Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The average iPhone buyer doesn't care about A5 and retina display and iOS5, infact the vast majority have probably never even heard of the words A5 or dual core or retina display they just want a state of the art phone that is sexy and is going to get them noticed when they are out in public with it, they are the sort of people who Apple need to cater for so a simple specs upgrade and the same look will be a serious error, the casual Apple buyers need something that is going to turn heads and Apple know that, us hardcore geeks who queue all night for Apple products and would buy a turd with an Apple logo on it are probably 5-10% at most of Apple buyers.

There will be an iPhone 5 with much sexier look and bigger size unveiled on Tuesday, Apple are not that stupid to simply just bump up the specs of an existing phone in this day and age
 
Essentially, what all of you "…it has to be redesigned…" people are saying is that you want Apple to be more 'innovative' by copying the phones that have larger screens. Sorry I don't see that as being innovating.
No screen size is not innovation in and of itself, however it is a big part of user experience and with the trend towards larger screens it would be foolish on Apples part to not give the iPhone a larger screen. The phone itself doesn't have to be all that much bigger to accommodate a larger screen and I really don't understand all the resistance to a larger screen size.

You can be a fan and love Apple (I do) but you can't have blinders on. Android is not that far behind iOS. I've been playing around with iOS5 for a few months now and while it is a better than the current version it's not a radical difference. I doubt someone who hasn't had iOS would be blown away by the differences. Visually it looks the same with some minor UI tweaks so we come down to form factor. The average consumer is going to want to see something new and different, even non techie iPhone 3 or 4 users who don't know RAM from storage will have to see something different enough to justify buying the new phone if it's only a 4S.

Right now I hate to say it but I think the iPhone is playing catchup to some Android devices out there. What will happen when WinPhone7/8 comes out with a curved SAMOLED screen? Or the rumored HTC Galaxy S 3? Will you still say the iPhone is ahead of the curve? Pun intended:)
 
Hmm... I think Apple "leaked" this on purpose. Shoot down expectations of a new phone, then come out of nowhere at the keynote with a radical new iPhone 5.

And the 4s is the cheap iPhone.

I think you're pressing a bit too much your hopes for a new i5. You could get disappointed even worse than the rest of us, you know.
 
lol if Apple waits this long only to unveil a slightly better iPhone 4.

I can't see too many people upgrading their 4's to a 4S. There's no doubt by now a 4S is official but we need a 5 to go along with iOS5.

Tim Cook's legacy is already on the line with this one.

People who evaluate companies for real, brokers, traders, etc. They know better. All this crap on the forum about "Tim Cook's legacy" is meaningless. The current product pipeline is all the result of Steve's vision.
 
If the new iPhone is really just a 4 with an A5 processor, that is a huge disappointment.

But, this doesn't make sense on a few levels.

1. Why are there 2 different logos? All rumors and common sense has pointed to a single phone with a dual-mode GSM/CDMA chip.

2. The iCloud screenshot that showed the definitely different looking iPhone.

I bet these are just placeholders. Apple is known to keep their cards close.
 
Maybe by some ignorant consumers, but not by the informed market.

Devices are planned probably 2 years in advance, I would bet that Steve already signed off the iPhone 6 and the iPhone 7 before stepping down as CEO, the iPad 3 and iPad 4 too, this is not a Cook phone it is a Steve phone

Tim's DNA will not appear in the Apple products until 2014 IMHO

----------

It would be crackup if the iPhone 5 gets announced in 2 days. arn's face IRL would be priceless.

It will be, for the past 3 nights I have dreamed of Steve Jobs launching an iPhone 5, I have even booked Tuesday off work because I will be too excited about the event to concentrate on any work so Apple had better not let me down, they won't :apple:
 
Devices are planned probably 2 years in advance, I would bet that Steve already signed off the iPhone 6 and the iPhone 7 before stepping down as CEO, the iPad 3 and iPad 4 too, this is not a Cook phone it is a Steve phone

Tim's DNA will not appear in the Apple products until 2014 IMHO

I agree with this; it isn't like companies (any company that makes things for that matter) make things and then sell, then try and make a new one AFTER the old one is out. THey have these things setup and hidden.

Actually, if you go back and find the Engadget article where they explore Apple and find out how they tested for reception for the iPHone 4, they talk about objects with black cloaks over them (they were back behind the scenes)

http://www.engadget.com/2010/07/16/inside-apples-black-lab-wireless-testing-facilities/

There's the link; good read.
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_3_4 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8K2 Safari/6533.18.5)

AppleScruff1 said:
Why would Apple have a delay of several months just to introduce a phone with only slight revisions? To see how far they can push things with their customers?

