Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
You know, I have to smile at some of the silliness here. 10 pages of "MS fail!" and "I knew it wouldn't work!" and all you have to do is look at the NYT article which says...

On Sept. 4, when the teaser ads started, the “buzz” about Microsoft was 25 percent positive and 13 percent negative, Mr. Marzilli said, and by Tuesday it was 28 percent positive and 8 percent negative. Microsoft “has been beat up pretty badly by the Apple advertisements in the last six months,” he said. “These are strong numbers, good numbers, for Microsoft.”

And...

Another research company, Zeta Interactive, using what it calls its Relevant Noise tool to mine places online like blogs and message boards for brand conversations, found what was described as overwhelmingly positive buzz surrounding Microsoft from Sept. 3 through Monday.

Of the posts analyzed by Relevant Noise during that stage of the teaser campaign, 63 percent were characterized as positive and 37 percent as negative.

As the ad agency says "It did what it needed to do".

Now, as an aside, I note from NPD's figures show the rate of growth of Mac sales decreasing in August from about 35% to 25% YoY which is less than the market expected. Probably more to do with the current economic climate but you never know do you? ;)
 
imapcsharkdiving.jpg

http://gizmodo.com/5051549/first-screenshot-of-the-new-microsoft-ads-im-a-pc-and-i-shark-dive

:eek:

so bad :D
 
new Microsoft ad...

(...opening music, something boring but horrendously expensive...)

Hi, I'm Bill Gates,

Nowadays I'm not so busy as I don't have to spend my day forcing manufacturers into crazy licensing agreements, but let me tell you, your average PC is really cheap, and if you buy one, you get a copy of Vista!
It's really good, sorry it went a bit stupid at the beginning, but these days it runs really great!
You can make your own PC too if you want, as long as your buy a copy of Vista, we don't care!
If you've got loads of cash, buy a Mac, they've got a decent OS too, but there's nothing stopping you installing Vista and playing games!

Thanks for listening, I'm off now to bend a shoe...

Bill
 
If you want a totally cool ad for a pretty defunct product that gets the message across with the catchyest song of 2008, Microsoft should have taken a leaf out of New Zealand Posts playbook.

The theme was "Send and you shall receive"
The song is "One Day" by Kiwi Band Op Shop and while the ad and song are totally memorable, the act of sending mail to people is still going the way of the CD - as is Vista. ;)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9hnomj-pGHc

The song "One Day" was the most requested Valentines Day song in NZ for 2008.

Just replace the filofax with a laptop, switch the gender roles and hey presto, she plays around with his laptop and really enjoys it but in the end does the right thing and returns it in a jiffy bag (is that too close to the Air's manilla envelope?) but with a photo of her as the wallpaper.
 
I totally retract what I said in previous posts about Microsoft having done their research.... apparently they didn't. As far as Gates showing up in commercials... hahaha, he must have gotten camera hungry. Once again, this whole debacle of a campaign shows Microsoft still can't connect with its user base.

-SweetSwirlingOnions
 
I have never understood why Microsoft does not target the weakest link in the Apple methodology - the lack of hardware choice. Apple offers 6 computers (MacPro, iMac, MacMini, MacBook Pro, Macbook and MacBook Air) and its a huge weakness.

Excellent idea. Apple would probably sell them their advertisement materials for cheap, so Microsoft doesn't have to pay $300,000,000 for that. Show a MacPro ad, an iMac add, and so on, and then tell customers that they wouldn't want one of those.
 
So Seinfeld's effectively been paid $10M for two ads? Nice! Wish I could get that kind of work! Didn't he hold the record for the biggest pay-per-episode? And I'm sure that the advertising time during the final Seinfeld episode was the most expensive advertising time ever? I think Pepsi spent a fortune for a long ad.

Wish I was a few quid behind that feller :(
 
What Apple needs to release is a "small", head-less computer (doesn't matter if it's a bit bigger than the Mac mini) but with the specifications of the iMac (decent discrete GPU, 3.5" hard drive, DVD Burner).

What Apple _needs_? No, it is what _you want_. Apple, as a company, is optimising their profits. And Steve Jobs has a very long term view, so they are optimising their profits at least planning for the next five years. Don't you think someone at Apple has thought about this, put some numbers into a spreadsheet, and since Apple doesn't sell a minitower, the result was obviously that Apple _doesn't_ need it.
 
