Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
That is not entirely Intel's fault, Apple decided against active cooling in 2018 MBAR, the CPU would throttle when ever you are pushing it hard for more than a few minutes.

Actually, the Retina MBA has a fan inside of it. It rarely powers up, but it has a fan.

Another fun fact, the battery is removable in the Retina MBA top case, like the iPhones. We might see this flow to the other new MacBook Pros...
 
The 'Air' name has too much goodwill, that's almost certainly why the October 2018 machine was called thus and not the 13" MacBook - more likely would be the 12"MB being rolled into the Air line (it was effectively the replacement for the 11" Air) add a 128GB version for $999 and the old Air can finally be retired. I would like to see a 15" MacBook based on the Pro but using something like an i7-8559U (Iris rather than Radeon graphics) for around the $1,500-$1,700 mark.

I know folks love the Air, but since the new Macbook came out, a lot of folks (myself included) have wondered, "Why have both?" I'm just wondering at what point they'll make a Macbook that does just the trick for everyone who wants a Mac but only uses one for internet, email, photos, etc. I used to work for Apple Retail, and it seemed like most people needed only the "basics." A low-level Macbook was all most people needed (I left in 2011). At some point, the "Air" becomes superfluous, IMO. Or, they keep the "Air." My point is that I see them rolling Air and Macbook into one line (as you suggested, just in reverse). This would certainly simplify things, and I hope they do it.

This sounds insanely accurate.

Thanks. I think it might be a good move for them, actually. Keep the low-tiered Macbook (or Macbook Air, just not both), start at a price that is reasonable, but add upgrade options (including screen size) for folks who need a boost (or larger screen) but don't need legitimately "Pro level" computing power. They have shown us with the new Mac Pro that they are serious about making workstation-level machines for "Pros." I can only surmise much of what they presented was in response to the mistakes they made (and criticisms they received) with the Trashcan. I can also guess they are planning to do the same thing for the Macbook Pro... make it a legit "Pro" machine. It'll cost an arm and a leg, but no one will be able to say, "the MBP is a mid-level system between the MacBook And the older MacBook Pro's." (see quote below). As for screen size, and this is anecdotal, based on my experience at Apple Retail, I cannot tell you how many 15" MBPs we sold to people who didn't need the horsepower. They just wanted the bigger screen. I absolutely think they could sell a ton of scaled down Macbooks (or Macbook Airs, whatever they decide to call them) with larger screens. To the folks who don't need to run 128 tracks in Logic. No, that's where the new MBP would come in. All speculation on my part, but just going off my experience with working there, as well as an observation that Apple likes to keep its reputation as an "elite" brand intact. They've suffered amongst pros in the last several years, and they are looking to rectify that.

Nope!

The current MacBook Pro's are a mid-level system between the MacBook And the older MacBook Pro's. This is a market that was not buying the newer MacBook's as they saw them as too low end (which they where).

Sadly, the more advanced amateurs and mobile pro's where left in the winds. The retina MacBook Pro systems where too limiting! Compared to the older MacBook Pro Unibody 2012 and older which offered serviceable RAM & Storage.

While Apple did put some effort into increasing the RAM & Storage in the later models, RAM was soldered and the single custom flash drive which Apple wouldn't upgrade after purchase (you had to go with 3rd parties). And dual drive support was just not possible!

A Pro's Pro is desperately needed! Offering the a less constrained CPU thermally, Serviceable RAM and Storage, And bringing back USB-A ports (2) and still offer the four USB-C ports. Modify the back two USB-C ports so a MagSafe adapter plug can be flush mounted so we get MagSafe back! On board Ethernet and SD slot. Pro's don't want dongles or clip on hubs! And they get lost too!

The New Mac Pro is a sign Apple is starting to swing the pendulum back to Function over Form! Now we need a mobile system to go with it! The 16/17" model I suspect is the one! I hope so.

Totally agree with you on the MBPs being "mid-tiered" and advanced amateurs and pros being left out. See my above comments where I flesh out a bit more detail on where I think they may but going.

In response to your proposed MBP (a "Pro's Pro"), I think you may be reaaaaaally darn close, if not nail-on-the-head accurate. The new MP is the tower version of what you're describing. For serious, workstation-level laptop computing, they really need to produce something like what you described to scratch that itch for folks who need it in portable form. For everyone else, we won't need it (or be able to afford it). Personally, as a professional musician, I can use a lot of horsepower for running Logic or Ableton, but I get by just fine on my maxed out Mid-2014 15" MBP. Point being, if I had the option of buying a tricked-out 15" Macbook (Air) that would get me by for say, $3k, I'd do that. But if I could get a New MBP (the one you're describing) for another grand, I'd do that. Especially since I tend to keep my machines for 5-7 years. It'd be nice to have all the options you describe.

They won’t kill the Air name. It’s too well-loved, and if they were gonna do it, the time was last year (just call the 2018 air a 13” MacBook).

Can’t see the MacBook starting at $1,000. Apple’s prices are all going up, not down. I think they’re done with the days of the $1,000 laptop. Hope I’m wrong.

MacBook Pro was JUST updated. Still has “new” badges on apple’s site.

