The cost difference is not as big as it seems, especially if you are planning to keep your phone more than a year. I have owned many BS and RL cases and in my experience they are very close but not the same. The BS leather feels better over time for whatever reason and how can you not like the warranty which if you really wanted to can use to your advantage in selling one of your 2 yearly cosmetic replacements to offset the cost. The fact is no one pays the full retail as there is always a promo code anyway or when you setup an account you can spend a few minutes doing the one off items and accumulate enough rewards for $10 to $20 off. That being said, RL are great cases for the price point. I just found way more manufacturing issues on them and being in the US, I wasn't even going down that road of returning them. I am also curious to see how BS full coverage leather cases look when they release later this year.