Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
good, i hope you get a perfect MBP you deserve that.

I'd like to think I do when spending £3000 on it.
[doublepost=1533659358][/doublepost]Oh cool so they deliver the new machine and I return the old one once I have set new one up :D sweet! Thats good.
 
On phone to Apple, they said they will arrange a replacement, it will be brand new and not a refurb.

You watch me get a light leak free machine but one with a dead pixel instead lol.

LOL...don't think that. Dead pixels are even rarer nowadays so I have a good feeling you will not get them on your replacement. The 2018 screens are better in quality than the previous years' so there's a good chance your replacement lottery has better odds.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Polaroid
The Apple support girl keeps apologising for being slow cause its her birthday... I don't care if its your birthday! Speed up love.
 
I'd like to think I do when spending £3000 on it.
[doublepost=1533659358][/doublepost]Oh cool so they deliver the new machine and I return the old one once I have set new one up :D sweet! Thats good.

Just for the sake of trying it, I went into a dark closet and checked my MacBook...nothing. Phew. Hope they replace your with one without a leak.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: donster28
Hopefully its an isolated incident then lol.

Well Apple were great, They have ordered my new machine, I pick that up in store and take home, they are supplying a cable to connect the two machines to transfer data and I return the old machine when the new ones all set up. Not bad tbh!
 
Hopefully its an isolated incident then lol.

Well Apple were great, They have ordered my new machine, I pick that up in store and take home, they are supplying a cable to connect the two machines to transfer data and I return the old machine when the new ones all set up. Not bad tbh!
That's great indeed! Great service from a trillion dollar company hehe. Update us on the new machine! Good luck!
 
The Apple support girl keeps apologising for being slow cause its her birthday... I don't care if its your birthday! Speed up love.
"bow out the candles, get me my MBP i paid for and meet me for a pint at macgillacuddys at 8, lady"
[doublepost=1533660201][/doublepost]
Hopefully its an isolated incident then lol.

Well Apple were great, They have ordered my new machine, I pick that up in store and take home, they are supplying a cable to connect the two machines to transfer data and I return the old machine when the new ones all set up. Not bad tbh!
this mean you will need to download a flashlight app, ya know
 
Trying to get compensation, they said they have authorisation limit of £80 but trying to get the Apple branded sleeve case lol


-


Wooo They offered me £199 Compensation so I can pick anything to that value off the Apple Store :D
 
Last edited:
You're referring to 2017 MBP's which do have backlight bleed problems. The 2018's are different!

I did all the testing on mine with a pure black screen with the old "iMac Yellow Test Website":
http://imac.squeaked.com/test.php

Also, I wouldn't use YouTube as a test for pure black.

Believe me, when I say there is no "perceivable" light bleed, there is none on mine and the one that it replaced with a slightly creaking chassis.


Your 2018 has some light bleeding... It has to because its an LCD screen. The severity is a different issue.
[doublepost=1533662052][/doublepost]
Again, mine does not exhibit any backlight issue...and again, do not generalize and be sure they all have it. I am trying to resolve my picture attaching issue here on Macrumors and I will show you mine.

I've had mine replaced and the first one I had did not exhibit any issues either...nor 3 of my friends'. Believe me, we work with video and photos and the first thing we check is the screen's consistency.


You clearly have no clue what you're talking about. Light bleeding is in every LCD device if you want to go looking for it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Painter2002
Maybe I used wrong terms but light is bleeding through the casing :p
No, you use the correct verbiage. I don't know how else you could describe it, some people don't read closely enough and/or just kind of like going off topic.

In any case that is most definitely a defect, and I am sorry you have to setup your machine all over again. Hopefully the new machine won't have the issue!
 
  • Like
Reactions: donster28
Your 2018 has some light bleeding... It has to because its an LCD screen. The severity is a different issue.
[doublepost=1533662052][/doublepost]


You clearly have no clue what you're talking about. Light bleeding is in every LCD device if you want to go looking for it.

