Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
While the Pixel 2 XL's LG OLED screens were generally panned, as others have suggested, the OLED panels Apple will be getting will be held to a much higher standard.

Samsung's OLED panels for the iPhone X incorporate Apple-licensed and patented technology not available on the OLED panels Samsung uses on the Galaxy family and this is why a number of reviews rate the iPhone X panel higher than the Galaxy.

Apple invested almost $3 billion into LG so it's assured that a fair bit of this money was to ensure the panels they make for the "iPhone XL" will be of the best quality.
 
As long as the quality is the same then it doesn't matter if you get Samsung or LG OLED panel on the new iPhones. However, if either one of the brands fail, I can see users blaming the company and let Apple off the hook. Do keep in mind that it is Apple making the decision to go with 2 companies.
 
Wonder if and how much LG OLED panels have improved since they seem to be six years behind Samsung and repeating six year old OLED panel issues like the dark blotches.
 
Oh good lord... here we go. Can someone go ahead and start threads for:

How do I tell which panel is in my X2
I've returned 47 iPhone X2s and still haven't gotten a Samsung panel
I've returned 47 iPhone X2s and still haven't gotten a LG panel
Samsung panel better than LG panel on X2
LG panel better than Samsung panel on X2
X2 Panel-gate
I've got green lines on my LG panel
I've got green lines on my LG panel
I've got ghosting on my Samsung panel
I've got ghosting on my Samsung panel
This sucks, I want my money back because I got an LG Panel on my X2
This sucks, I want my money back because I got a Samsung panel on my X2
Lets get a class action suit because of the panel inequality
Why can all the panels just be exactly the same
Displaymate: iPhone X2 LG display is rated the best ever
Displaymate: iPhone X2 Samsung display is rated best ever (posted 4 seconds after the prior thread for correct timing)
Note 9's display is better than X2 LG display

Did I miss any?
 
After seeing the Pixel 2 XL screen and how blue it is, I won’t be getting the plus. I’ll stick to the one with the LCD screen.

Keep in mind the Samsung OLED panels used in the X were significantly less blue than the ones Samsung used in their own phones. This was because those panels were made to Apple's own specifications.

I see no reason why the LG panels would be treated any differently.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Reactions: manu chao
The 6.1" model at $600 will totally crush OLED model sales. I really cant imagine Apple being able to hold back enough features to make a smaller OLED appealing for $300-400 more.

Maybe if they go back to 16 GB, and really go cheap on the display.

If pricing is correct, then the 2017 iPhone X will probably be the best deal, likely to sell between the new 5.8 X and the h6.1 budget model
 
Apple actually giving us a choice!!!!!!. Who says miracles don't happen?
 
Why would you think Apple would accept panels that were as bad as the Pixel 2?

I'm not simply speculating either because we've already seen Apple's Samsung displays are better than Samsung's Samsung display. Apple has very high standards for screen quality.

I don't see why this wouldn't continue with LG. LG is also another year along, so they should have improved.
LG's panels on their own flagship and the Pixel sucked and various Android review sites pointed out they were generations below Samsung's panel. In fact it was comparable to a Samsung panel from 2012. Apple can't work magic with LG in 1 year. The Samsung panel iPhone will be superior
 
Three words:

OCD .....(There will always be winners and.......losers :D )

So in the forums just lie and say LG is better. That actually seems to work, as people are sheep and will believe anything you tell them.

It's alway fun to do this, as then they go en masse to the stores and exchange 10 times FOR THE WRONG ONE!!! ha ha ha.

Gotta love this.
 
