I used to own one, and I wasn’t too bothered with them - but going back to the older chiclet keyboards made me realize how the new ones were a step backwards in terms of feel. The older ones had better travel (less force on your fingers, felt better, quieter at least quieter than the first and second Gen butterfly)
Not everyone who owns one likes them, though most are content with them
There is hyperbole on the keyboards but they are no longer the best feeling keyboards on a laptop. A lot of the competition has really caught up and surpassed Apple, and it’s sad to see Apple stagnate. Apple had no comparison in that field for over a decade. Now many high end laptops offer incredible keyboards, that just make one question “how come The new MacBooks don’t feel this great?”
Maybe the third Gen keyboards offer more travel and feedback than just quieter sound, but they still require a revisit to fix the core issues. By all accounts the third Gen keyboards are the same sound aside. Second Gen was a step in the right direction but only just a step.