Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
A truly updated apres-Ive 13" or 14" MB (Pro/Air) with whizbang innards (remember? Apple used to make stuff like that once) would be great, but it'd be really fantastic if it could run on pre-Catalina.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Mercurian
“Low yields will be a temporary problem”- ROFLMAO...10nm is a dumpster fire and has been since its inception. Apple upgraded the 13” in 2019 with 8th Generation 15w and 28w U-Series CPUs and while the 28w was a 100MHz whiffle ball, the 15w update with Iris Plus 645 obviated any need for Apple to waste time with Ice Lake this year.

Intel is going to limp along with 14nm+++ad infinitum refinements using Comet Lake and whatever Lakes they still have left, while they string us along for as long as possible until they can get 7nm online. If they can get it online.

See this article - https://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/intel-10nm-ice-lake-test-benchmarks,6257.html - it looks as though they basically punted on making any unkind declarations towards Ice Lake at the end of the article. For sure, GEN 11 GPUs are where the majority of improvements are along with things exclusive to Ice Lake that aren’t being backported to any Coffee Lake, CFL-R ad nauseum updates because that’s about the only way to get people excited about Ice Lake. I’m sure that a small percentage of my knowledge has already shifted as Intel’s messaging on what Comet Lake or Tiger Lake will get in terms of refinements keeps shifting while some poor clown in Intel PR touches base with the fabs to see how good or bad production yields are since Intel refused to thrown in the towel on 10nm. At the same time, AMD is eating Intel’s lunch on 65w-110w TDP CPUs and even higher end than CPUs.

Battery gains are as much to do with Intel FINALLY including an LPDDR4/x DRAM controller along with some of the obvious process improvements with 10nm and IPC gains. One wonders how much this would have helped 14nm had Intel not tied the use of LPDDR4 to Cannon Lake/Ice Lake.

I expect Apple to take a wait and see attitude with respect to Ice Lake or to completely skip it as Intel has proven that they cannot admit they’ve bungled 10nm worse than Broadwell, which I did not think was humanly possible. Until now.
[automerge]1574108804[/automerge]

Are you still living in 2018 or something?
Overall, I think Apple did a great job with the 16" MBP but I'm gonna wait till Intel's Tiger Lake which is Intel's next major architecture change and is suppose to bring a host of improvements, the biggest being the utilization of Intel's Xe GPU. It's suppose to bring 1080p 60fps gaming to discrete GPUs. We should be seeing these in laptops 1H of 2021.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Zdigital2015
Shouldn't 2020 be the year of a "complete" redesign?

If that rumor is true, then there won't be a complete redesigned MBP because 16-inch is completely redesigned base on Apple's claim which is very disappointing.
 
If that rumor is true, then there won't be a complete redesigned MBP because 16-inch is completely redesigned base on Apple's claim which is very disappointing.
Think of it like the Porsche 911 of pro laptops => minor changes on the outside, major changes on the inside. Nothing wrong with that.
 
Think of it like the Porsche 911 of pro laptops => minor changes on the outside, major changes on the inside. Nothing wrong with that.

We are talking about MBP, not Porsche. Clearly, there were changes between each MBP since the original one. Despite what others saying, 16-inch MBP is more like 4th gen MBP.

Monitor: Slightly bigger and bezel-less design.
Keyboard: Technically, they went back to a scissor-type keyboard with some improvements. Nothing new.
CPU, RAM, Speaker, GPU: Apple always adds and changes GPU even for the same gen MBP. Nothing new also.
Touch bar: NOTHING NEW. Both ESC and Touch id was already separated from MacBook Air and they just added a short version of the touch bar.
Inside: If you compare with the previous MBP, there isnt any differences especially with the cooling system.

I seriously doubt that 16-inch MBP is fully changed MBP.
 
An 11" ipad pro would be ideal for me if it had a file manager and could connect to external drives.
The ones with USB-C... I'm thinking they meet your requirements - you can plug in external drives, and there's the Files app. I haven't paid enough attention to that corner of iOS though, so maybe it doesn't get you what you need. (I'd need a proper userland - /bin, /usr/bin, /usr/local, and such - and multiple terminal windows with bash, before I can even think of using an iPad Pro instead of a Mac.)
 
