While some of the concepts are interesting and well done i think someone went a long way for a fake out.. the FAQ included.
Installing the latest version of the Startup Disk control panel To switch from Mac OS 9 back to Mac OS X, be sure to use Startup Disk control panel version 9.2.1 or later. A recent version of the Startup Disk control panel is available at this location: docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=120024
Why would apple be updating startup disk when not supporting 9 anymore..
it just doesn't fit.
All the images are Panther stuff, apple's changed the X logo every time since jaguar i don't think they are going to stop that now.
The requirement of a DVD drive doesn't fit either.. my friend has an 800 mhrtz emac without one from less than two years ago.. i don't think they are going to abandon him now
The system prefs thing looks really fake and the scrollbar in the dropdown and the notable missing little arrow next to the magnifying glass tips me off if not for the sheer ugliness of the rest of it. It also doesn't make sense from a usability standpoint.. possibly covering the preferences under it. Not like them at all.
Dashboard sounds really cool and i'll even say i kinda almost like the look but it doesn't fit anything they've done or are doing. Anyone else notice though that the calender thing is called "calender" not ical? that alone tips me off it's fake, why would apple make two apps to do the same thing?
The "new" itunes GUI is too big and confusing.. not their style.
I'll also say i don't buy the safari things either Dave Hyatt once talked about RSS readers in his blog and came to the conclusion that RSS readers and Browsers should remain seperate... and while i know he's the rendering engine programmer not the app designer, and it was a while ago i think he has significant influence and the reaction was bad too.
Also i'd expect safari 2.0 to offer much more than 2 new features... if anything it would be safari 1.5 apple doesn 't jump numbers like that without a major overhaul (we're still at mail 1.3.8!)
Combine all this with the blatent typographic errors, un-apple like wording on things like "stealth mode" i just done buy it.
Apple is about wowing people with features not leaving them dissapointed.