Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I have a very expensive Sony Bravia Android TV, and the app experience sucks in comparison to the TvOS experience. For that reason all of my TVs have an Apple TV 4K attached to them.

An Apple TV app, does not replace nor is it a substitute for the TVOS experience. It is simply a method for those without Apple TVs to access Apple content. That would be like thinking that making Apple Music available on other platforms means “Apple is phasing out the iPhone”. Many will still want the full experience and the Apple device. Seems you don’t really understand the value of Apple products.

that was a terrible comparison, given that an iphone is a standalone product, while the atv needs a tv to function. but i get your point. of course i don't, only really smart kids do. be a little more open minded - not everyone approaches their setup the same way.

oh, but thanks for sharing your bravia experience, i love sony tv's and my next one was/is going to be one, so good to know.
 
Air Playing music to a tv makes no sense. Air Playing to good speakers makes sense. That means Apple TV is always the best choice... for little money

I imagine many people have an ARC setup or at least an optical out from the TV to a receiver to handle the sound.

I have a QN75Q65FN and it updated fine and pushes the audio to my receiver via an ARC connection.

No apple TV required.

However, the limitations of this setup won't make me get rid of my Apple TV. I have quite a substantial movie collection in my iTunes library along with home videos that aren't accessible through the Samsung. So, I'll stick with ATV for now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: alexandr
It's prob set to a auto update..the new version of firmware is 1251..you just need that..if it is not working, hold down the power button for 10 secs or so to reset the tv. Mine is a 2018 6 series and works for me.
How is yours working? I have my TV on that update and i can not connect.
 
that was a terrible comparison, given that an iphone is a standalone product, while the atv needs a tv to function. but i get your point. of course i don't, only really smart kids do. be a little more open minded - not everyone approaches their setup the same way.

oh, but thanks for sharing your bravia experience, i love sony tv's and my next one was/is going to be one, so good to know.

My closed-mindedness was no more than yours for thinking that people who buy an Apple TV because they want the TV app.

Of course some people would only use the TV app, but I highly doubt they are someone who would’ve bought an Apple TV in the first place. — Those who buy an Apple TV are willing to pay the money for the tvOS experience (or Apple brand), they don’t typically buy it for one app, and therefore there is no way that Apple would be phasing out a device due to the release of only one app.

Sony’s android experience is close to stock Android TV, which I have not found pleasant at all. The issues with Android apps are prevalent whether it’s Sony’s TV or the Firestick. No matter how well it’s coded Java will always be clunky, so long as Java is being used to render the interface. If Java is handing it off to another handler then it’s not as clunky / sluggish (but still is). The poor app experience is why Android moved to Kotlin instead of Java. Java was a poor UX choice to begin with, and I say this as a Java developer (but I understand the desire to use a universal language, that developers around the world could use).

LG’s TV experience is much better than Android TV, but app availability would cause me to choose an Android TV before an LG (if I weren’t using an external device). I’d rather have the apps I want to use, and deal with the poor Android TV experience. Android TV apps tend to force-quit pretty often, but I don’t think it’s inherently a problem with Android TV per se, it’s more of a lack of developer skill problem (be it because they aren’t programmatically handling memory well, or because of bugs in their code). Those same apps never crash on tvOS, the codebase is obviously different but the fluidity of the interface and stability of apps in my opinion puts tvOS leagues beyond Android TV. It’s not something that you can just throw a faster processor or more RAM at to fix, what i’m speaking of exists even with the fastest processors and highest refresh rates. I can still perceive the clunkiness. Perhaps it’s only because I am a developer that I even notice those nuances.

Regardless, most of the people with Apple TVs will not be giving up their Apple TV due to the release of a single app, and many people will continue to buy Apple TVs, even if they don’t see the clunkiness that I do. The iOS, tvOS, etc experience is just more pleasant. Even Android appreciators like MKBHD can see the difference between IG on iOS versus java Android.
 
Last edited:
So Beancounter Tim's plan is to commoditize Apple's ecosystem to the point that you can be an "Apple fan" while buying hardware from Apple's single largest competitor. This definitely isn't what SJ meant when he said they'd cracked the television problem.
You can still be an Apple fan only because while watching Apple streaming content you won’t see android tech reviewed or any other tech except for Apple tech being reviewed.
And you won’t be able to watch shows that have Apple trademarks in the name so no shows called “iOS today” from Leo Laporte such is Apple’s Dictatorship
 
It's nice having AirPlay on my TV, not that I ever missed it up to this point but it's still inferior to Chromecast in many ways because it's just mirroring.
 
never got myself an apple tv as i never saw enough reasons to, and i'm kind of glad they are phasing it out.
Dont be a fool. The  TV is as excellent as ever. This TV service , is just to make  Services money.
[doublepost=1558046282][/doublepost]
You can still be an Apple fan only because while watching Apple streaming content you won’t see android tech reviewed or any other tech except for Apple tech being reviewed.
And you won’t be able to watch shows that have Apple trademarks in the name so no shows called “iOS today” from Leo Laporte such is Apple’s Dictatorship
So edgy dude. Go buy something else if you feel so trapped.
 


There are dedicated sections for "Watch Now," Movies, TV Shows, Kids, Library, Search, and Settings, and the app offers up access to all of the iTunes content that you've previously purchased. You can also purchase or rent new movies within the app.