“Low yields will be a temporary problem”- ROFLMAO...10nm is a dumpster fire and has been since its inception. Apple upgraded the 13” in 2019 with 8th Generation 15w and 28w U-Series CPUs and while the 28w was a 100MHz whiffle ball, the 15w update with Iris Plus 645 obviated any need for Apple to waste time with Ice Lake this year.

Intel is going to limp along with 14nm+++ad infinitum refinements using Comet Lake and whatever Lakes they still have left, while they string us along for as long as possible until they can get 7nm online. If they can get it online.


Ice Lake parts that are a perfect fit for the 13” MBP are available *right now*, Dell is already shipping laptops with them. That means Intel is confident they will get yields up to acceptable levels to ship these things in volume, which is needed for them to be profitable. If they were not confident and instead planned to skip 10nm completely, they would not have partnered with a relatively big partner like Dell, for decently popular device like the XPS 2-in-1, but instead pushed them to stick with the 9th gen or 10th gen parts. If 10nm Ice Lake was ‘almost dead’ Intel would at best work with some unknown low-volume manufacturer, similar to what they did with the rare 10nm cannon lake i3 that was found in some Chinese laptops.

You are confusing the rumored skip to 7nm for their desktop parts and highest-end laptop parts. There will likely not be Ice Lake for these segments. Makes a lot of sense because at these power envelopes Ice Lake has fewer benefits, and typically they are used with separate dGPU so Gen11 graphics are irrelevant. By focusing completely on the ‘premium‘ ultraportable chips and selling them at higher margin Intel can at least recuperate some of the loss they incurred from their troubled 10nm process.

For the 13” MBP the currently shipping Ice Lake chips are perfect, and eliminate the biggest drawback of their 8th and 9th gen counterparts: the weak GPU. That, and the 16 GB LPDDR3 limitations. I’m 100% sure Apple will use them if Intel can supply them in volume. If they already gave up on that, they would have updated the 13” along with the 16” already.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: smulji
Why didn't they make Jony publicly apologize for the abomination that was the butterfly keyboard, like how they supposedly wanted Scott to apologize for the Apple Maps debacle, and then supposedly fired him because he wouldn't publicly apologize?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Saturn007
I went into Curry's last week to look at the size difference between the Macbook Pro 13 inch and 15 inch. When I noticed the 13 inch I thought it was tiny and wouldn't want it for daily usage. This is just my opinion though.
 
Give Lenovo 5 years, see how much disappointment comes your way. Hopefully not and you can enjoy yourself while the rest of us fanatics fondly say, “Remember that old crank, the Snail?” “Who?” “Never mind, he moved to Lenovo years ago and it was sort of therapeutic for him!” Don’t let the door hit you on the way out.
Lol defensive much?

I've been using Lenovo for the past 4 years and regret not having used them earlier, it's the best quality computers and service I've ever had.

There's only one problem with Lenovo computers: They don't run Mac OS [excluding hackintosh].

If Apple allowed Mac OS to be installed on other brand computers, I would have the PERFECT machine.
[automerge]1574121332[/automerge]
Why didn't they make Jony publicly apologize for the abomination that was the butterfly keyboard, like how they supposedly wanted Scott to apologize for the Apple Maps debacle, and then supposedly fired him because he wouldn't publicly apologize?
Him "leaving" was the apology.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Saturn007
Why would they not go to 14" is beyond me.

12" - Air
14" & 16" - Pro

Makes too much sense I guess.
 
What a relief..I might pick that new Macbook Air if it comes with GOOD keyboard.
I'm really suffering because of the AWFUL butterfly KB in my 12" Macbook.
so far,I had it serviced 3 times by Apple,last time was few months ago and they replaced the WHOLE KB and fron casing,the problem returned within a week! space key specially very hit and miss.
I give up taking it to Apple,they simply cannot do anything it was a design flaw.
so out of 3 space bar pushes at least 1 is missed and I have to edit.
seriously that's f-ed up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Already in use
Lol defensive much?

I've been using Lenovo for the past 4 years and regret not having used them earlier, it's the best quality computers and service I've ever had.

There's only one problem with Lenovo computers: They don't run Mac OS [excluding hackintosh].

