This is easy.
Go visit the girl in person - with the press in tow.
Don't give an exclusive, but line-up at least one TV station to be there for sure, and give them "front of line" privileges. Send out invitations to the rest of the press.
And then one more special invitation - this one goes to the public relations contact for the local police department.
I can see it now. The guy from How to Catch a Predator knocks on her door. That alone would scare the crap out of me. "I see you have a barely one month old iPhone 4 that's not yours." She runs and is tackled by 2 police officers.