Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Would Apple have the legal right to remove those old "purchases" from their App Store? Absolutely not. No company would have that right. People like myself actually PAID for many of these products. And even if customers have obtained those products free of charge or as part of a hard- and software bundle, all applicable laws (and even Apple!) still define this as a "PURCHASE" - with the implicit transfer of ownership of usage rights. Nobody has leased or rented that software from Apple - all customers obtained software licenses that were not limited to a specific time window.
The EULA for the AppStore does state that they can remove software whenever they feel like it. Now you could try sueing to see if you could get that portion struck down, but I don't think you'd be likely to get that far.
 
  • Like
Reactions: arefbe
How do we now back them up? Just copy the icon from the applications folder and hope it didn't have any dependencies in other folders?

You have to copy off the installer, prior to installation. If memory serves (Google is your friend here) you cancel the install, then backup the installer (backup drive) - you're good if you need it again in the future - then relaunch the installer and let it do its thing (after which it will delete itself).

Frankly, since Mavericks is still being supported (security updates etc.) for another year this was almost certainly not intentional, but its a good wake up call to those of us who want back up installers of things (make backups as you do installs). I'm running Mountain Lion, will be going to 10.11 after release, but have installers backed up to take me to Mavericks instead if I have any incompatibility issues with applications I use.

Tomorrow, Mavericks will enter the "officially unsupported" product phase, because tomorrow, Yosemite and El Capitan will be the only two supported versions of OS X. So, yes, someone might have prematurely flipped the kill switch. But that does not make it a bug.

I believe since Apple went to yearly Mac OS updates, they also went to giving security updates (supported) for the last 3 releases (Mountain Lion has still been getting security updates through last month, but it should fall off the truck with 10.11 getting released)....this was a change from when they did 2-3 year releases of OS X.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: OttawaGuy
Lol just another day in Cupertino. Making arrogant decisions then backpedalling right after.

OMG... Really? Sorry... but this sort of attitude is silly. My goodness, they we're probably just doing maintenance on the App Store in prep for El Capitan's release.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5aga
There, now people can make backups of their software, and perhaps stop complaining when Apple finally takes down the stuff that was largely FREE to begin with.

Actually, many people paid good money for Aperture. Also, while it hasn't been widely reported, Logic Pro 9, which was $200 also vanished. Logic Pro downloads additional content after installation, so is harder to back up.
 
Let's not forget the unapologetic 16GB storage on a phone that records 4K videos
Apple should update the base storage to at least 32 GB but the reason they go with 16GB is that most people with a 16GB iPhone do not use all their storage. Maybe if there was more people would use more but Apple collects data from the phones and uses that the gauge usage. If we really want larger storage on the base model it's time to encourage the majority of people with iPhones to fill up their phones to capacity.

Most people will not use all their storage and most people will not record in 4K (you have to turn it on in the camera settings).
 
There, now people can make backups of their software, and perhaps stop complaining when Apple finally takes down the stuff that was largely FREE to begin with.
The problem is that people bought hardware that came with this software, but it also came with no physical copy of it (There was a short period where they included flash drives, but that ended quickly.) So now a user has no way of restoring their machine to its original state.

Also the issue is with removing paid software at all, and it is something we haven't dealt with yet. Setting a precedent of digital software being able to just randomly disappear because it is old is something that we don't want as users.
 
10.7, released four years ago.

My dad has a version of Wordstar on 3.5" floppy drives. Wonder if I can complain why I can't run it on my OS.

That is a different story....
Immagine you find your dad's old computer and you cannot boot it up, so you look for the OS floppy but someone just took it away..... you had the licence for it, simply there's no way to download it again ... now would you complain then?
 
It doesn't mean Apple should provide the download link forever. I think it's enough if done for warranty period.

I understand what you're saying but in place of physical media purchases I think cloud digital content providers need to be ready to provide the same service, that is to provide access to the content that the user purchased rights to use, for as long as that user needs. Or at bare minimum to notify the user well in advance of when exactly each piece of content will be removed from the store. I would think several notifications over the course of 6 months would be sufficient.
 