If Apple allowed Mac OS to be installed on other brand computers, I would have the PERFECT machine.
[automerge]1574121332[/automerge]

Him "leaving" was the apology.
Or maybe him "leaving" was him quitting and saying "screw you" to Tim Cook for how he's running Apple.
 
I think they had to release the 16" now.

From my anecdotal experience, a lot of people have been holding on to older MacBooks because of the
keyboard and thermal design.

Even the company I work for has stopped offering new MacBooks to employees, we mostly get Lenovo.
These are obviously not that good, but I have to say the onsite support for us is amazing.

I hope that there is still a reasonable upgrade for WWDC, because the 16" as it is now is not the model I like to buy. The market is moving to quickly with ARM, RISC-V etc.

Also, I still believe that the port situation needs to change ... sorry but USB-C only is not the future.
So .... 6 month to go ... I can wait. The times to throw money at Apple are over for me.

PS: Written on a MacPro 3.1 from 2008 running ElCapitan.
 
Lol defensive much?

I've been using Lenovo for the past 4 years and regret not having used them earlier, it's the best quality computers and service I've ever had.

There's only one problem with Lenovo computers: They don't run Mac OS [excluding hackintosh].

If Apple allowed Mac OS to be installed on other brand computers, I would have the PERFECT machine.

Nope, not defensive at all, just tired of the utter lack of understanding on the part of people who cannot grasp or accept how Apple does things and then proceed to dispense advice on how Apple should do things that just aren’t going to happen in order to make them happy or else they are going to leave.

Such as Apple allowing macOS to run on non-Apple hardware.

I no longer care to evangelize Apple or macOS...if you don’t want to be here, go, there are plenty of alternatives out there. Go buy them and be happy.

For my part, I simply need to regain my self control and not waste time on people dwelling in fantasy land trying to get Apple to change for their particular set of self-entitlement. I simply don’t wield the block tool enough...

Live long and prosper!
 
I'm just going to buy a ThinkPad X395, AMD-based, 12" form factor but a 13.3" screen. Only 16GB RAM though, but at least Lenovo hasn't disappointed me on a consistent basis like Apple has for the past 5 years.

If I keep waiting for Apple to release a good quality computer that is reasonably priced, or allows me to do my own upgrades, I'd be able to claim being a victim of Stockholm syndrome.

Desires for the MBP:
  1. Physical function keys with the option to have the stupid POS touch bar for those fanatics who say "why do you need physical function keys". They can even charge more for that "privilege" to put the fanatics in line.
  2. Removable storage, so if the board craps out I don't lose all my data.
  3. I would like non-soldered RAM so I can cheaply upgrade my RAM, however the new memory prices are more...... fairly priced but still too expensive.
  4. SD Card Slot
  5. USB 3.1 ports in addition to USB C, even if only two and two.
I make enough money to waste it on the new MBP 16" and pay for a top of the line version, but just because I make that money doesn't mean I'm stupid enough to mindlessly throw it away, unlike lots of people here that say "Then don't buy it if it's too much." Those people should re-evaluate why they are so miserable.
You bought a ThinkPad X395 with soldered DRAM? Wait a minute, you’re lambasting Apple, but you bought a Lenovo with soldered DRAM? WTF?!?
 
Why didn't they make Jony publicly apologize for the abomination that was the butterfly keyboard, like how they supposedly wanted Scott to apologize for the Apple Maps debacle, and then supposedly fired him because he wouldn't publicly apologize?

Clearly they feel that the butterfly design has some merit, but still needs more work to survive in our dusty, dirty world. They operate perfectly in Apple's dust-free labs!
 
Why yes, since I cant wait to see a new design of a metal rectangle that has a screen, a keyboard, and a trackpad.

Forget about how it functions, I want to just gaze at the slightly modified angles and colors of the metal.

Redesigns have next to nothing to do with appearance.

Have you carried around a 2012 model recently?

The improvements are more about reduced weight and footprint.
[automerge]1574131708[/automerge]
If that rumor is true, then there won't be a complete redesigned MBP because 16-inch is completely redesigned base on Apple's claim which is very disappointing.

How much further can they go as far as design is concerned?

What would you have liked to be redesigned? It can’t get any thinner, nor can the footprint be made smaller.
 
Last edited:
A redesign would be great. Since it will be da second decade of the year. For the performance i doubt there will be major changes...
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.