I agree. I know widgets and customisable home screens are often touted as a big plus on Android, but if I can have access to 324 apps within two taps of my home screen, its not like you have to drill down through endless menus to find things.
Having said that, to cater to those who would like them, I would change it so it worked like this:
- Home screen as is, then swipe left as you do now to move through the pages.
- Swipe right to move to and through any widget style pages, so you could have things on there like weather, notifications, facebook, twitter feeds if that was your thing.
- The option to select either the first existing style page or first new widget style page as your default homescreen.
- Swipe down for the notification centre, which could have more functionality, for example access to a few common settings and the ability to swipe to delete individual notifications.
- Swipe up for the search screen.
That and lose some of the skeuomorphism, and it would probably be improved quite a bit, without losing what keeps it as clean and simple as it currently is.