To the smug -

There are a lot of reasons why (and you can see the previous thread) business users and others still rely on the ability to run legacy OS versions. Legitimate reasons beyond not "feeling" like upgrading.

It's amazing how narrow-sighted some people are. Only able to see their own use case and no one else's.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ravenstar
Let's not forget the unapologetic 16GB storage on a phone that records 4K videos
Again, nobody is putting a gun to your head. 32 GB isn't enough if you plan on using 4K, either. So, either you're suggesting 64 GB should be the base model or you're just complaining to get likes. The base model is for people like me who get iPhones for their jobs.
 
Tomorrow, Mavericks will enter the "officially unsupported" product phase, because tomorrow, Yosemite and El Capitan will be the only two supported versions of OS X. So, yes, someone might have prematurely flipped the kill switch. But that does not make it a bug.
You're mixed up. Unless things change tomorrow, Apple supports the current and the previous 2 versions of operating system, so starting tomorrow, the supported versions of OS X will be 10.9.5, 10.10.5, and 10.11.
There are already betas of Safari 9 for 10.9.5 (but not 10.8.5) so I would say it's safe to assume this pattern will continue.
 
Last edited:
Tomorrow, Mavericks will enter the "officially unsupported" product phase, because tomorrow, Yosemite and El Capitan will be the only two supported versions of OS X. So, yes, someone might have prematurely flipped the kill switch. But that does not make it a bug.
Even if, does not mean my old computer will:
A) Explode
B) Stop working all together
C) Stop needing a reinstall from time to time...

So Apple can stop "supporting" all they want and not release new fixes, but that does not mean they need to prevent me from using a perfectly fine computer (for my needs) by not allowing me a complete format and reinstall of OS and App that were compatible with that computer (and that i bought).

Heck in my studio we still have a 512K and a Classic....Hypercard is still living!!

(On another note I am sure waiting for Skylake MacBook Pro!!!!!)
 
  • Like
Reactions: ravenstar
There, now people can make backups of their software, and perhaps stop complaining when Apple finally takes down the stuff that was largely FREE to begin with.
And majority of people are right to complain. It shouldn't be a hassle to install an older OS. There are plenty of people here who rely on software that is only compatible with say, 10.8.

Additionally, if I'm running an older Mac, I shouldn't be forced to upgrade to a newer OS.
 
There, now people can make backups of their software, and perhaps stop complaining when Apple finally takes down the stuff that was largely FREE to begin with.

FREE? Aperture was FREE? The OS that came with my machine was also FREE? Damn, I missed out on these FREE offers!
 
Um. Did I not read something? So if I didn't update Aperture before I upgraded OSX, can I not update Aperture now? If you are going to go through the trouble to allow access to an app you removed from the app store, why not make the updates available too. I paid $199 for this software, and it was killed with no warning from Apple.

Thanks MacRumors for reopening a wound. Thanks again Apple for giving it to me.
 
Let's not forget the unapologetic 16GB storage on a phone that records 4K videos

My car can do 140mph but the maximum I do is half of that. Just because a feature is there doesn't mean that people use it. The majority of iPhone users just use it as a phone to make calls and texts, maybe the odd app and photo. Many people buy the iPhone because it's fashionable to own one, not because they are using it to its fullest potential.

No sane "proper" user would buy the 16Gb model and then complain about lack of storage.

Many other people simply just don't want to do a load of stuff on a small screen and have an iPad for that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: arefbe and 8692574
My car can do 140mph but the maximum I do is half of that. Just because a feature is there doesn't mean that people use it. The majority of iPhone users just use it as a phone to make calls and texts, maybe the odd app and photo. Many people buy the iPhone because it's fashionable to own one, not because they are using it to its fullest potential.

No sane "proper" user would buy the 16Gb model and then complain about lack of storage.

Many other people simply just don't want to do a load of stuff on a small screen and have an iPad for that.
I would say 16 GB is perfect for a business person who use the phone for what it was ment to .... work.... that means Emails Phonecalls and some internet (nowadays most business use socials and stuff even for marketing).

16 Gb for them is more than enought! For everything else ? there's Mastercard..... i ment..there's option to get bigger versions!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.