You may be right on the Air name (see my comments above). I've thought about the starting price... I think you may be right on that, too. I'd guess an $1199 starting point if you are. I don't think it would be smart on their end to start at that point, as they'd price out a lot of college kids, but I can certainly see them doing it.

Gosh, this is a long post. Sorry, everyone, but since leaving Apple, I don't have anyone to geek out with over all these things. :) Thanks for dialoging.
 
Here's my guess:

- New 16" MacBook Pro, fullscreen display. Will be launched at a premium over the 13" and 15" models that were just updated. Those will probably remain for sale for the coming years. Typical Apple strategy to increase ASP.

- Updated 13" MacBook Air
- Updated 12" MacBook

Possibly 2-3 SKUs of each. No way is Apple going to release 7 new laptop models. Manage expectations! :)

As for the timeline, I think this would align well with an October event, or possibly September if Apple decides to skip their October event altogether.

Do we know what the rumored Ice Lake processor might bring for the MacBook Air? A switch to a low-voltage Quad Core would be really appealing!
 
The 16" is going to be the same form factor as they will just swap out the screen for one without a bezel. For those living the dream...the ports are never coming back. Apple has never backtracked on ports and the Touch Bar is probably here to stay.
 
  • Like
Reactions: twanj
Oh wow, some links...

No one said there weren't some cases with the butterfly keyboards. Until you have failure rates, you're just posting 15 anecdotal stories.

Apple sold 18M Macs in 2018. If there were a design flaw, you couldn't stop the tsunami of unhappy customers and a repair program wouldn't be sufficient. You also would have seen a major redesign, which you didn't.

Again, not impressed. I don't look at random articles. I watch what Apple does. Apple is acting like it's not a major issue because it isn't.

So, fake news from the corrupt media, right? Yea, uh-huh.

Apple did sell 18M Macs in 2018. Recalling ALL of them makes little business sense when you can offer a repair program and hedge your bet against recalling every single machine. Oh, oh, oh but there's no real numbers as to how many repairs! Like they'll release that info. They'd be absolutely stupid to do so.

Instead, they hedge their bet even further by very publicly stating they redesigned the keyboard (a THIRD time), but when iFixit tore it down there was little difference.

The evidence is clear. And Apple is the strongest piece of it: They redesign something YOU say doesn't need fixing 3 times, APOLOGIZE for it, and offer a Repair Program for your supposedly non-existent issue and market it all as "Hey, check OUT our customer service! It's second to none. We care about you!"

Please.

Here it is folks: you can lead a horse to water, but sometimes it wants Apple-flavored Kool-Aid instead.
 
Here's my guess:

- New 16" MacBook Pro, fullscreen display. Will be launched at a premium over the 13" and 15" models that were just updated. Those will probably remain for sale for the coming years. Typical Apple strategy to increase ASP.

- Updated 13" MacBook Air
- Updated 12" MacBook

Possibly 2-3 SKUs of each. No way is Apple going to release 7 new laptop models. Manage expectations! :)

As for the timeline, I think this would align well with an October event, or possibly September if Apple decides to skip their October event altogether.

Do we know what the rumored Ice Lake processor might bring for the MacBook Air? A switch to a low-voltage Quad Core would be really appealing!
This is the strange thing though, Apple don't have different model numbers for SKUs of a product line. All 2018/19 MBP 15s are A1990, for example. Possibilities I can see given the 13 and 15 Pros have just been updated:

MacBook Air - Intel
MacBook Air - ARM
MacBook - Intel
MacBook - ARM
MacBook Pro -13" nTB
MacBook Pro - 14" (Or MBA 15" Intel)
Macbook Pro -16" (Or MBA 15" ARM)

Edit: Or perhaps cellular MacBook variants like iPads have?

I suppose these don't have to be announced immediately, some could come via a press release in the next couple of weeks, some could be held back for an October Mac event. I think the 12" MacBooks might well be imminent given a lot of retailers seem to be selling off stock.
 
Last edited:
Predictions:

Macbook Air moniker goes away, leaving simply Macbook and Macbook Pro.

Macbook starts at $999 and includes a 15" option. No Touchbar. Configurable up to $3.5k.

Macbook Pro is an overhaul (like the Mac Pro) in response to criticisms that Apple neglects "true professionals." One screen size, includes Touchbar, ports besides USB-C. Prices start at $4k and can go over $10k.

Thoughts?
They are not going to remove the touchbar, I don't think that's going to happen anytime soon... If anything they will improve it but removing it I don't think so...
 
OK, after arguing pointlessly to no end over keyboards and headphone jacks (why do I do this to myself?), I can say that the mockup they show here is awesome-looking.

If Apple released a 17", it would be difficult for me to resist. Pointless touchbar and crappy keyboards be damned.

Crap, I did it again.
 
