I think you are on the right track, but be careful because some states do charge tax on the full amount upfront. Other considerations: monthly carrier fees may vary whether or not you own the phone or it is one of theirs (option 1 vs. option 2), but this will make the upgrade program a better deal (at least currently, but who knows what the carriers will do). Also, at the end of the two years on option 2, you own a phone, at the end of two years on option 1, you have nothing tangible; some part of less than ½ a phone if you are willing to pay for the rest of it, but nothing tangible you could sell.
Yeah but you could technically pay it off and keep it with option 1 but who wouldn't want to get a new iPhone every year. That's what the conundrum is. It's so lucrative LOL.
iPhone once every two years or iPhone once a year lol