I harbor the same feelings as most people here. I really
want to want it. I just don't.
The biggest reason being that I don't know if this is best execution of the user experience that Mark Sullivan outlines in his thoughts from VentureBeat. I mean, this is what I want too:
I could see it as a powerful personal assistant that's always just an arm's lift away to help you make sense of the minutiae of daily life: the schedules and reminders and appointments and social media and everything else we all have to process every minute of every day.
I just don't think Apple Watch is just that yet, for a few key reasons. I wrote an article about this that was published on PSFK a while back (headline was not my headline, but I digress).
http://www.psfk.com/2014/09/apples-smartwatch-fails-cant-cursory.html
The Apple Watch may have some appeal and may sell relatively well, but it hasn’t quite changed perspectives on smartwatches in the way the iPhone did with smartphones.
Let’s think for a moment about the core function of a watch. For the longest time, it has given us a quick glance of critical information: the time. As more devices started giving us the time, the watch became more of a fashion accessory. In order to generate demand, tech companies have infused their watches with new smart functions as a way to overcome any reservations about fashion appeal. The problem is that all of that functionality adds up to an experience most of us don’t want: spending a whole lot of time tinkering with our wrists.
Even when the function of telling the time was a critical application of the wristwatch, the maximum time we spent looking at it was 1-3 seconds. By the very nature of its position on our bodies and its diminutive size, the wristwatch isn’t meant for browsing maps or opening secondary menus with hard presses. Watches are instead meant to consistently live with us in a way our phones can’t. The experience shouldn’t be immersive like a phone; it should be cursory, much like time itself.
With that in mind, I proposed a design that isn't too far from the general idea of Withings Activite. I doubt it's actually possible yet (technologically speaking), but I think the holy grail of smart watches would be something I dubbed "The ICE." It sports a mechanical watchface with only one “smart” addition, a “Glacial Glass” display that frosts over to show information in select situations - info that would only take about 1-3 seconds to absorb.
Image