These threads pop up every year across multiple media. Take better care of your device.
If you're worried, get a tempered glass screen protector. They are amazing these days and if you go to an Apple store, they'll install it for you.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone 11 Pro iPhone 11 Series "Scratch Gate"
- Thread starter soft99
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
If you're worried, get a tempered glass screen protector. They are amazing these days and if you go to an Apple store, they'll install it for you.
LOL
Is pointless trying to share experiences here. I have owned iPhone since the very first one. I take great care of my devices. This one is different. How is that so hard to comprehend??
You're the guy that was so proud about going caseless.
Now you're paying for your mistake
That’s my point. I have done that for years! And now this happened. That’s exactly my point. Get it now?
This is a very good post that explains precisely what is going on, but it appears some people have skimmed past your point.
A hard gemstone like a diamond or quarts resists scratching, as does very hardened glass. But the harder these substances are, the easier they are to shatter. They’re essentially brittle. The hardness makes them vulnerable to other kinds of forces.
Yes you could carry the older phones with harder glass without a screen protector and not get much in the way of scratching. But if you were to drop one, your phone was at a much increased risk of chipping or shattering than it is now.
So over the years the industry worked on formulating glass with less brittleness. To do that, they had to incorporate polymers that introduced softness.
So, what we have now are phones that are more likely to survive impacts from dropping, but they will be more likely to scratch. The glass is softer. Being softer imparts a degree of flexibility in the glass that is better for absorbing the forces of impact without shattering.
Putting a screen protector on one of the older phones really didn’t gain you that much. Impacts could still be devastating.
But now you’ve got a display that is more resistant to impacts. And when you put a screen protector on you also get protection from scratches. Win-win.
I happen to use a full screen protector (does not have a cut out for the notch) made by ESR. It is compatible with all of my cases so far and is smooth and a pleasure to type on. I can’t even tell it is on there.
Eventually it will accumulate some scratches itself and I will put a fresh one on.
No big deal.
I have noticed the oleophobic coatings on iPhones fresh out of the box since last year feel a bit more sticky. Maybe there is some sort of change made to that coating that is undesirable. That’s why I do prefer the feel of the screen protector.
But regarding the quality of the glass itself, it’s the highest it’s ever been for impact resistance.
There is no “gate”.
Some people just need to understand the compromise that’s been made to get a phone that can better withstand drops and hits.
Last edited:
And I'm telling you there's nothing wrong. People like you screw up and post these kinds of threads every year.
iPhone XS screen prone to scratching ? - Apple Community
iPhone 7 screen easily scratched - Apple Community
Some poor soul like you doesn't take care of their brand new $1000 device and it becomes Apple's problem.
And I'm telling you there's nothing wrong. People like you screw up and post these kinds of threads every year.
iPhone XS screen prone to scratching ? - Apple Community
discussions.apple.com
iPhone 7 screen easily scratched - Apple Community
discussions.apple.com
Some poor soul like you doesn't take care of their brand new $1000 device and it becomes Apple's problem.
The reddit link doesn’t work but take both Apple forum links you posted to the one I did and compare the amount of responses.
Look man, lesson learned.
This happens every year. I would strongly recommend a screen protector.
There's really nothing to see here out of the ordinary.
Look, man.
There is something different with these phones. Maybe there’s a batch that’s defective. Maybe this glass for this phone is more prone to scratches. I don’t know but there’s something there. If Apple said that this glass is more prone to scratches it would be done but my experience this year is inconsistent with 10+ years of owning an iPhone. That’s all I’m saying.
I always have a bumper case and screen protector, on every phone I've owned. If you don't want to do that, then select another phone. I wouldn't have an iPhone without one.
I’m glad you see it that way too. Be at least somewhat careful with it it until you can get a case and screen protector for it. It’s the risk of having no case or screen protection on a $1100 phone. I don’t know about anyone else but if I’m spending that much on a phone, I’m going protect it and make sure it looks flawless as long as possible. When I sold my 18 month old iPhone X, not a single scratch, even on the stainless steel. You take care of it, it lasts. Simple as that.
I agree. You are accepting the risk if you carry your phone around entirely naked. You could probably replace all the water in the Great Salt Lake with the tears from those whose unprotected phones have been damaged. That's their choice and it is fine as long as they acknowledge they are taking on that risk.
I have a small weird smudge line mark on the right side of my notch. But it’s only in certain lightening that I see if. I can assume it’s the oleophobic coating. I sometimes can’t even see it unless I find the right light.
Since I’m on Apple upgrade program I’m trying to get over my ocd cause I always return my phone every year.
Also I figure 6 months in if I get more normal wear and tear I can ask Apple for another one.
Since I’m on Apple upgrade program I’m trying to get over my ocd cause I always return my phone every year.
Also I figure 6 months in if I get more normal wear and tear I can ask Apple for another one.
Perhaps apple should take responsibility for using a screen that scratches so easily.
Look up some drop tests for the iPhone 11. They don't break when dropped. The only way that happens is the screen is made of softer material. The screen is more plastic than glass now. Softer materials scratch more easily vs harder materials.
Sure they break. Any phone made of glass can break if dropped.
You do realize iPhone uses the same Gorrila Glass 6 as Samsung, Oppo, OnePlus, Asus, Sony, and Xaomi, right?
I think Apple made the right decision. It’s more shatter proof and a screen protector will protect from scratches. And if you have a really hard drop you just replace the screen protector. It’s ironic the people that don’t like this they don’t want to use a screen protector but with the harder glass it will break easier.
I would actually prefer more scratch resistance to shatter resistance, but I am in the minority on that. I also don't think the scratching is a new issue.
Jerryrigeverything makes yearly videos on screen durability. Nothing has changed this year. Same scratch resistance. Scratches at a level 6 with deeper grooves at a level 7