Late to the thread; figured I would add my story.
At 6 am CST on the morning of October 7, I placed two orders for black 64 GB models from ATT's site. Wife and I were both eligible for upgrade, yada.
Placed both orders a minute apart.
Each of us received email confirmation in a few minutes that order was successful.
Your iPhone has been reserved and is expected to be delivered on Oct 14, 2011.
On October 8, we each receive an email that had this message:
We wanted to confirm that your order for iPhone 4S 64GB Black on 08-OCT-2011 00:00:00 is still scheduled to be delivered as early as October 14, 2011.
As the week progresses, I check the site to see order status. No change, just pre-order.
Meanwhile, card is charged for both phones.
On Wednesday October 12, wife receives an email with shipping number. My phone is still in pre-order status.
On Thursday, I call in to see what my status is...told that it might be 2-3 weeks before I receive my phone.
On Friday, wife receives her phone. I call ATT again...am told it might be 28 days now. I'm beyond pissed. How is it one phone can be delivered but not the other?
Thought about visiting the local corporate ATT store. Walk in, am told by the sales flunkie that they were out of 16 and 32 GB models, but had plenty of 64 in stock. I briefly explain my situation, and she is of no help---but took my name and put it in a queue to speak to someone else. While waiting, I notice a number of folks who had never had an iPhone being aggressively pushed on the 64 GB model.
Finally meet with the manager on duty or whatever his title was. He tells me there is no way they can assist me. I'm visibly frustrated, and he can tell. He tries to play off the "promise" that I would have a phone on the 14th. While I acknowledge that I was never promised a phone on launch day, I point out the hypocricy that he stated the best way to insure a phone is to order it on the website. As I am pointing to the customers being rung up for sales on a 64 GB model they probably did not want...I tell him the moral of the story is not to order online if you want a phone and leave.
Next day (October 15) I notice the I had a voicemail on my 3GS. Check it, and it is an automated message from ATT giving me a $50 refund on my next bill, and that I "may" receive my phone on Monday. Hour or so later, I receive an email with a tracking number and a delivery of "by 10:30 am Monday".
So, there was a conclusion to my story. What pisses me are two things:
-Wife and I order at same time, but only one phone is delivered.
-ATT store was of zero help to me.
ATT really needs to clear up their entire ordering/sales/inventory/store situation. Life is not fair, but selling a $400 after subsidized device a week early on the premise that you will receive it on the "launch day" and then not delivering, yet continually keep insisting to a customer that the best way to ensure you get a phone is by ordering it online is piss-poor.