Sorry but you cannot expect me to believe you if you generalize. Not all backlight bleed is visible to the naked eye...I am talking about backlight bleed that is visible and bothersome, nothing more, nothing less. I'm not gonna be scientific as you are suggesting me to be because we are not talking about exact specifics here. What's in the word "perceivable" do you not get?

My eyes (and all of my colleagues') are not seeing backlight bleed on my 2018 unit. My 2015, on the other hand had a slight bleed on the right top corner...it was subtle but it was still there and it did bother me a little...but I did not want to play the lottery game then because most of the other units I saw had worse.

Do not judge me to be wrong because I'm not! And as on owner of an OLED TV, LED TV, a photographer, a videographer and an avid movie viewer I do know what I'm talking about.
 
Last edited:
Sorry but you cannot expect me to believe you if you generalize. Not all backlight bleed is visible to the naked eye...I am talking about backlight bleed that is visible and bothersome, nothing more, nothing less. I'm not gonna be scientific as you are suggesting me to be because we are not talking about exact specifics here. What's in the word "perceivable" do you not get?

My eyes (and all of my colleagues') are not seeing backlight bleed on my 2018 unit. My 2015, on the other hand a a slight bleed on the right top corner...it was subtle but it was still there and did bother me. But I did not want to play the lottery game then because most of the units I saw had worse.

Do not judge me to be wrong because I'm not! And as on owner of an OLED TV, LED TV, a photographer, a videographer and an avid movie viewer I do know what I'm talking about.

Omg you own an OLED tv? Congratulations? Problem is they have no backlight bleeding because it doesn’t have a backlight. You could be a photographer but who says you’re a good one ( or bad). Saying this on the internet means nothing. And you’re wrong 100%. Every screen that uses LCD ( or LED which is just LCD anyways ) will have some sort of backlight bleeding issues. Trust me 100% I’ll find some sort of it on your laptop I can guarantee that. If you aren’t going OCD on it and it’s not bad to begin with you won’t notice it but it’s there somewhere.
 
Sorry but you cannot expect me to believe you if you generalize. Not all backlight bleed is visible to the naked eye...I am talking about backlight bleed that is visible and bothersome, nothing more, nothing less. I'm not gonna be scientific as you are suggesting me to be because we are not talking about exact specifics here. What's in the word "perceivable" do you not get?

My eyes (and all of my colleagues') are not seeing backlight bleed on my 2018 unit. My 2015, on the other hand a a slight bleed on the right top corner...it was subtle but it was still there and did bother me. But I did not want to play the lottery game then because most of the units I saw had worse.

Do not judge me to be wrong because I'm not! And as on owner of an OLED TV, LED TV, a photographer, a videographer and an avid movie viewer I do know what I'm talking about.

Omg you own an OLED tv? Congratulations? Problem is they have no backlight bleeding because it doesn’t have a backlight. You could be a photographer but who says you’re a good one ( or bad). Saying this on the internet means nothing. And you’re wrong 100%. Every screen that uses LCD ( or LED which is just LCD anyways ) will have some sort of backlight bleeding issues. Trust me 100% I’ll find some sort of it on your laptop I can guarantee that. If you aren’t going OCD on it and it’s not bad to begin with you won’t notice it but it’s there somewhere.
 
Omg you own an OLED tv? Congratulations? Problem is they have no backlight bleeding because it doesn’t have a backlight. You could be a photographer but who says you’re a good one ( or bad). Saying this on the internet means nothing. And you’re wrong 100%. Every screen that uses LCD ( or LED which is just LCD anyways ) will have some sort of backlight bleeding issues. Trust me 100% I’ll find some sort of it on your laptop I can guarantee that. If you aren’t going OCD on it and it’s not bad to begin with you won’t notice it but it’s there somewhere.