A delay from what? They never announced anything to delay.
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_3_4 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8K2 Safari/6533.18.5)

rocknblogger said:
My friend you said a mouthful and I agree with every single word. I sit in on a lot of meetings at my work and it used to be when I pulled out my iPhone, everyone went "oooooooo, iPhone eh?". Now, everyone else in the room has an Android HTC or Samsung 4-4.3" screen super phone and pulling out the iPhone is gotten a bit embarrassing. Everyone here may think the iPhone still drops golden nuggets in it's stool, but let me tell you the rest of the populous thinks differently. AND keeping the same design with the same small screen for what will amount to 28 months is either the height of stupidity or arrogance on Apple's part.

I passed on the 4 because it was behind the times 14 months ago. A new chip and camera is not gonna do it for a lot of people.

Now, honestly, a fella came into my office Friday with his new iPhone 4 and we both compared the screen to my old 3gs. Loaded a few websites to get a look at the 'retina' effect on small text. We could hardly tell the difference. Believe me, it ain't the selling point you folks think it is.

This guy has always been a die-hard Apple supporter and Jobs was always god to him, but he's not too happy with the iPhone 4 compared to what's on the marked these days. The screen's too small and he doesn't like the square shape. Even he's looking at Android now.

Apple is going to look damn pathetic if they try to shlep the same phone on the public again after 15 months. It ain't 2007 any more.

Both of you guys +100. I could not agree with you more. For all the reasons you guys mention, nothing other than a new redesigned phone makes sense. I don't think Apple is that arrogant. To allow Android to grab a larger market share? I don't think so. Without a new iPhone it will be said that Apple is in decline.

How does apple having a superior device with a superior os allow android to steal marketshare.

So many people are confusing their personal wishes and desires with the actual reasons why people buy apple products.

Quite frankly those thinking it will be a disaster if apple does not introduce two new phones are wrong.
 
I am really getting sick of these rumours.
Hats off to Apple for keeping the new flagship iPhone a secret.

But to be honest now, if there really is not a redesign, I am not buying it. I know Apple doesn't care about me or some other people; and there are going to be tonnes of people buying this new iPhone, I just don't wanna see an upgraded iPhone 4 shoved up my face.

I don't like iPhone4's design. It just doesn't feel right in the hand. iPhone3G/3GS was amazing to hold; the feel was just right and appropriate.

If there really isn't a new iPhone on the 4th, I'll be really happy to go get a new Mango device the very next day.

/stupid rant.
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_3_4 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8K2 Safari/6533.18.5)

aeaglex07 said:
Why do people clamor for constantly new and different? The iPhone 4 form factor is beautiful, elegant, and imminently ergonomic. WHY change it? The internals are what count - that's where you get the changes that actually matter. So yes, 15 months and "all" you get is a new, faster processor, better camera, etc! LOL.
!

because the current competition is better LOL

By what measurement?
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_3_4 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8K2 Safari/6533.18.5)

zigzagable said:
you guys are ridiculous! the iphone 4 is outdated and has been outdated since its launch! im as much as a fanboy as everyone else, but facts are facts. right now the iphone 4 is behind every other phone. if the iphone 4s is released with with the features it's supposed to have, the it will only be average compared to the phones that are out now, and then soon be outdated again. if your talking about speed, thats mostly because of ios not the internals. think about it this way: the macbook pros that are out now are great (i have one). they look great, they're fast, and they work great. but even so, you can go get a windows laptop for cheaper, that has superior hardware. when it comes to apple the only things they succeed in for the most part is software

How come nobody buys any of these better phones? The 3GS outsells ALL of them
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_3_4 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8K2 Safari/6533.18.5)

zigzagable said:
Again, who cares if the iPhone wouldn´t have the fastest specs out there when it is faster than most of the phones that have better specs?

like i said before capability is what matters. if a phone has better hardware then it is capable of more. what your talking about is preference and opion.

----------

Essentially, what all of you "…it has to be redesigned…" people are saying is that you want Apple to be more 'innovative' by copying the phones that have larger screens. Sorry I don't see that as being innovating.

well first of all screen size isn't something you can innovate. size is size is size. you can't be creative with it. and you can still easily be innovative and have current to future generation hardware. you innovate design, not internal hardware.

Yeah but it has a horrible os so it is capable of much less. Apple can integrate the hardware and software to maximize effectiveness and outperform those devices you erroneously believe to be more capable.
 
Let's just get this straight guys.

Apple might just announce an iPhone 4S. Will it still sell good? Yes, because it's an iPhone. But will it sell amazingly as predicted?
I don't think so.

The public would look at how the phone looks first, and then they would look at the specs. If the next iPhone looks just like the iPhone 4, then people would say "if it looks the same as last year's model, i can just buy the iPhone 4 which is cheaper now"
It would be completely stupid for Apple to release an iPhone 4S as their main phone after 15months since the last upgrade.

