Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Huawei already have their own OS for the phones. All they need is to port a couple of the usual apps that people use (FB, Insta, WA, Netflix, Snapchat). How many people who don't give a hoot about privacy but just want a cheap phone to blast their life onto the internet with above apps are going to bite?
[doublepost=1558366762][/doublepost]
You really think people in the west or Africa will buy Chinese phones with Chinese OS? Lol yeah right.

This step is long overdue.


Most people in the West are incredibly stupid. They'll just use the WhatsApp app on the phone.
If it works, they don't care.


They didn't care when they signed up to Google and Facebook.
Huawei just needs to display a huge banner on every startup that says "Your data is secure, we promise".

People believe what they want to be true.


And in Africa, they have no choice. Nobody buys an iPhone there, unless they're really rich.
 
And yet America has provided zero evidence, to its citizens or to its allies, that Huawei represents a national security to our country or to our allies. Apparently Huawei's crime was taking the worldwide lead in 5G technology, both in terms of patents and shipping products, in a era where free-market beliefs have been supplanted with nationalistic protectionism.

It's just like most things the government investigates especially concerning national security matters.

Giving the evidence would eventually give away sources. People can either believe or not believe the government.
 
You really think people in the west or Africa will buy Chinese phones with Chinese OS? Lol yeah right.

This step is long overdue.

What next..? An all outright ban on Windows,Android and Apple to all Chinese in China for retail and manufacturing..?

I don’t think this is right as provocative measures along with incitement lead to ugly trade wars and in trade wars there really are no winners as both sides suffer losses. In the end the consumer pays the consequences
 
  • Like
Reactions: AleRod
Fat's in the fire now. I can't decide whether this is good or bad. Hopefully the PRC will see reason in that even if tariffs are removed their government's unfair trade practices are giving the PRC a bad reputation, and they might well face a consumer boycott in the West.
 
...and that will eventually push chinese companies to be less reliant on US, by building their own techs. Which means initial trouble but stronger future for China.
Don't you mean by building our reverse-engineered tech, for their own use? That's been just about the only way they've "invented" anything beyond a bottle rocket.
 
Ultimately a dumb move. Anyway, your loss in the US. Huawei is the fastest growing smartphone company in the world and has some truly awesome devices that we are able to enjoy here in Europe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AleRod
This is a fun story to follow.
The world changes. China becomes big and is communist.

The European idiots are completely surrendering China and will become an communist protectorate.

Wonder what my American friends will do, if they will save Europe again.

Russia will fall first, or doesn’t matter anyways because they are just to primitive to survive.

Wonder what will happen to Africa?
 
Imagine a world where Apple and Google captured the same amount of private information about you as they do right now (including location services, access to your phone's data remotely, etc.) -- except they willingly share it with the United States government upon ANY request (be it national security or otherwise), with no need for a court order or due process.

That's the reality for Chinese companies like Huawei.

The fact that you don’t think Google isn’t doing equivalent wrong is very worrisome. Google and Facebook are the real enemies to American people.
 
You really think people in the west or Africa will buy Chinese phones with Chinese OS? Lol yeah right.

This step is long overdue.
chinese companies have a much more established presence in africa than any western companies, oppo and other smaller players even manufacture their phones there, not to mention cars and railroads built by the chinese govt.

as for europe, huawei is one of the top sellers there, alot of folks there using honor or mate 20 pro. i was surprised myself.
[doublepost=1558368545][/doublepost]
Don't you mean by building our reverse-engineered tech, for their own use? That's been just about the only way they've "invented" anything beyond a bottle rocket.
that used to be the case but chinese tech are quite up there now, even surpassing west in multi fields. the oh they can only copy and produce cheap stuffs and not invent used to be the saying for japanese goods back in the 70s and 80s. but now the tech in asia has surpassed many westerns, how can you steal something that they dont even have?
 
But they have shows a blatant disregard for the law throughout their history.
They have stolen trade secrets and copied product from Cisco and others.
This isn't speculation but fact.

