rick snagwell accused ucfgrad93
Post 1043 twietee accused Koodauw
Post 1044 FenrisMoonlight accused comeagain?
Post 1045 ucfgrad93 accused comeagain?
Post 1049 FenrisMoonlight accused twietee replacing previous accusation in post 1044 for comeagain?
Post 1051 Moyank24 accused Koodauw
Post 1053 ravenvii accused comeagain?
Post 1054 Scepticalscribe accused Koodauw
Post 1055 rick snagwell accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1032 for ucfgrad93
Post 1057 Queen of Spades accused Koodauw
Post 1059 Koodauw accused ucfgrad93
Post 1060 FenrisMoonlight accused comeagain? replacing previous accusation in post 1049 for twietee
Post 1064 Sythas accused comeagain?
Post 1065 WoodNUFC accused comeagain?
Post 1068 Comeagain? accused Koodauw
Post 1073 Queen of Spades accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1057 for Koodauw
Post 1077 Roric accused Koodauw
Post 1079 twietee accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1043 for Koodauw
Post 1081 twietee accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1079 for Koodauw
Post 1082 ucfgrad93 accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1045 for comeagain?
Post 1091 Scepticalscribe accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1054 for Koodauw
Post 1092 FenrisMoonlight accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1060 for comeagain?
Post 1093 rick snagwell accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1055 for Koodauw
Post 1094 FenrisMoonlight accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1092 for ucfgrad93

Please understand that by doing so, if no one else votes, you are essentially sealing my fate. As, I do believe I reached the higher amount of votes first.
 
Please understand that by doing so, if no one else votes, you are essentially sealing my fate. As, I do believe I reached the higher amount of votes first.
Nope - since my vote bring you back up to 5, ucfgrad93 reached 5 while you were at 4 so you move up to tie him so he reached 5 first. Unless me and my voting script is misinterpreting the rules and the fact you had 5 votes much earlier means your in the lead now but I interpret as since you went down to 4, then back up to 5 once ucfgrad was at 5 then ucfgrad reached that 5 first. Someone with more experience of these games please correct me if I'm wrong and I'll modify the way my script works.

----------

I'm torn, but I respect the fight you're putting up. ucfgrad



Edit: ninja'd!!
And with those almost simultaneous votes we've hit majority lock. I make that the second day in a row you've majority locked someone's fate!

Majority Lock reached: Post: 1097 Moyank24 majority locked ucfgrad93

Potential Traitors
ucfgrad93: 7 Koodauw, Queen of Spades, twietee, Scepticalscribe, rick snagwell, ravenvii, Moyank24
Koodauw: 4 Comeagain?, Roric, ucfgrad93, FenrisMoonlight
comeagain?: 2 Sythas, WoodNUFC


Accusations
Post 1032 rick snagwell accused ucfgrad93
Post 1043 twietee accused Koodauw
Post 1044 FenrisMoonlight accused comeagain?
Post 1045 ucfgrad93 accused comeagain?
Post 1049 FenrisMoonlight accused twietee replacing previous accusation in post 1044 for comeagain?
Post 1051 Moyank24 accused Koodauw
Post 1053 ravenvii accused comeagain?
Post 1054 Scepticalscribe accused Koodauw
Post 1055 rick snagwell accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1032 for ucfgrad93
Post 1057 Queen of Spades accused Koodauw
Post 1059 Koodauw accused ucfgrad93
Post 1060 FenrisMoonlight accused comeagain? replacing previous accusation in post 1049 for twietee
Post 1064 Sythas accused comeagain?
Post 1065 WoodNUFC accused comeagain?
Post 1068 Comeagain? accused Koodauw
Post 1073 Queen of Spades accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1057 for Koodauw
Post 1077 Roric accused Koodauw
Post 1079 twietee accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1043 for Koodauw
Post 1081 twietee accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1079 for Koodauw
Post 1082 ucfgrad93 accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1045 for comeagain?
Post 1091 Scepticalscribe accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1054 for Koodauw
Post 1092 FenrisMoonlight accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1060 for comeagain?
Post 1093 rick snagwell accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1055 for Koodauw
Post 1094 FenrisMoonlight accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1092 for ucfgrad93
Post 1096 ravenvii accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1053 for comeagain?
Post 1097 Moyank24 accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1051 for Koodauw majority lock!

FenrisMoonlight - Squire in service to the King's Justice
 
Well, I'm away from MR for most of the afternoon/evening and we've reached majority lock.

Hopefully, SS can get the team a good scan tonight. I probably won't be alive to see the morning, so good luck to you loyalist out there!
 
Last edited:
Nope - since my vote bring you back up to 5, ucfgrad93 reached 5 while you were at 4 so you move up to tie him so he reached 5 first. Unless me and my voting script is misinterpreting the rules and the fact you had 5 votes much earlier means your in the lead now but I interpret as since you went down to 4, then back up to 5 once ucfgrad was at 5 then ucfgrad reached that 5 first. Someone with more experience of these games please correct me if I'm wrong and I'll modify the way my script works.

----------


And with those almost simultaneous votes we've hit majority lock. I make that the second day in a row you've majority locked someone's fate!

Majority Lock reached: Post: 1097 Moyank24 majority locked ucfgrad93

Potential Traitors
ucfgrad93: 7 Koodauw, Queen of Spades, twietee, Scepticalscribe, rick snagwell, ravenvii, Moyank24
Koodauw: 4 Comeagain?, Roric, ucfgrad93, FenrisMoonlight
comeagain?: 2 Sythas, WoodNUFC


Accusations
Post 1032 rick snagwell accused ucfgrad93
Post 1043 twietee accused Koodauw
Post 1044 FenrisMoonlight accused comeagain?
Post 1045 ucfgrad93 accused comeagain?
Post 1049 FenrisMoonlight accused twietee replacing previous accusation in post 1044 for comeagain?
Post 1051 Moyank24 accused Koodauw
Post 1053 ravenvii accused comeagain?
Post 1054 Scepticalscribe accused Koodauw
Post 1055 rick snagwell accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1032 for ucfgrad93
Post 1057 Queen of Spades accused Koodauw
Post 1059 Koodauw accused ucfgrad93
Post 1060 FenrisMoonlight accused comeagain? replacing previous accusation in post 1049 for twietee
Post 1064 Sythas accused comeagain?
Post 1065 WoodNUFC accused comeagain?
Post 1068 Comeagain? accused Koodauw
Post 1073 Queen of Spades accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1057 for Koodauw
Post 1077 Roric accused Koodauw
Post 1079 twietee accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1043 for Koodauw
Post 1081 twietee accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1079 for Koodauw
Post 1082 ucfgrad93 accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1045 for comeagain?
Post 1091 Scepticalscribe accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1054 for Koodauw
Post 1092 FenrisMoonlight accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1060 for comeagain?
Post 1093 rick snagwell accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1055 for Koodauw
Post 1094 FenrisMoonlight accused Koodauw replacing previous accusation in post 1092 for ucfgrad93
Post 1096 ravenvii accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1053 for comeagain?
Post 1097 Moyank24 accused ucfgrad93 replacing previous accusation in post 1051 for Koodauw majority lock!

FenrisMoonlight - Squire in service to the King's Justice

We usually play that the first person to reach the higher amount is the person that dies. I don't know if first is considered earliest in the day (in this case me) or first between the two people tied. I guess you could argue it either way, and it is up to the GG, to specify.

Technically I would think the first between the two tied makes more sense but just my opinion.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.