Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
£5,769.00 for a laptop fully loaded! Are they crazy or just plain greedy. Even £2,799 for entry level is going to be too expensive for most. For that you can buy a 2nd car!

By the way, do you know how much an 8 TB SSD costs? Its between 2000 and 6000 Euros dude! Just the SSD!
 
Very much remains to be a consumer product that can be utilised by a minority professionally. I'll wait on 2020 as this is not the turning point by any means, if at all...

SSD's must be removable at a very minimum in order to consider the MBP as professional orientated notebook.

Q-6

You'd probably be well off to start looking at Dell then. Very unlikely we'll see removable SSD and RAM.

For SSD, with thunderbolt-3 external options available, there's little reason to upgrade the internal - and the wear issues are long past something to worry about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Detnator and Sikh
with Catalina you don’t need to worry about how it performs with games anyway.
[automerge]1573668625[/automerge]


So the new keyboard is a cost cutting exercise.
I am not just about gaming. I am also about 32-bit support and better legacy app compatibility. I care nothing much about catalyst project or play iPad games on a Mac, and I am not a big fan of using iPad apps to replace macOS native apps.

Anyway, just random rants.
 
Oh well, I think I'm in. I originally bought my current 2019, i9 2.3ghz 8 core, 32GB ram, 2TB SSD, Vega 20, because I knew the 16" would require Catalina and there'd be no way to go back to Mojave.. Sadly I have 100+ steam games and some audio apps that are 32 bit only and I didn't want to lose them...
However, get ready for this, the new one with ATI 5500M EIGHT GB, 32Gb ram, 2TB SSD and the 2.3ghz 8 core is *$400* Australian dollars cheaper! I can add the 9980HK to it and the new 16" is still around $70 cheaper, WITH an 8GB 5500M, than my setup above! That's just stupid so I would have to be an idiot to keep this and not return it. It will go into refurb and my sister who needs a new computer could even re buy it for a massive saving. Now, I DID get 5 percent off, so it was 5962 AUD vs 6259, and I have no idea if they would do that for me for the 16", but even if not, I will save 100 bucks just paying full price and getting the precise same processor, ram, storage I have now but with a very decent graphics card which means I could game at full HD at good frame rates.
I am really who shocked and surprised at the price difference, especially more so if I hadn't gotten that 5% off on the apple store phone for being a loyal customer.
So I only have 3 disappointments with the 16".. The 4 USBC ports are still no where near spaced enough, so much wasted room on the sides, the loss of all 32 bit app compatibility and I think they could have improved thermals more dramatically. At the end of the day, 12 watts heat dissipation improvement is a lot, and should enable the processor to sit at around 3.5ghz on all 8 cores when loaded, but they are still using a single shared heat pipe which is a bit bizarre. That said, the performance will get close enough to my base iMac pro that I could sell it now and just use the one computer for work and play...
In fact I think I'll load this up, 64GB ram, 4TB SSD and even the 9980HK..
I think even the 5300M is capable of HD gaming.. and it has 15 less watts of heat..The way to do that is to buy the 6 core then upgrade processor, ram etc and leave the GFX at the 5300M. That said, I will wait a few days for benchmarks to come out as well as thermal tests.. I have till next Wednesday to decide. I really did get it at the right time in that regard.
Right now, my 2.3ghz I9 can max out at about 3ghz all core turbo when under load.. far from the 4.1ghz capability of the chip. My iMac pro stays on the max all core turbo 3.9ghz without any throttling whatsoever on all 8 cores.. so if this new MacBook Pro can get close, why keep both computers.. I can still get 6K AUD for mine (it has 2TB SSD and 64GB ram), I'll spend 2K of that on a killer screen and have a 2 screen setup with the MacBook when in the music studio.
Lots to think about everyone! Cheers.