Well I hope Apple is giving Samsung a 30% cut on everything sold on a Samsung TV. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: jeffbax
Does anyone know if the AP2 TV's can push audio from non-apple content displayed on the TV (i.e. Dish, Xbox, etc.) to other AP2 devices?

I thought that with AirPlay 2 the TV could send the sound from the built in YouTube app to my HomePod but not. It’s only a receiver. Major disappointment.
 
i think they slowly are. i mean who's going to want to pay money for something that takes up room, when your tv has all of the same functions?

That’s like saying in the 2000’s “why get a Mac if iTunes is now on Windows?”.

tvOS is more than just the Apple TV app. With Apple Arcade coming, there’ll be even more of a reason to get a new Apple TV. Contrary to what you’re suggesting, Apple is not only not discontinuing the Apple TV, they’re likely going to release a new one this Fall, capable of running the games that’ll come with Apple Arcade.

The reason Apple TV is being released widely on third parties is because Apple is entering the subscription tv streaming business. If they want to have a chance of competing with Netflix and Disney+, they’ll have to be available on all the same platforms, the same way Apple Music is on Android to compete with Spotify.
 
If it is a 2018 6 series (mine is) the most p-to-date firmware is V1251 which is what makes the TV compatible with the Apple TV App. What is the latest firmware available for your TV and are you dead positive it is a 2018 or later model. it is possible you have firmware 1251 but have not added the Apple TV app on your TV yet.
Checked again and it definitely isn’t there and I’m sure I’m on 1251. Samsung support has definitely not been helpful.
 

Attachments

  • 2EF7771E-D230-4D8B-9E00-50B0D77A0C6D.jpeg
    2EF7771E-D230-4D8B-9E00-50B0D77A0C6D.jpeg
    120.9 KB · Views: 228
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Keane16
Check again and it definitely isn’t there and I’m sure I’m on 1251. Samsung support has definitely not been helpful.

Okay, please give me the full model number, for example mine is QN65Q6FNAFXZA. You can find this information on the TV itself or. you should have written it in your manual.

If you are on 1251 (I believe you) and your TV is supposed to support the new Apple TV app then on the TV, navigate to your apps where you add new apps and you should be able to find it.
 
Strange that the TV app isn't available on older models. I have a 2016 KS8000 and I see no good reason they couldn't build an app for that. I can understand Airplay 2, if there are hardware limitations. Guess I'll have to not use the app on my Apple TV instead.
I have the same TV, so I understand your frustration. While the older models probably could support the new features, I highly doubt that they would bother developing and testing/supporting such a large upgrade on a device that is no longer produced. There is essentially no value in it for Samsung.
 
why does the new iOS not allow me to turn my apple tv on and off with siri or allow me to add my apple tv to home kit scenes? whenever my apple tv turns on it turns on my sony tv and when I turn off my apple tv it turns off my sony tv. I don't see why apple is adding this functionality to third party devices and not their own set top box.
 
I bought two new Samsungs last week. The big QLED Q80 75” had both AppleTv and Airplay out of the box, but the 43” 7100 did not. Quick firmware update and it was there.

I guess its nice for playing Apple purchases or rentals, but i haven't found a way to play my iTunes content via home sharing, so i guess my AppleTv will stick around, though all the streaming services are much better on the TV than the AppleTv4K.

Still waiting for Plex client for the Q80, though it is available for the 7100. Not sure why the difference sine the OS is the same.
[doublepost=1558059503][/doublepost]
I have a very expensive Sony Bravia Android TV, and the app experience sucks in comparison to the TvOS experience. For that reason all of my TVs have an Apple TV 4K attached to them.

An Apple TV app, does not replace nor is it a substitute for the TVOS experience. It is simply a method for those without Apple TVs to access Apple content. That would be like thinking that making Apple Music available on other platforms means “Apple is phasing out the iPhone”. Many will still want the full experience and the Apple device. Seems you don’t really understand the value of Apple products.

I retired a very nice 65” Sony Bravia because of the horrid AndroidTv Os. Constant reboots and app crashes. Would have been a great TV with a decent OS
 
No update available yet for the 2018 UHD 6 Series for me

Same for me. Just got off Samsung Support Chat. This is what they told me:

9:16 PM

Current AirPlay is only available for 2019 model TVs. It is still being worked on for 2018 model TVs.

Once the update is available for 2018 models, AirPlay option will be available on your TVs Settings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: uptownjimmy
Maybe one day there will be one TV that can do both things... TV App and Airplay2.
 
I'm still going to use the Apple TV hardware because I don't trust these TV manufacturers further than I can throw them. A lot of the included OS out there are spyware and adware. I prefer to never boot into those and never give them access to my network. Everything I need is on the Apple TV hardware. I prefer a dumb display. I wish there was a way to get a TV with nice image quality that just doesn't include the extra garbage.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Meuti
I wish there was a way to filter out all of the stuff that I can't watch without paying. It's annoying to still see so much "pay-required" content integrated in with stuff that is either free to watch, owned, or a part of an existing subscription. Is there "cord cutter" type term for people who heave their streaming device through a window?

The entire reason the app exists is a way to get people to buy or rent content! You'll notice that the only things that show up in your library are things purchased, not anything acquired from other sources.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Unity451
I thought that with AirPlay 2 the TV could send the sound from the built in YouTube app to my HomePod but not. It’s only a receiver. Major disappointment.

That’s too bad. The ATV can push audio to other AP2 devices. It would be amazing if I could push anything playing on a AP2 compatible TV to other AP2 devices.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.