Okay, here's the deal
The att next plan isn't much different from the two year contracts in terms of what you pay. You can STILL keep your unlimited data plan if you have that already.. THAT is what's not going away.
You have an extra payment with your monthly service plan but you're not paying anything out of pocket to get the phone, (except the tax) AND activation fee was lowered to $15 on NEXT..
It's only more expensive if you want a phone every year instead of every two years, but if you're wanting a two year contract anyway, it's not going to make any difference.
The thing is that Next is, obviously, not good for everybody such as myself. So it is quite different, especially in cost. Sure with either Next or 2yr contract I can keep my unlimited data, thats fine.
It's the roughly $370 I pay for the phone out of pocket when I sign a new 2 year that makes the difference. With Next, what I would end up paying after 12 months for the phone to upgrade again, is more than $400, and I don't get to keep the phone. At least with the two year I can sell it and essentially make that money back if I wanted to. I have 2 lines, which have staggered upgrade years, so every year I can get the newest iPhone at subsidy, keeping unlimited data on my line while keeping the phone. It makes sense for me and it's unfortunate that my only option to keep it this way is through a corporate store or ATT's website only.