The smartphone market right now is leaning towards bigger screen, better resolution, better camera, slick form factor.

Unfortunately, i think Apple got it's priorities wrong, I believe Apple could have taken the iPhone 4 launch as a great way to launch an iPhone with a 4" screen. At the time the iPhone 4 came out, a 3.5" would be small. Now a days we're seeing phones with 4" screens at the same form factor as the iPhone. But 4"+ screens.
Now, if the iPhone had text wrap, it would've been even easier to browse the internet, but it doesn't. So a bigger screen does help a lot.

The iPhone 4 has a completely flawed design, with all the issues it has such as: antennagate, proximity sensor, glass breaking, ergonomic design, fact that consumer report couldn't recommend it etc. it would come as a huge surprise to me, if Apple didn't redesign it.

Needless to say, a redesign would be the smart thing to do, and the right thing to do. Will Apple do it? Who knows.

couldn't have put it better myself!
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_3_4 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8K2 Safari/6533.18.5)



A delay from what? They never announced anything to delay.

Right, never announced, however, they're OBVIOUSLY some new stuff hence it being released a year later. I don't' see how you came to the conclusion of that statement.
 
No screen size is not innovation in and of itself, however it is a big part of user experience and with the trend towards larger screens it would be foolish on Apples part to not give the iPhone a larger screen. The phone itself doesn't have to be all that much bigger to accommodate a larger screen and I really don't understand all the resistance to a larger screen size.

You can be a fan and love Apple (I do) but you can't have blinders on. Android is not that far behind iOS. I've been playing around with iOS5 for a few months now and while it is a better than the current version it's not a radical difference. I doubt someone who hasn't had iOS would be blown away by the differences. Visually it looks the same with some minor UI tweaks so we come down to form factor. The average consumer is going to want to see something new and different, even non techie iPhone 3 or 4 users who don't know RAM from storage will have to see something different enough to justify buying the new phone if it's only a 4S.

Right now I hate to say it but I think the iPhone is playing catchup to some Android devices out there. What will happen when WinPhone7/8 comes out with a curved SAMOLED screen? Or the rumored HTC Galaxy S 3? Will you still say the iPhone is ahead of the curve? Pun intended:)

perfect way of putting it! especially when you said, "You can be a fan and love Apple (I do) but you can't have blinders on. Android is not that far behind iOS." +1
 
I've been playing around with iOS5 for a few months now and while it is a better than the current version it's not a radical difference.

I don't think we have seen the full effects of iOS5 yet, it gives apps a lot of great new tools to work with so I think you have to wait until you see how apps are improved with iOS5. One big thing that comes to mind is the syncing of data between various installations of an app, this is huge. Now that Apple automatically downloads apps you buy on one device to all other devices, I am finding myself starting a game on one device, then later picking up another device and wanting to just start where I left off on the other device (some games like Words with Friends do this, but with their own proprietary syncing technology). Once developers starting using the iCloud syncing feature of iOS5, you'll be able to just use any device you have with one set of data, that is HUGE.
 
Let's just get this straight guys.

Apple might just announce an iPhone 4S. Will it still sell good? Yes, because it's an iPhone. But will it sell amazingly as predicted?
I don't think so.

The public would look at how the phone looks first, and then they would look at the specs. If the next iPhone looks just like the iPhone 4, then people would say "if it looks the same as last year's model, i can just buy the iPhone 4 which is cheaper now"
It would be completely stupid for Apple to release an iPhone 4S as their main phone after 15months since the last upgrade.
Wrong. Consumers almost always go with "bigger is better". They will buy it for faster specs, if they understand it or not.

The iPhone 4 has a completely flawed design, with all the issues it has such as: antennagate, proximity sensor, glass breaking, ergonomic design, fact that consumer report couldn't recommend it etc. it would come as a huge surprise to me, if Apple didn't redesign it.
.

Yet that flawed design sold better than all the competition.
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_3_4 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8K2 Safari/6533.18.5)

By what measurement?

Well, most would shout specs but there definitely are some great phones out there. Mozart7 is a great device. Although, its battery is just half as good as an iPhone surprisingly.
I really like windows phones as the software is just so awesome. I won't be comparing it with iOS, but it definitely has some great UX design written all over it.

Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_3_4 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8K2 Safari/6533.18.5)

How come nobody buys any of these better phones? The 3GS outsells ALL of them

Well, people have choices? 3GS does not outsell all of them together, I suppose. People do buy those phones.

Some of these phones are cheap too and that helps to sell a lot, really. I would have bought my mama and my aunt an iPhone4 if it was cheap enough; but I got two windows phones running decent software on decent software for a combined price of £500 ~ price of iPhone4.

But yes, I'd buy a windows phone if the form factor is still the same. Don't care about LTE, 4G, assistant or unicorns; I'd still buy a windows phone.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.