They should have



MACBOOK AIR 12":
$999

GOOD FOR BASIC NEEDS
Long battery life
Thin and light


MACBOOK 13"
$1299
non touch bar
Middle specs

MACBOOK PRO 15" and 17"
Most expensive
Highest specs
With touchbar
 
Wish Apple to just kill the retina MacBook. With the new Air, the retina MacBook feels out of place. It’s only slightly lighter, but compromised too much on the hardware, and battery life is not better. The original intention was to have the MacBook Air lineup as the regular consumer laptop, with the MacBook Pro for the Pros. The Air monicker was just a transition from the traditional MacBook. It would be much simpler if Apple can just have the current Air as the consumer MacBook, removing the 12” retina MacBook altogether.
 
  • Like
Reactions: happygodavid
You may be right on the Air name (see my comments above). I've thought about the starting price... I think you may be right on that, too. I'd guess an $1199 starting point if you are. I don't think it would be smart on their end to start at that point, as they'd price out a lot of college kids, but I can certainly see them doing it.

Gosh, this is a long post. Sorry, everyone, but since leaving Apple, I don't have anyone to geek out with over all these things. :) Thanks for dialoging.

I for one, appreciate long posts!

Regarding the Air name, I wish Apple retired it, but it doubled down on it not just with the MB but with the iPad as well.

Looks like it's here to stay.
 
  • Like
Reactions: happygodavid
Actually, the Retina MBA has a fan inside of it. It rarely powers up, but it has a fan.

Another fun fact, the battery is removable in the Retina MBA top case, like the iPhones. We might see this flow to the other new MacBook Pros...

The CPU only has a heatsink sitting on top and passively cooled by the Fan blowing air far away from it ( if I remember correctly ) , not really the usual active cooling. Hence the CPU could only do about 10W max, compared to previous MacBook Air 15W.

And one reason why it sucks, the 7W gets you 1.6Ghz, While it *can* turbo to 3.6Ghz, it quickly throttles down within minutes... ( if not seconds )
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Ener Ji
Wish Apple to just kill the retina MacBook. With the new Air, the retina MacBook feels out of place. It’s only slightly lighter, but compromised too much on the hardware, and battery life is not better. The original intention was to have the MacBook Air lineup as the regular consumer laptop, with the MacBook Pro for the Pros. The Air monicker was just a transition from the traditional MacBook. It would be much simpler if Apple can just have the current Air as the consumer MacBook, removing the 12” retina MacBook altogether.


The new air is the most lackluster in terms of sales

Its not much different in weight compared to non TB 2017 macbook pro which offers greater performance.

Its the odd one out.

They should just discontinue the new Air, and make the rMB with lower price
[doublepost=1560451432][/doublepost]
I for one, appreciate long posts!

Regarding the Air name, I wish Apple retired it, but it doubled down on it not just with the MB but with the iPad as well.

Looks like it's here to stay.
The problem is the new air is heavier than the Macbook and is almost thetsame weight as the new macbook pro lol
 
I really don't see ARM in the line up. While there are a lot of people looking for it there are a lot of reasons its not in the cards. As good as the A series chips are they aren't like general purpose CPU's like AMD or Intel chips.

I do see the possibility of seeing AMD Ryzen! Given the ID numbers are so different from older models I'm wondering if that maybe what Apple is up to. Or maybe its FaceID or even version of Mini LED based display (like the new Mac Pro XDR display)


I don’t think apple will ever consider AMD for their chips. Intel still provides superior perf/watt on mobile parts and I don’t see apple changing cpu brand just to end up relegating their control to a different chip manufacturer. If apple decides to use a different chip it will most likely be their own
 
  • Like
Reactions: dmelgar
It's important to note that the Y-series part is a 9-watt part I believe. It kind of makes sense why Apple used a fan on the 7-watt part used in the MacBook Air released last October. They were planning ahead. That said, it would be really nice if Apple dropped the 12-inch MacBook & the 13-inch MacBook Pro sans Touch Bar from their line-ups. It would clear things up considerably.
[doublepost=1560457354][/doublepost]Oh and hopefully they drop the entry price of the MacBook Air to $999!
 
That said, it would be really nice if Apple dropped the 12-inch MacBook & the 13-inch MacBook Pro sans Touch Bar from their line-ups. It would clear things up considerably.

Uuum, no, au contraire. The MBP without Touch Bar gives you the best of both worlds: it is priced closely to the MBA, but has a MBP screen and CPU. If only Apple cared to give it a 4th gen keyboard.

Apple should merge MB and MBA, and update the n-TB MBP.
 
This is the strange thing though, Apple don't have different model numbers for SKUs of a product line. All 2018/19 MBP 15s are A1990, for example. Possibilities I can see given the 13 and 15 Pros have just been updated:

MacBook Air - Intel
MacBook Air - ARM
MacBook - Intel
MacBook - ARM
MacBook Pro -13" nTB
MacBook Pro - 14" (Or MBA 15" Intel)
Macbook Pro -16" (Or MBA 15" ARM)

Edit: Or perhaps cellular MacBook variants like iPads have?

I suppose these don't have to be announced immediately, some could come via a press release in the next couple of weeks, some could be held back for an October Mac event. I think the 12" MacBooks might well be imminent given a lot of retailers seem to be selling off stock.

Thanks! Did not know that.

This makes it very interesting. Can't wait to see what Apple has in store!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Falhófnir
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.