Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
staffing-shortage-business-signs-memes11.jpg
 
With unemployment at its lowest ever? If there’s all these skilled workers sitting around, what do you think the problem is?
Err... what?

Yes, unemployment is currently quite low in the US compared to historical rates of unemployment, which would align with what I had said. First, as I said, the pool of such workers is much smaller in North America than it is in Asia. Second, if the vast majority of them are already employed (since the unemployment rate is low), it makes it that much harder for TSMC to hire enough of them.

Well, one way around this is try to poach them from other companies, but that can get really expensive really quickly, and it also incurs legal and other risks.
 
When Intel canceled its contract with TSMC to make 3nm chips it really hurt TSMC and Apple. TSMC needed that financial commitment from Intel to build the new facilities in AZ. Apple was hurt because their 3nm chip would from that same facility. So Apple went to TSMC and said they would take the Intel contract over so TSMC had the financial backing they needed, but Apple in their deal commited to buy TSMC's whole production of 3nm chips to they would an market advantage. Well Apple and TSMC were all smiles until TSMc started having labor problems in AZ and falling off schedule.
Was this particular plant EVER slated to make 3nm? From the start I think it was mentioned, but then it was clarified that this wouldn’t be a “leading edge” plant. It seemed to me “backfill” plant, making valuable chips, yes, but they wouldn’t be producing the millions of processors a year that Apple would need. I think 3nm was always going to be at their main plants outside the US.
 
Nope, its a manufacturing job, not an executive job. If you’re compensated for the product of your labor, you are livestock to be commoditized and traded. If you skim off the top of all the other suckers doing the work, that’s the real value, now you’re in the money. Why can’t we find enough cattle that educated themselves at exorbitant personal cost & at interest, and who someone else trained to do the work, so we can invest nothing and rake in the profit? The darn cattle are so lazy and unappreciative of our generosity these days.
The headline is a bit misleading. It’s not yet a shortage of workers to manufacture the chips, but of people to construct the factory. The skill sets are demanding, but different.
 
Working at a chip fab factory is a brutal job since the factory needs to be utilized 24/7 for it to be financially worth it. Given that the unemployment in America is amongst the lowest it's ever been it's unsurprising they're unable to find enough labor. Most likely they will need to dramatically improve the compensation in order to get the talent they need.
A chip fab factory-- isthat a factory thst produces chip factoties, or did you infact ean chip fbtication plant or chip factory? Other than that your post brings up a valid point. PersonnalyI wouldn't wanr ri kive in arizone due to it beainga rather hhot plaze ( at least temperature wise j
 
some other factor: Intel is south of Phoenix, in Ocotillo and TSMC is way up north, probably more than 1 hr drive ...
so would you take a job that makes your drive in the heat for 1hr+ (compared to your current job)?

And yes, because we aren’t graduating enough stem workers we can’t staff factories.

You are looking at current dilemma I’m looking at that and beyond.

Situation is bad now and will not get better if we don’t invest heavily in education. That is the only investment that lifts all boats.
 
Why 4nm when 3nm is already there?
Because TSMC wants their bleeding edge nodes to be produced in Taiwan. Note also that this FAB in Arizona is like a mini FAB (20,000 wafer starts a month) compared to the gigaFABs (100,000 wafer starts per month) they have in Taiwan
The fact that they can’t find staff for a small fab is embarrassing, but unsurprising. It is Arizona. I wouldn’t live there for 2x my salary.
 
Because TSMC wants their bleeding edge nodes to be produced in Taiwan. Note also that this FAB in Arizona is like a mini FAB (20,000 wafer starts a month) compared to the gigaFABs (100,000 wafer starts per month) they have in Taiwan
The fact that they can’t find staff for a small fab is embarrassing, but unsurprising. It is Arizona. I wouldn’t live there for 2x my salary.
The thing I don’t understand is why Arizona? The state is already running out of water, and chip fans use A LOT of water. It makes no long term sense. I suspect this will be another scam at the end of the day like the massive subsidies Foxconn just stole to set up an American plant that isn’t actually doing anything at all today.
 
America is very behind, but let’s be clear, companies don’t want to pay what the work is worth. This “skilled labor” line has been running for well over a decade and instead it should be read as “we can’t find enough high skilled workers willing to work for below market rate”.
Pay has nothing to do with it. People don't want to do the work REGARDLESS of pay. The vast majority of Americans don't want to do this kind of construction labor. A few yes, but not enough to develop massive factories.

This is a well known problem. Basically even the poorest homeless people in our economy today are living luxuriously compared to 50 years ago. As in, actual homeless people make more money panhandling today than a worker did 50 years ago.
 
Just installing and firing up this equipment is a highly, highly delicate process. It takes months, and even things like the floor not being level to 0.001” can result millions of dollars of unusable chips.

Chip factories are no joke, and neither is the paycheck that’s supposed to come with being responsible for installing, testing, running, and maintaining it.
I worked in fabs that had to be isolated from road traffic noise.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NT1440 and EugW
Just hope TSMC considers another plant in the UK, which would service Europe. TSMC need more plant outside of Taiwan to ensure that production can continue throughout the world should the worst happen in Taiwan.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Apple Fan 2008
Rather a sad excuse in my opinion. The answer is to train up employees. Obviously there will be a skill shortage on a new plant producing new chips, even on the 4nm chips.

This would apply to any new plant, whether car manufacturer or chips.

So take employees and train them in the skills required.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BusanAA
I don't get it. All these millions of college students, all of these degrees, all these student loans we "must" cancel for their benefit... and we don't have skilled workers? What?!? /s
 
  • Like
Reactions: BusanAA
Rather a sad excuse in my opinion. The answer is to train up employees. Obviously there will be a skill shortage on a new plant producing new chips, even on the 4nm chips.

This would apply to any new plant, whether car manufacturer or chips.

So take employees and train them in the skills required.
The difficulty isn't in staffing the fab...it's difficulty in building it properly. Read more closely.

Fact is, the US has long ago abandoned any encouragement for the trades in favor of a utopian world where a 4 year degree is a birthright (and should be free).

Also note the difference in the conversation about hiring "employees" vs hiring "workers." There's a difference, in my experience. Some people work. Others simply expect to be employed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: An-apple-a-day
I'm surprised robots cannot just make everything from start to finish by now and replace the workers? This was the promise of the west when I was a kid, all the low end jobs would be gone, but it wouldn't matter as everyone would be middle class and populations would be decreasing. Instead what happened is they just sent all the jobs abroad, while increasing immigration which is causing populations to rise and wages to decrease in relative terms.

Edit: The even worse thing is no one in the west wants a normal job now. They've all grown up on the internet thinking life is one big holiday, so I'm not surprised that the mid skilled level is having a hard time to find people. However these companies need to be willing to train people like they used to, they all just stopped years ago because it costs a lot of money.... But it is the only way. Although I think they'd just close shop and move to India instead.

These are heavy automated fabs with robots, the jobs in question are not low end, they're quite high-end actually.
 
Pay has nothing to do with it. People don't want to do the work REGARDLESS of pay. The vast majority of Americans don't want to do this kind of construction labor. A few yes, but not enough to develop massive factories.

This is a well known problem. Basically even the poorest homeless people in our economy today are living luxuriously compared to 50 years ago. As in, actual homeless people make more money panhandling today than a worker did 50 years ago.
That’s a dumbass comment. They don’t make more inflation adjusted money than workers 50 years ago.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.