I don't think they are garbage, but I do believe they are overpriced, because they have the Apple logo. There are a TON of headphones out there that sound just as good (or better) for less, only thing they are missing is the H1 chip. I feel people that purchase these as their first set of serious headphones are much like people that buy an Apple Watch for the first time, beforehand they wouldn't even consider spending +$400 on a watch, but Apple does such an amazing job of adding functionality and marketing it, people don't think twice.