Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
So, a couple of things.

First, I continue to be fascinated/interested in how the writers choose to deviate from the original story as laid out in the comics. What I mean is, how do they choose which characters and what parts of the story to change and what is the rationale behind making those changes. I would certainly watch a show or listen to a podcast that covered this topic in more depth. For example, in the comic Rick lost his hand in the Governor story arc. Kirkman said they chose not to do that in the show because in hindsight he regretted making that choice. The show allowed him an opportunity to "right a wrong" and, in his mind, improve the story. They are doing some very different things in the show with Eugene's character and I'm really curious as to how they think these changes are improving the story.

Second, my current theory is that the writers/producers of TWD have learned from watching the debacle that Game Of Thrones is and are purposefully slowing down the pace of the plot progression because they don't want the show to ever catch up with the comic. I have no doubt they see it as an opportunity to do more character development, a way to go deeper into the plot, and a chance to explore tangential plot lines that were left as is in the original source material.

I'm still really enjoying TWD, but having read the comics there are times where I'm conflicted because I want the pace to pick up a bit or I may not fully agree with a deviation they make.
 
Well tonight is supposed to have a huge twist or death in it. I wonder how many people will vow to quit watching if the mid season finale isn’t anything special and they are sick of the hype.
 
In the first 15 minutes I was ready to complain that it was moving too slowly.

The last 30 seconds...dayum....did not see that coming. That will be an emotional loss, for sure, but I'm not convinced that will make a long-term storyline difference.

Was that in the book/graphic novel?
 
I'm not buying it. I'll be back here on Feb 20-whatever to eat crow as needed :D

I'm even making this spoiler, umm, spoiler free, but if you're interested in a possible out for "korls" situation, look into the comic storyline regarding the Whisperers.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Mac'nCheese
In the first 15 minutes I was ready to complain that it was moving too slowly.

The last 30 seconds...dayum....did not see that coming. That will be an emotional loss, for sure, but I'm not convinced that will make a long-term storyline difference.

Was that in the book/graphic novel?
No, that's why it was supposed to be such a shock to the fans. Carl is alive and well in the comics. I guess they couldn't hide the fact anymore that a man with facial hair was playing a 12 year old.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlliFlowers
What I'm kinda confused by, is in the beginning of the season in the future look ahead when Rick is old wasn't Carl there?
 
I'm not buying it. I'll be back here on Feb 20-whatever to eat crow as needed :D

I'm even making this spoiler, umm, spoiler free, but if you're interested in a possible out for "korls" situation, look into the comic storyline regarding the Whisperers.
I've read the comics and I'm not following your logic here?

Are you saying he could have been bitten by a Whisperer?

I do wonder if they are taking Carl off the show was the decision in some way actor motivated. Does he have other projects he's working on, etc. ?
 
I've read the comics and I'm not following your logic here?

Are you saying he could have been bitten by a Whisperer?

Yes! I mean, it's a possible "solution" to this, though he seems like he's succumbing to zombie-itus (and if this is a ruse, wow, the people involved with the show are really working overtime to sell it).

As someone who knows the source material better, maybe you can tell me whether that's at all possible[?]

That being said, I'll take my crow with extra gravy :D
 
Yes! I mean, it's a possible "solution" to this, though he seems like he's succumbing to zombie-itus (and if this is a ruse, wow, the people involved with the show are really working overtime to sell it).

As someone who knows the source material better, maybe you can tell me whether that's at all possible[?]

That being said, I'll take my crow with extra gravy :D

I guess that's possible, and it certainly would be a great plot twist by the writers, but it just doesn't seem feasible to me. If they take Carl out then this would be the biggest departure from the comics that we have seen and likely will take the show in a completely different direction from the source material.
 
If you remember at the end of last season, they said Carl had one more year on his contract. I am wondering if they were not able to work out the details so, they said oh well, kill him off. But yeah, this is one of the biggest if not the biggest difference between the two universes.
 
Finally got to catch up with Walking Dead season 8. it was superb. it was kinda dark in some episodes lighting wise. and dont like that ricks plans keep messing up but i guess they need to make things intresting. sucks that carl is gonna die. cant wait for the rest of season 8 in Febuary when it resumes..
 
Well Carl’s dead.

That was all you got out of last night's episode?

I can't even find myself getting worked up over Morgan's newest breakdown, knowing he's leaving to join Fear.

I'm starting to wonder if all the flash forwards we've been seeing are only Carl's imagination, and not real at all. Especially given the final 12 seconds of last night's extended episode.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hulugu
I'm starting to wonder if all the flash forwards we've been seeing are only Carl's imagination, and not real at all. Especially given the final 12 seconds of last night's extended episode.

On Talking Dead after the show they said that the flash forwards were Carl's vision of what the future could be like.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hulugu
On Talking Dead after the show they said that the flash forwards were Carl's vision of what the future could be like.

Aha. That makes perfect sense. I only saw the preview for TD. The boy who plays Carl is such a little cutie. You lose track of that under all the grime. No pun on the character's last name intended.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.