This is definitely one where you can upgrade yourself out of budget. I settled for starting with the top end model, upgrading to 32-gig and the top of the line graphics option. SSD isn't something that I could justify, especially with prices dropping on external options. 64-GB of ram is very tempting to future proof it - if it was $200 I'd have stretched budget, but couldn't scrape together enough to justify it.

I'd have traded the touchbar for that extra ram in a heartbeat.....

On the games, the only issue now is the lack of titles coming out for the mac. The move to metal, and the 32-bit cutoff have really whacked mac gaming bad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TTOZ
you gotta be kidding for saying that. did you even consider the ports etc?

They ain't coming back, Apple's far too arrogant to accept that one. Four ports that rely solely on dongle's is simply a joke, then again the MBP has been a joke since 2016 so what's new. Tell you what is W10 & Linux as that's where many independent professional's have switched to thx to Apple's piss poor design, reinforced with reduced reliability and bad decisions.

2020 we'll see, new 2019 16" MBP is just stopgap as the 15" MBP was simply a mess. Said numerous times Apple needs to do something spectacular to regain it's professional audience. Assuming it even remotely cares at this point in time. It's an exodus and Apple knows it, "Halo Effect" is well and truly evaporating by the minute...

Q-6
 
Last edited:
With speeds from Thunderbolt 3 already here and upcoming usb4 playing catch-up next year most professionals want these speeds ”outside the box” already so this is a small step in the right direction. I’ve ordered mine today and won’t need another laptop for a “long” time.
 
You'd probably be well off to start looking at Dell then. Very unlikely we'll see removable SSD and RAM.

For SSD, with thunderbolt-3 external options available, there's little reason to upgrade the internal - and the wear issues are long past something to worry about.

Well past that one. The requirement for removable mass storage should be clear & obvious, nothing to do with wear & tear. Once past a certain level; corporate, company, client data must be stringently controlled, hence why Microsoft is now offering Surface products with "removable" drives, most definitely not for the average user to easily upgrade.

Vast majority of my contracts clearly stipulate data management and control, which precludes the MBP as it's firmly a consumer product in the current configuration...

Q-6
 
  • Like
Reactions: turbineseaplane
At least that’s a little bit cheaper than older model bu starting with 512GB storage.
 
Sorry, but I just have to chuckle at all the folks who a month or two ago bought the 2019 15-incher, with the flawed keyboard, way worse thermal management ... absolutely convinced this one wouldn't come out anytime soon, or be way too expensive.

Now you're kinda stuck with one of the laptops that is part of what will arguably be remembered as one of the worst series of laptop designs Apple ever made.
B036E5F1-C94B-4567-83A6-9BD02BA260E4.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: Queen6
wow...

$200 upgrade from 2.3ghz to 2.4ghz (I dont think turbo boost upgrade from 4ghz to 5ghz is helpful enough)

considering that Samsung 970 EVO NVME SSD 1TB in Amazon is only $169 the upgrade from 1TB to 2TB which is $400 is I think insane :)

considering that 32gb Samsung 2666mhz ram is only $127 in Amazon, again the $400 upgrade is I think insane :)
 
Although there are some improvements, After 4 years doing tiny steps in the right direction is not enough.
Apple used to be the leader and now we suppose to be happy be "Tiny steps"....??
Here's what we're happy about: for the past few years, Apple (wrt Mac) has been running - running - headlong in the wrong direction ("let's strip off everything! let's make it thinner! nothing else matters!"). Now they've stopped running, and they've started walking back in this direction. It's not "hurrah! everything is perfect now!", but at least we're no longer losing ground. If my old MBP breaks, they now sell a MBP with a keyboard that's not horrible, so I feel less at-risk now. Baby steps. It's a good thing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MallardDuck
Here's what we're happy about: for the past few years, Apple (wrt Mac) has been running - running - headlong in the wrong direction ("let's strip off everything! let's make it thinner! nothing else matters!"). Now they've stopped running, and they've started walking back in this direction. It's not "hurrah! everything is perfect now!", but at least we're no longer losing ground. If my old MBP breaks, they now sell a MBP with a keyboard that's not horrible, so I feel less at-risk now. Baby steps. It's a good thing.

