Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I love this proposal from someone at The Verge forums. It's kind of a different view of the current design. The only icons which I don't like in the mockup below are the reminders icon, which I think is too vague. Also the App Store and iTunes Store icons which lack circles, which makes it harder to tell iTunes and Music apart.

Image
Image

This is exactly what I want, with a few changes to the Photo's icon/Safari icon.

Safari should be all blue with compass pointers.

Photos, maybe the colors could go all the way to the edges so it was rainbow like Game Center.

The white space icons bother me, I feel like they lacked creativity so they were just like "lol let's leave it blank"
 
I love this proposal from someone at The Verge forums. It's kind of a different view of the current design. The only icons which I don't like in the mockup below are the reminders icon, which I think is too vague. Also the App Store and iTunes Store icons which lack circles, which makes it harder to tell iTunes and Music apart.

Image
Image

Looks like something that would bore me to death in 2 minutes.

Say what you want about the current icons, but there is a deeper design choice behind them that make them "last longer".
 
Circle, circle, circle...

game-center-ios-7-icon-256.png

Game Center Icon IOS7

applecampus2rendering.jpg

Mothership

mac_pro_2013_later_this_year.jpg

Future
 
These new icons all look as though they were pilfered from some class assignment for beginning graphic designers. For example, what does the icon with different sized colored circles represent, versus the NBC-peacock ripoff logo? Is that a Safari logo or a Compass logo? And what does an airplane, a movie projector, and a coffee cup all have in common to share one icon? Is that Passport?!

Perhaps (if you haven't already) a viewing of the session at WWDC where Apple explains details about the iOS 7 UI, where they came from with the first touch based interface 6 years ago, why they started there (and some decisions that were made at the time), and where they're going with this new UI will put some of the things into context.

As for the icons, the simplified nature of them is by design because they don't believe that detailed, photograph quality images representing an application in an icon is the future, they believe that we have matured and evolved in our understanding of the touch based paradigm on tablets and phones, that the icon is merely a way to represent a way to launch an application, not the application itself. There is so much more and I've already harmed their presentation (which was very enjoyable to watch) by attempting to explain *their* thinking.

Personally I'm not a fan of all the icons, but the Safari icon has never been anything I felt enamoured regarding, and a couple of others I don't get, but once you've clicked on them one time, you'll remember them and never think about it again, unless of course you're the type that can't let anything go. ;-)

The WWDC session (Rogifan first suggested this) is called, "What's New in iOS 7 Interface Design." And it's very, very enjoyable.
 
Last edited:
I would love to find out the weather icon actually dynamically changes, fades back and forth between the temperature and icon itself.
 
Amazing how they took the icons and put a grid on it in the hopes of justifiying their work as being Class A professional mathematical artistic creation

And the worse is that a lot of people got fooled by the gimmick

Umm those grids are meant to be placeholders for apps that aren't finished? They are not gonna be left there in the final release.
 
I will not complain if the "playful circles" are using actual ball patterns, meaning football (The real one, not handegg), basketball, baseball, etc.

Trouble is that that implies there are games in Game Center.

I like the idea I saw about using either a checkerboard set of squares or even the two profile from inside the app
 
Change Safari

Safari is atrocious and needs to be changed, and also not a big fan of the neon green everywhere... but other than those two things I think it looks great.
 
I think the circles for signal strength make perfect sense. It's the indication of battery strength on the Mac laptops and on my lawnmower. The bar graph is stupid and takes too much vertical space. It's not like it's graphing actual data. If it makes you feel better, the dots are bars that haven't been stretched to increasing heights artificially. Instead of 4 bars, you have 4 dots. Is it that hard?

According to your logic, maybe they need to change it like a percentage just like the MacBook too?
I don't see how the dots are actually using less vertical space either...
Last but not least, as I have pointed out, the dots sardine-packed together are not really easy to use for some older folks or anyone with less than ideal eyesight...
We criticize because we love the products but it disappoints this time.
 
I wish you could download your iBooks drectly, instead of you needing to first go into the iBooks app just so it re-directs you back to the App Store to download.

These should be in your 'Purchased' section along with your apps..... Not seperate, or a link.

Also, the "mother-ship" looks set to take off soon. :)
 
First time I have ever been disgusted by an Apple product.:mad: I was expecting Apple to do away with the extreme skeumorphic stuff here and there, but this neonfest and ugly icons are horrible. I have a feeling all of this is in effort to gear up for the chineese market. As a european, It goes all the way against my taste.

I am neither european nor asian. I am Australian. And what was shown on iOS7 in the keynote looked amazing to me. Including the new icons. These icons bring to iOS what was lacking in some parts of OS X recently. Colour.

I am glad Apple told Forstall what part of his lower half to shove his skumorphism up. And hope it never comes back. For the short time Ive and co had to work on iOS I am amazed at what they did do and it'll only get better.

I think everyone has their own tastes when it comes to icons. Some love them and others hate them.
 
