Well... I've been working on this problem since 9:30am (as of now, nearly 8.5 hours).... and still no resolution.... Now AT&T says I have to go to the closest Apple Store (50 miles away) and get a new phone. Below is a high-level view of what happened.
- Couldn't activate my upgrade from iPhone3G to iPhone4S... SIM card issue noted in previous replies.
- Called AT&T, couldn't get it to work, try again in 1-2 hours.
- Called AT&T again, still couldn't get it to work. AT&T transferred me to 1-800-myiPhone... which sent me to the iPod department, transferred to iPhone department, on hold for 45 minutes to talk to rep, no response.
- Went to AT&T store, they tried for 1.5 hours, finally said 'Since you bought it through Apple.com, you have to go to an Apple Store to replace the phone, we cannot help you.'
- Scheduled an appointment with the closest Apple Store for tomorrow morning (soonest time).
- Called 1-800-myiPhone, put on hold to speak to a rep, but no hold music, just silence... now for 30+ minutes.
I guess I'll have to drive the 100 miles round trip to Apple.... if they tell me to go back to AT&T I will be PISSED!!!!