Very well said - it'd the pivot to *listening* to customers instead of *telling* them.

Now if they'd just do it with the software too...but maybe that's next year
 
  • Like
Reactions: CarlJ
Well past that one. The requirement for removable mass storage should be clear & obvious, nothing to do with wear & tear. Once past a certain level; corporate, company, client data must be stringently controlled, hence why Microsoft is now offering Surface products with "removable" drives, most definitely not for the average user to easily upgrade.

You'll be banging against the wall to get this forum to understand stuff like this.
They think we are "complaining" when really it's something Apple should be supporting.
[automerge]1573690317[/automerge]
wow...

$200 upgrade from 2.3ghz to 2.4ghz (I dont think turbo boost upgrade from 4ghz to 5ghz is helpful enough)

considering that Samsung 970 EVO NVME SSD 1TB in Amazon is only $169 the upgrade from 1TB to 2TB which is $400 is I think insane :)

considering that 32gb Samsung 2666mhz ram is only $127 in Amazon, again the $400 upgrade is I think insane :)

Agreed..

Apple decided to start soldering on things just to drive upgrade BTO revenue at the time of initial purchase.

They duped some into thinking it was "necessary for design/thin profile", but other laptop makers have shown us just how optional of a choice it really is.

At one time it maybe was justified (earlier on in the "thinning" process), but at this point soldering things on and making you choose to buy upgrades from Apple is simply a revenue driver.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Queen6
Sorry, but I just have to chuckle at all the folks who a month or two ago bought the 2019 15-incher, with the flawed keyboard, way worse thermal management ... absolutely convinced this one wouldn't come out anytime soon, or be way too expensive.

Now you're kinda stuck with one of the laptops that is part of what will arguably be remembered as one of the worst series of laptop designs Apple ever made.
No complaints here with my full spec'd MBP 2019 15. Thing runs like a beast. No keyboard issues. Im covered by their keyboard repair/ replacement program for 4 years. I am happy. Any dints scratches i incur while owning it will be repaired for free if i have any keyboard issues. But as of now, keys are soft and butter to type on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Detnator
There doesn't seem to be a trade in option for the 2019 macbooks?

I finally upgraded this year after having a release 2012 retina that has been very reliable but basically rebuilt after the graphics card issue 2 years ago. Solid machine at 7 yo, but it was time, and I had somehow convinced myself that the 16 would be at a different price point. Now seeing I could get for the same price much better specs, I am a little annoyed. I hope I can trade it in and off set the difference in my mind with the 64 RAM and 8 GB video. I was planning on spending a little money doing some extra mods to my mp 5,1, but I might hold off on that.

I will say I like the keyboard as others seem to loathe. I assume I would (will?) love it much less with broken keys, but I like to type on it substantially more than my 2012.
 
Sorry, but I just have to chuckle at all the folks who a month or two ago bought the 2019 15-incher, with the flawed keyboard, way worse thermal management ... absolutely convinced this one wouldn't come out anytime soon, or be way too expensive.

Now you're kinda stuck with one of the laptops that is part of what will arguably be remembered as one of the worst series of laptop designs Apple ever made.
Laughing at people’s misjudgment or lack of knowledge on a product and rubbing it in. Sound like a great human.
 
All you 2019 15" fans - I'm glad you're happy..
But I'd fire sale that thing myself.

The valuation hit is going to be "not fun" and I'd jump ship now, while the value is still there.

Not only is the keyboard fixed - the ESC is back, Inverted-T is back, Navi is inside, the Screen is bigger, the Speakers/Mic are way better (according to reviewers), the cooling system/fans is better...

It's not just the keyboard here..
 
