Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

[WW] - They Live?! - GAME OVER - Villagers win!

my feeling on this was derived from last game, when we knew who was a wolf, you guys didnt vote on it, yet voted for other people.

we know we have one in that list...lets keep that on the backburner and see how they vote, won't that give us some great info once we see who dies?

----------
Plutonius said:
Koodauw, I think Twietee is a guy :p.

My list

Moyank, QoS, tweitee, Sceptical Scribe

Everyone else

Moyank was the first vote for Jav and didn't change her vote.
QoS was the only vote for Twietee and didn't change her vote.
Twietee voted for Plutonius then switched his vote to ravenvii (third vote).
SS was the second vote for Jav and didn't change her vote.

SS so they all have at least one vote.

Why is Rick voting for "Don't Panic" ? Change your vote to one of the four people in Koodauw's question.
Click to expand...

so i will change to moyank, my day one vote. just cuz pluto thinks so.

and twietee is a women, when will everyone rememeber?
 
this comes a bit late, but i was looking back at the rules and it doesn't seem to specify anywhere the exact final make-up of the Bitten.

is it Alpha+kami+1 normal zombie? so 3 initial + 1 potential infected. plus the possible 'traitor' role (morpher)?
is this a correct assumption?

on a separate note, i can't update the spreadsheet properly yet, but will try tonight. then from monday my schedule/location is back to normal
 
Don't panic said:
this comes a bit late, but i was looking back at the rules and it doesn't seem to specify anywhere the exact final make-up of the Bitten.

is it Alpha+kami+1 normal zombie? so 3 initial + 1 potential infected. plus the possible 'traitor' role (morpher)?
is this a correct assumption?

on a separate note, i can't update the spreadsheet properly yet, but will try tonight. then from monday my schedule/location is back to normal
Click to expand...

Yes.
 
right now we have 13 players remaining.
of these, 3 are certainly Bittens, plus possibly 1 or two more depending on whether the Infection has been used, and whether the Morpher was in play AND became traitor (unlikely but not impossible).
if we exclude those two possibilities, we have 3/13 baddies (23%).
the odds to catch a baddie in the oracle's least are AT LEAST 1/4 or 25%.
a slightly better chance, but not by a much.
if you consider it from a non-bitten who is not in the list the odds become 3/12 (13-self), so back to 25%.
if you are an innocent villager in the list, than the odds are (at least) 1/3, or 33%.

if anyone in the list can clear themselves (if it is reasonable to do so), then the odds to vote within the list improve.

in other words, there is a minor advantage, right now, to vote for one of the 4 in the oracle list, but it is very tiny, so it is not unreasonable to vote out of the list.

that said, i do not endorse rick switching his vote back to me ;)
 
Queen of Spades said:
Why do you guys always insist on separating us by gender? You know we're not all automatically in cahoots because we have boobs, right? That said, I am not infected. But that does narrow it down quite a bit.

Leaning toward twietee again, maybe it was a lucky first guess.
Click to expand...

Because you're more fun when you get riled up. ;)

Ill vote for twietee.
 
Last edited:
Queen of spades (3) : Don't Panic, Twietee, Ufcgrad93
Twietee (3) : ScepticalScribe, Koodauw, Sythas
Moyank24 (2) : Jav6454, Rick Snagwell
ScepticalScribe (1) : Plutonius


Still to vote : Moyank24, Queen of spades, Ravenvii, Appleguy123


I updated the spreadsheet, but without color and everything

It's true that the oracle give us 3 more days of voting like the first day.

But if the oracle ask the question privately, in conjonction with a nightwatch, that could be very powerful tho...
 
We have until Monday theoretically, so lets not rush to lock. I'd like to hear from everyone before that happens. I'll be using my vote to save myself should it come to that.
 
Queen of Spades said:
Okay, based on what? I am fairly convinced of Moyank's innocence, but unsure on anyone else (outside of myself that is).

And now I'm really off for a bit.
Click to expand...

SS knows how to play wolf. She would have taken out Dont Panic on the first night. The fact that they (wolves) took out Tomorrow, means they (wolves) are not guided by someone with much wolf experience.

That's my spin on it.
 
jav6454 said:
SS knows how to play wolf. She would have taken out Dont Panic on the first night. The fact that they (wolves) took out Tomorrow, means they (wolves) are not guided by someone with much wolf experience.

That's my spin on it.
Click to expand...

Don't panic is nearly always killed night 1 which means he's also usually protected night 1. As happened last game, killing him night 2 makes a lot more sense.
 
Queen of Spades said:
Don't panic is nearly always killed night 1 which means he's also usually protected night 1. As happened last game, killing him night 2 makes a lot more sense.
Click to expand...

True. Which proves my point on SS. She is just talk, very eloquent talk, but nonetheless talk. I hardly think she'd be able to break bone as such.

But like I said, that's my take from past experiences in these games.
 
jav6454 said:
True. Which proves my point on SS. She is just talk, very eloquent talk, but nonetheless talk. I hardly think she'd be able to break bone as such.

But like I said, that's my take from past experiences in these games.
Click to expand...

I'm not sure how that proves your point - she's smart and experienced enough to know that DP is normally protected on night 1.

Nonetheless, the Queen's hunch about me is correct, so I'm going to follow her and vote Twietee.
 
mwa said:
What on earth are these games? Is it like Mafia?
Click to expand...

It's like Mafia but much better :). Check out some of the older WW game threads and follow this one to see if you would be interested in playing in any future WW games.

jav6454 said:
To be fair, I doubt it'd be SS.
Click to expand...

At least one of the four is a WW and none of them are cleared yet.

Queen of Spades said:
I am fairly convinced of Moyank's innocence
Click to expand...

I'm not sure where that is coming from ? I have read nothing in any of her post or seen anything in her voting that would clear her. I realize you like to team up with her most games (within the rules) but, she hasn't been cleared.
 
I think it's chrmjenkins. *Looks in his general direction while rubbing chin pensively and eating a PopTart.*
 
Moyank24 said:
I'm not sure how that proves your point - she's smart and experienced enough to know that DP is normally protected on night 1.

Nonetheless, the Queen's hunch about me is correct, so I'm going to follow her and vote Twietee.
Click to expand...

It really doesn't prove my point. I'm just sure to certain extent. Of course it can come back and bite/kill me later.

I'm just stating a fact that to me is true but not everyone might agree. I'm curious though on QoS post of how she is certain it's not Moyank. I'd like to hear more about that before removing my vote for moyank.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back