TO hell with apple. making me wait for the new monitor. those swines.

and their demo during wwdc was fake as hell. the beta they released barely functions properly

What are you talking about? It works nearly perfectly on my iPhone 5.
 
I am sorry that I cannot see that as "playful" circles...
The old icon was better.
I will not complain if the "playful circles" are using actual ball patterns, meaning football (The real one, not handegg), basketball, baseball, etc.
That way, it is instantly recognizable.
Apple is good at making things intuitive, but this failed.

The sunflower, again, maybe I am just not good with art. I also cannot see this as sunflower. Sorry about that.:(

"Abstract" in art is a word used for things that don't really look like what they're supposed to represent, but if you want to believe it does, then it can. Also, sunflowers are yellow....
 
People are crying the app icon has nothing to do with what the app is about? So what? The icon does not have to reflect the app content. Only make an association so eventually you know ah that's that app.

Same thing as this website.
Very little Mac news or rumours occur here. And when there is they can't put the Mac rumours first.
Apple Announces iOS 7, New Mac Pro, OS X, and More
But it does not matter as it's just a name. It's reflecting the brand awareness and not the content. The same as the iOS7 app icons.
 
Am i crazy or the flap of the envelope of the mail icon is rounder in the first image? In the second image it is more triangular. Very subtle, but looks better. :)
 
There's no uniformity. Design 101

The real problem is these icons look like they've been grabbed from several different icons sets - or designed by different teams.

I download a lot of icon sets in my web design role, and every single icon set you can download online has one simple goal - to make each icon in the set look like it comes from the same set.

Apple is failing so far with these icons to achieve that uniformity.

Game Centre and Photos look like they came from one set; Reminders, Notes, Calendar, Newstand, Safari from another; Mail, iTunes Store, Music, Messages, Phone, App Store from another; Settings and Camera another. And so on!

This was a problem with iOS6 and earlier, but is more starkly obvious in iOS7.

Apple should pick a style out of each its used, and redesign all its iOS7 icons to follow that style.

It's the principle of repetition, consistency, uniformity - call it what you like. It's one of the first things you get taught in design.
 
I think having a live weather icon isn't worth it. It requires an Internet connection of some sort at all times, and is generally out of date unless it's updated a LOT. I wouldn't trust it to have the correct data, anyway. Apple are going about that the right way.

It's an iPhone, has internet connection 100% of the time.

They can disable real-time updating in iOS for iPod Touch, iPad, etc.
 
I think we might get live weather for three reasons:

1. Notification center weather sucks right now. There are no graphical depictions of the conditions, and half the time it leaves out the current temperature! Though they might fix this during the beta process.

2. The new background process system in iOS 7

3. The Clock. What the hell does this have to do with the Clock you might ask? The Clock is now dynamic. But not like the Calendar used to be. Now I don't know for sure how the Calendar worked previously, but I'll guess they used different graphics with numbers and weekday combinations. The Clock is too complicated to make out of thousands of static icons that would need to be updated so quickly. I think that we could get current weather conditions behind the current temperature—maybe even animated. Think about how cool that would be.

As for all the icon complainers—while the icons are quite different, you get used to it after a few days. The one that bugs me the most is Safari, followed closely by Camera. I think Apple will continue to unify as we move through the beta. Just look at all the iterations the Calculator app has gone through since iPhone OS 1.0! But the thing that bugs me most about Safari is that it doesn't feel like Safari. The hash marks are too bright and the caridinal directions are missing! Also I don't like the two black blobs of Stocks and Compass, but those are hidden anyway. I mean, does anyone leave those on their home screen? I haven't even opened Stocks to see how it looks in iOS 7 because it don't care! Also Game Center is weird, and Newsstand doesn't seem clear to me.

And for the people who say this will kill the battery—how exactly? My phone already gets dozens of emails, dozens more texts, Twitter notifications, AppShopper alerts, ESPN news updates, Calendar invites, Mint notifications, and more. On iOS 6 I usually had 30-40% left at the end of the day. How exactly will pinging a server to update the weather 24 times a day kill the battery? And for 8 of those pings you'll be asleep with your phone plugged in anyway. So 16 pings per day extra! It could even update every 30 minutes for all I care.

If this was an accidental leak, don't be surprised that only the iPhone 5S supports it and other fancy new yet-to-be-revealed live icons or Notification Center widgets because of the added "CPU power needed." Combine that with Offline Siri for basic tasks and dictation, possible NFC and/or fingerprint scanning support, digital wallet, 802.11ac WIFI and 12 or 13 megapixel camera and the iPhone 5S becomes a compelling upgrade. But what do I know? I'm just wildly speculating.
 
Why would anyone need a constant reminder of the current temp? Not worth the battery drain.

Why would anyone need the background to change depending on the angle of the phone? Seems to me that's much less important than what the temp is.

I personally would like to see both, but I'm not sure why someone would think the current temp (and preferably an indication of the current weather conditions on the icon as well) would be unimportant — lots of people work in buildings where they don't have immediate access to a window to see what it's like outside.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.