That’s is a hard choice. I liked the Bullstrap cases I have for my xr when I had it. The buttons were decent and their customer service was always awesome. I do like how their leather appears to look more natural.
That’s the only con I have with the Bullstrap is the buttons. They stick out slightly more than the Apple leather. I just had 3 screenshots taken while in my pocket because of it lol. The buttons just push so easy is all.