Last edited:
I think you are misunderstanding what a fanboy is. Fanboy DEFENDS Apple no matter what. They wonder incredulously how they can possibly be granted the immense gift & pleasure of actually being allowed to own a phone made by Apple and pay as little as "only $1,000+" for it. If Apple rolled out a phone:
  • made of rusty razor blades, fanboys would be passionately spinning the merits of regularly turning over our blood supplies.
  • that kills people, fanboys would be passionately arguing that the world is too crowded anyway... that a reduced population is good for the entire planet... all while attempting to shift actual blame to "cheap Chinese chargers" and other redirection spin standards.
  • sans battery & camera now as accessories (sold separately), fanboys would be gushing at the genius of Apple for letting those that need more or less battery choose whatever size they want now (as long as it's from Apple)... and those needing a better camera can now choose whatever quality they want (as long as it's from Apple too)... all while readily pouncing on anyone griping that a battery-less and camera-less iPhone is still priced at the same level or higher vs. iPhones that used to have those baked in (because maximizing a corporation's profitability is right up there with "thinner" at any cost.. and kicking both of those out to sold-separately (exclusively by Apple) accessories would kill both birds with a single stone).
  • Etc.
Who you are referencing are the anti-fanboys and/or maybe the crowd in the middle not so intoxicated by the Koolaid that they may have (their own "think different") opinions that may differ from whatever Apple has for sale now... and/or can question the value of a $1000+ for a phone. Those are usually the ones complaining about useful feature deprecation... decisions like the notch... and price hikes... against which the fanboys typically rally to defend: "the future"/"we must be forced"..."I like the notch" (though I'm not buying notch stickers to overlay on up to all of my other screens)... and "only $X.XX more per month on the payment plan"/"don't like, don't buy." If all else fails: "$2XX Billion in the bank can't be wrong" and "...but who makes the most profitable <product name>?" If that doesn't work, devolve to name calling.

All ;) (barely).
Dude I’m sorry. I read the first sentence then saw how long it was and didn’t bother with anymore. Brutal. Anyway. You’re crazy if you don’t think Apple fanboys are the biggest nit pickers of anyone.
 
Oh good lord... here we go. Can someone go ahead and start threads for:

How do I tell which panel is in my X2
I've returned 47 iPhone X2s and still haven't gotten a Samsung panel
I've returned 47 iPhone X2s and still haven't gotten a LG panel
Samsung panel better than LG panel on X2
LG panel better than Samsung panel on X2
X2 Panel-gate
I've got green lines on my LG panel
I've got green lines on my LG panel
I've got ghosting on my Samsung panel
I've got ghosting on my Samsung panel
This sucks, I want my money back because I got an LG Panel on my X2
This sucks, I want my money back because I got a Samsung panel on my X2
Lets get a class action suit because of the panel inequality
Why can all the panels just be exactly the same
Displaymate: iPhone X2 LG display is rated the best ever
Displaymate: iPhone X2 Samsung display is rated best ever (posted 4 seconds after the prior thread for correct timing)
Note 9's display is better than X2 LG display

Did I miss any?

I don't think so.
Funny.

Me, I prefer LCD. Give me a good IPS display with color accuracy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aston441
LG's panels on their own flagship and the Pixel sucked and various Android review sites pointed out they were generations below Samsung's panel. In fact it was comparable to a Samsung panel from 2012. Apple can't work magic with LG in 1 year. The Samsung panel iPhone will be superior
What’s your point? Samsung’s panels on their own phones weren’t as good as iPhones and it was by a wide margin in specs and consistency. So that nullifies LG making poor panels on their own flagship. Maybe they just had low standards? If the LG panels don’t meet Apple’s standard, I would think based on track record that they will be rejected.

You are again speculating about what Apple can do and what LG will do for Apple a year later and with limited capacity.
 
Oh good lord... here we go. Can someone go ahead and start threads for:

How do I tell which panel is in my X2
I've returned 47 iPhone X2s and still haven't gotten a Samsung panel
I've returned 47 iPhone X2s and still haven't gotten a LG panel
Samsung panel better than LG panel on X2
LG panel better than Samsung panel on X2
X2 Panel-gate
I've got green lines on my LG panel
I've got green lines on my LG panel
I've got ghosting on my Samsung panel
I've got ghosting on my Samsung panel
This sucks, I want my money back because I got an LG Panel on my X2
This sucks, I want my money back because I got a Samsung panel on my X2
Lets get a class action suit because of the panel inequality
Why can all the panels just be exactly the same
Displaymate: iPhone X2 LG display is rated the best ever
Displaymate: iPhone X2 Samsung display is rated best ever (posted 4 seconds after the prior thread for correct timing)
Note 9's display is better than X2 LG display

Did I miss any?
In your permutations you forgot the modem. /s
 
After seeing the Pixel 2 XL screen and how blue it is, I won’t be getting the plus. I’ll stick to the one with the LCD screen.
Screenshot_20180628-112436_Twitter.jpg
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.