And we've done the same thing. Furthermore, we are fine propping up some warlord who keeps things profitable for us, but when we don't like how others are conducting their business, we simply swoop in and "bring democracy." We don't give a hoot about others' laws, and given our sudden need to charge money for someone to request asylum (upending centuries of international practice) we don't have any right to whine now about, frankly, ANY foreign actor.
 
Precisely. The focus needs to be far more diligent on protection of intellectual property. They are the global leader in technology theft.
Do we have to get into that? The concept of intellectual property couldn't be any more outdated. Apple itself is built on "stolen" IP anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AleRod
It's just like most things the government investigates especially concerning national security matters.

Giving the evidence would eventually give away sources. People can either believe or not believe the government.
After that UN WMD show that Powell putted unfortunately (i say that because in the end the USA is an completely incomparable country to something like Russia or China) the USA's word is not worth much.
And that is one of the reasons why not a single European country cared much about this Huawei thing. Not even the UK. Of course knowing for a fact that the USA was the country that indeed tapped European phones and listened to elected people of allied countries didn't help a lot.
 
There must be another Trump project that needs a loan.

Quid Pro Quo

https://www.businessinsider.com/tru...ons-to-trump-organization-tied-project-2018-5

Within three days of the Chinese government agreeing to provide $500 million in loans to an Indonesian theme park that the Trump Organization has a deal to license President Donald Trump's name to, the president stunningly ordered sanctions be rescinded against a major Chinese telecom company.

As AFP reported via the South China Morning Post last week, the developer of that project just outside of Jakarta had secured the half billion in funding, in addition to another $500 million from Chinese banks, 72 hours before Trump's Sunday tweet on the Chinese telecom company ZTE. Trump's family business has a deal with that developer to include the Trump name on the resort, which also includes hotels and a golf course.

"President Xi of China, and I, are working together to give massive Chinese phone company, ZTE, a way to get back into business, fast," Trump tweeted Sunday. "Too many jobs in China lost. Commerce Department has been instructed to get it done!"

He added another tweet on the subject Monday, saying that ZTE "buys a big percentage of individual parts from U.S. companies."

"This is also reflective of the larger trade deal we are negotiating with China and my personal relationship with President Xi," he wrote.

 
This is exactly why China is setting up their own banking system and PetroYuan for international trade as the US Banking system poses a national security threat for their international trade and their own national security. They can not allow a foreign like Trump to come along and just sign off on a paper which cripples their manufacturing,trade or banking. China has a lot of things that they are wrong on but also has a lot of things they are right on. It goes both ways depending on which one chooses to look at.
[doublepost=1558365549][/doublepost]
Some Chinese also felt the same way which is why Google,Facebook.Whatsapp,Instagram amongst a few others were not allowed in China ;)
Yep, but I'm not talking about that, but the fact that US spies on their citizens aswell and you're so happy China won't be able to do it.
 
Yep, but I'm not talking about that, but the fact that US spies on their citizens aswell and you're so happy China won't be able to do it.
Maybe there’s a misunderstanding, what do you mean by “you’re so happy China won’t be able to do it”?
 
Imagine a world where Apple and Google captured the same amount of private information about you as they do right now (including location services, access to your phone's data remotely, etc.) -- except they willingly share it with the United States government upon ANY request (be it national security or otherwise), with no need for a court order or due process.

That's the reality for Chinese companies like Huawei.
The same goes for Windows. Remember the NSA private key in windows?
 
  • Like
Reactions: stylinexpat
Who knows how much information was shared.

My point still stands that the US government is not going to supply evidence especially on subjects that they deem national security where sources can be compromised.

You either believe them or you don't.

The UK is our closest ally and within the inner circle who we share our most sensitive intelligence information. If they saw nothing from America's intelligence agencies to be concerned about for their own security then that tells me who to believe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Queen6 and Gasu E.
Who knows how much information was shared.

My point still stands that the US government is not going to supply evidence especially on subjects that they deem national security where sources can be compromised.

You either believe them or you don't.
apparently germany, france, england dont lol
 
apparently germany, france, england dont lol
You're being disingenuous.

The countries you listed, while not outright banning Huawei, still question the security of their equipment and are looking at methods to mitigate potential risks.

You also left out the countries that do currently ban Huawei.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.