Originally postyed by Jeff Harrel
I stand by my challenge. If somebody can find me a program for Linux that is (1) equivalent in a meaningful way to iTunes or iPhoto, and (2) actually functional, not one of those "in development hell" things, I will... well, we can talk about the actual, literal terms later. Suffice it to say that I declare there are no such applications.
Let's look at what iTunes and iPhoto do.
iTunes plays MP3, AAC, AIFF, and WAV files. But that's just the tip of the iceberg. It's also an encoder for all of those formats, but that's not all either. It's a complete library management system, capable of storing, indexing, and organizing literally tens of thousands of audio files. (Maybe more than that, with version 4.) Playlists, smart playlists, automatic organization of the music library, Rendezvous sharing, and most importantly disc burning. Find me a Linux application that can even come close to this. (All of this is, of course, ignoring the iTunes Music Store. There's nothing else like that anywhere in the world, on any platform. And it's only available through iTunes.)
iPhoto is similar. It interfaces with your digital camera (this alone is worth the price of admission), downloads the photos, and displays them. It also arranges them by roll and various user-entered and automatic metadata. You can select photos and publish them directly to the web. You can order prints with just a couple of mouse clicks. You can create slideshows (with music from your iTunes library) and export them straight into iDVD, for crying out loud! And, of course, like iTunes, you can burn CD's or DVD's with the push of a button. There is nothing like this for Linux.
This epitomizes the entire issue. If you look at iTunes and say "MP3 player" or iPhoto and say "picture catalog," you're not getting it. Same thing if you look at a Mac and say "expensive PC." You're just not getting it.