  • Like
Reactions: Queen6
What do we know about these GPUs? I work mostly in audio, so don't need an amazing GPU, but if the 5500M with 8GB can play games well in bootcamp, I'd take the plunge.
Oh well, I think I'm in. I originally bought my current 2019, i9 2.3ghz 8 core, 32GB ram, 2TB SSD, Vega 20, because I knew the 16" would require Catalina and there'd be no way to go back to Mojave.. Sadly I have 100+ steam games and some audio apps that are 32 bit only and I didn't want to lose them...

I think even the 5300M is capable of HD gaming.. and it has 15 less watts of heat..The way to do that is to buy the 6 core then upgrade processor, ram etc and leave the GFX at the 5300M. That said, I will wait a few days for benchmarks to come out as well as thermal tests.. I have till next Wednesday to decide. I really did get it at the right time in that regard.
Are you referring to Steam games on Mac? I didn't realize there were so many. When I do game, it's on Windows.
 
What do we know about these GPUs? I work mostly in audio, so don't need an amazing GPU, but if the 5500M with 8GB can play games well in bootcamp, I'd take the plunge.

It depends on what you mean by "well".
I think it's a GTX 1650 class card - which isn't amazing, particularly with the screen resolution of the MBP

(thinking of gaming - of course you could play at lower Rez also)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Falhófnir
This is just nonsense. A laptop is just a damn tool. SSDs break so if your super heavy and excellent laptop breaks after 3 years of usage it can only be scrapped. Climate change, right to repair, longevity?
Each of my Macs was upgraded with new SSD/more RAM over the years And each of them had a second or third life.

There was a time one could grab its laptop and talk at a conference without an adapter and there was a time one could flash a SD card without an adapter.
Yes, developers, pen testers and a lot of other people need those features - the same group of people that demanded a physical escape key.

So Apple, take a step back to the models of 2012-2015 and call it „pro“. GPU, Keyboard and RAM is fine now.

Why does “without an adapter” matter?! Why is that the be all and end all here?What’s wrong with moving the ports out of the machine and into any one of a number of CHOICES of mini dock... that you can STILL TAKE WITH YOU?!

Your comparison to a physical escape key is laughable. I can’t just plug one of those in. And its location is much more important than the location of a HDMI port.

Just get the dock and include it with you everywhere you take your Mac. Why can’t you do that - other than some psychological block?

You’re still carrying less weight and volume than you used to when the ports were built in. And you’re only carrying what YOU need and not what other people with different needs need.

What is the huge problem with this????

Secondly... why does YOUR Mac have to have a second or third life with YOU?? Why can’t you sell it to someone else and give it a second life with them, where it’s more appropriate?

You haven’t addressed my key questions. Here’s the flaw in your argument: Why do you need to upgrade ONLY the RAM and SSD while refusing to upgrade the rest? If you’re buying computing power (CPU, GPU, WiFi, Bluetooth, security, display technology sometimes, everything else that’s in these things) in 2019 that will still be good enough for your needs in 2022 then it’s more than you need now in 2019. You’re spending too much now for everything outside of RAM and SSD. So spend a fraction of that now and replace the entire machine when you need more RAM and SSD since by then you’ll need more CPU and GPU and whatever else. You will spend less money overall and be more up to date more consistently.

What is wrong with this??
 
Last edited:
It depends on what you mean by "well".
I think it's a GTX 1650 class card - which isn't amazing, particularly with the screen resolution of the MBP

(thinking of gaming - of course you could play at lower Rez also)
I appreciate the info. I'm coming from a GTX 970 in my desktop, so looks like not even at that level. Oh well, more of an after thought. Probably still worth the upgrade for the additional 500 GB on the internal SSD
 
  • Like
Reactions: turbineseaplane
I appreciate the info. I'm coming from a GTX 970 in my desktop, so looks like not even at that level. Oh well, more of an after thought. Probably still worth the upgrade for the additional 500 GB on the internal SSD

Hey though - shout out to the 970!
I have a relative that still uses one. That was an ALL-TIMER GPU in my opinion.

It's honestly still a very good card, to this day, in my opinion.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.