You really don't get it do you? I threw in an OLED in there to let you know my eyes know what to look for. You don't need to teach me how OLED's work.

I will not debate with you on how to look for backlight bleeding because you seem to be set on what you believe in. Have a nice day.

Oh and just for giggles...
perceivable - capable of being perceived especially by sight or hearing; "perceivable through the mist" perceptible - capable of being perceived by the mind or senses; "a perceptible limp"; "easily perceptible sounds"; "perceptible changes in behavior" 2. perceivable - capable of being apprehended or understood.
 
You really don't get it do you? I threw in an OLED in there to let you know my eyes know what to look for. You don't need to teach me how OLED's work.

Having said that, I will not debate with you on how to look for backlight bleeding because you seem to be set on what you believe. Have a nice day.

You can believe what you want but you’re wrong. You’re preaching wrong info
 
LOL...don't think that. Dead pixels are even rarer nowadays so I have a good feeling you will not get them on your replacement. The 2018 screens are better in quality than the previous years' so there's a good chance your replacement lottery has better odds.

In my experience, yes - dead pixels are very rare these days. Unfortunately, I can't say the same about dust particles. This brand new 2018 MacBook that I'm typing this on has a tiny dust particle trapped between the LCD display and the surface in the upper left corner. I know it's dust because I can put the very tip of the mouse pointer right underneath, focus my eyes on the pointer, then shift my head left and right while watching the particle move ever so slightly left and right in response due to the parallax while the pointer stays fixed. Oh well. That's my 3rd recent Apple product with this kind of flaw.
 
In my experience, yes - dead pixels are very rare these days. Unfortunately, I can't say the same about dust particles. This brand new 2018 MacBook that I'm typing this on has a tiny dust particle trapped between the LCD display and the surface in the upper left corner. I know it's dust because I can put the very tip of the mouse pointer right underneath, focus my eyes on the pointer, then shift my head left and right while watching the particle move ever so slightly left and right in response due to the parallax while the pointer stays fixed. Oh well. That's my 3rd recent Apple product with this kind of flaw.

Now that's a different kind of evil. I do believe there will be other kinds of defects like dust caught in between...remember when Apple screens used to have a slight gap in between layers? Now they're supposed to be fused but factories can still screw that up by not being totally dust free.
[doublepost=1533664300][/doublepost]
You can believe what you want but you’re wrong. You’re preaching wrong info

Okay then...move on buddy.
 
Again you are talking about the wrong thing. Yes, pretty much every LCD display has some sort of backlight bleed. But again, that is not what this is.

Man, I’m taking about exactly what the OP is talking about. Why do you keep saying I’m talking about the wrong thing? I’m not talking about backlight bleed - I’m talking about the leakage of light around the bezel. Always have been.
[doublepost=1533665480][/doublepost]
MY previous Mac Book Pro never had this issue :p just saying ;) and also I checked Apple store and they down seem to have any of these issues.

How can you possibly have checked in the Apple Store?! Did you break in at night? ;)
 
Man, I’m taking about exactly what the OP is talking about. Why do you keep saying I’m talking about the wrong thing? I’m not talking about backlight bleed - I’m talking about the leakage of light around the bezel. Always have been.

It's been a confusing thread indeed with people thinking this and that.

I admit, I'm guilty of assuming the OP was talking about backlight bleed. Should have read the title better myself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Painter2002
Relax..? I have a faulty £3000 Laptop, that's not acceptable and I have every right to post about it and question if it's an isolated issue.

You don’t, though, as I fear you’ll find out when you get your replacement. I mean, you might get one with less of it, I guess, but I’ll bet it has it to some extent.
 
You don’t, though, as I fear you’ll find out when you get your replacement. I mean, you might get one with less of it, I guess, but I’ll bet it has it to some extent.

Apples admitted its a fault and have ordered me a new laptop and given me £199 in gift cards as an apology, I doubt they would do all that if it was NOT a fault. lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: donster28
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.