Am I the only one who was kind of put off by this? Like yeah it was funny, but this whole thing kind of felt...forced, for lack of a better term. Having Iovine Cue and St John there just gave off an arrogant vibe. They're management of a company, not celebrities. Idk say what you want but I wasn't a fan of the decision to make this.
It is, to
me, not as compelling an ad as the previous two (the Apple Watch one was particularly well done I thought); the setup is fine, but the scenarios he pitched just didn't resonate with me (they were corny; I like absurdist, but he's no Monty Python). But I don't see
arrogance at all. This wasn't "celebs sit around and come up with ideas" (with the Apple folks pretending to be celebs), it was a comedian trying to pitch ad ideas to the folks in charge at a company. He's on one side of the table, full of wacky ideas, they're on the other side of the table, looking alternately a bit stern, puzzled, and exasperated. It makes
perfect sense that Iovine, Cue, and St John are there - they are who he'd need to pitch to - the first and last are high-level Apple execs with much sway in regards to Apple Music,
and background in the music industry, and Eddy Cue is there because a) he oversees some of that, b) he's often involved in media negotiations, and c) he has the authority to sign off on things (if he wasn't there, and they accepted one of the pitches - if the scenario was real - the next step would likely be getting him or someone as senior to sign off on it anyway).
What we (tech nerds who not only read MacRumors but pay attention to the comments and forums) see are three very recognizable Apple execs
who are quite plausible/authentic choices for the roles. What the
general public will see on their TV's, in between shows, is a comedian they know, pitching outlandish ad ideas to three people that they'll assume are actors portraying Apple management. I think it's amusing that they got the actual real people to play the roles*.
*: (reminded me a just a bit of an old Rodney Dangerfield movie, "Back to School", where he's a millionaire businessman who has to go to college, and he's throwing money around to get things done for him, and he hires someone to write "his" paper on the novels of Kurt Vonnegut. And, dropping off the finished paper, in walks ... Kurt Vonnegut.)
Also, the bit with James Corden in Bowie makeup
can't be unseen.