I am in the minority within the vocal detractors, but, I agree with his assessment of a MBP not having a touch screen. Having to interact by reaching up isn't natural, nor ergonomically comfortable in practice.
I think the advancement needs to happen in IOS to incorporate more of MacOS's core features and multi-tasking ability. The Mac could totally benefit having some more multitouch capability, and perhaps eventually replacing the keyboard with a full screen lower case half, for multitouch input.
But again, this is just my opinion.
I'm inclined to agree with that, I'm not particularly interested in reaching up to tap my laptop screen. The Trackpad and the Touch Bar will serve perfectly well in that respect. I find reaching up to touch a screen to be something that completely interrupts my flow, my hands are better served on the keyboard portion, which is why any touchscreen laptop I've had or used has actually never been used that way by me.
I wouldn't however object if that same screen could detach from the MacBook and serve as an iPad Pro. That's something I'd very much like, the masterful combination of my MacBook Pro and my iPad Pro.
No longer would you have to think, ok which one do I want to take on my travels. The one to get serious work done, or the one for light work and entertainment. Or will I be better served taking both with me.
That's just my outlook of course, I don't think a detachable device needs to operate as a touchscreen when docked with its base. It could I guess. But I'd be happy enough if it didn't in order to save power. There's no really good reason I can think of why Apple shouldn't go this route, it's the one thing I really like about the Surface Book.
I've said many times I think macOS would be a terrible mobile OS and iOS would be a terrible traditional computing platform. But a delicate merging of the two to form two distinct uses within the same device. No objection to that at all.
It wouldn't necessarily be cheap, but some of the cost could be offset by the fact that the iPad Pro would be serving as the screen, the wireless chipsets, potentially as at least a portion of the storage, part of the battery, basically the keyboard section would be a large battery, the USB interface, graphics chipset and the Intel processor. With the iPad Pro taking care of the rest. It would still be macOS and iOS, but refined versions of both to take advantage of the merging.
I could sit and get my serious work done in laptop configuration, maybe undock the screen to use the Pencil. Then when I'm done, just lift the screen off and read spider-man, err, I mean war and peace of course