Well I liked the ads and will miss them. Admit it, they still beat most of the garbage ads we have today.
I loved them too. Seinfeld is always worth seeing on TV. Those ads didn't have to 'make sense' to be good entertainment.

I agree completely. There are so many fundamental hardware markets that Apple doesn't do anything at all to serve... Apple has absolutely nothing to compete with that.
Maybe Apple doesn't want to? I'm just saying.

And don't even get me started on the mid range desktop market segment
Okay, I won't. This is a thread about a TV ad, after all. ;)
 
Wirelessly posted (iPhone: Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 2_1 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/525.18.1 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/3.1.1 Mobile/5F136 Safari/525.20)

If this new Ad starts with "I'm a PC" won't Apple have some legal claims to that? I don't look for Apple just to sit back and take something like that when they went after people like Psystar.
 
Well, they tried.

I don't get how hard these guys make it look to make a great ad. It's not that hard at all. People don't want abstract, and they don't want to have to think about it. They want you to tell them clearly what the idea behind the product is.

- iPhone ads: Show the product. All white background, no visual distraction. Walk you through some of the features, like Safari and GPS. All about the product. Tells you why it's a great product, and what the idea behind it is.
- MacBook Air: Show the product. Key feature: size. Make the point visually that it's very thin. That's it. Shows the idea behind the product, and no extra fuzz.
- iMac ads: Show the product. Design philosophy: remove the cable clutter. Spin the product around, make it clear that it's a neat unit. That's it. People get the point.
- iPod nano ads: Show the product. Key feature: lots of colours, new, thin form factor. Spin the product around, let them see it. Show the new colours. Done.
- iPod touch ads: Show the product. Key feature: games (app store). Show some examples. Nuff said.

Notice a pattern? Show the damn product! Make it all about the product! I saw a chewing gum advert the other day that had some guy at the photocopier. He fell through the floor, got dragged around different places, shrunk, and fell in to the copier. What on earth is that about? Why should I buy that product? To get high?

Even the iPhone advertising at the stores is beginning to get copied. Apple decided to have giant demo units, to show people the product. Now everyone's trying to do it, which is good, but the stuff on the screens is not what you get on the handset, which shows they missed the point entirely.

:cool: I'm in love with this post! *little floating hearts around it*

Hey, at least they scrubbed it before they got the Bill Gates/Jerry Seinfeld '80s Taster's Choice coffee ads love scenes. ;)
 
it makes sense

it makes sense. microsoft has been ripping off apple's OS since about 2000, so it's only natural that they'd start ripping off apple's commercials as well.
 
I'm actually thinking George... why? It's simple (notice the similarity?)

Not to mention the new version of windows will now have the Seinfeld theme song for the startup.wav

Well, as bad as Microsoft's Jerry/Bill ads were, at least they didn't unleash this print ad like DirecTV did.

I made a slight change to reflect this story (the yellow font's mine).

http://i37.tinypic.com/8w9or8.jpg
 
Has any of this news been officially confirmed yet? I trust and respect NYT, but still...

Yes. Microsoft confirmed late on Wedneday this was part of their planned stratgey.

As mentioned, response to the adverts has been positive although from the rumblings of the usual incompetent tech bloggers you wouldn't think that was the case.
 
You mean exaggeration. I don't know why some people think that just because we use a Mac, we need to hate Windows!
Although I don't use Windows near as regularly as OS-X, I still think it's an okay OS.

Errr... I used XP for the first time when I got my new iMac with boot camp. Figured there's all those great games that are PC exclusives... yeah... despite only having used XP for a combined total of 40 hours or so in the past several months (thank god The Orange Box was so cheap,) I've had it crash on me 20+ times. I've probably used Mac OS X 40 hours a week and I don't think I've had it crash on me once (although I have had it get very slow... I imagine that's because I'm an beginning programmer and not doing garbage collection well enough which results in memory leaks... I just reset it every other week to fix that... although I wonder if there's a program that I can download to instantly detect and fix memory leaks...)

Oh yeah, to sum it up, you should hate windows. It's an awful operating system. Valve needs to get on the right OS before I'll resume playing their games. (*Crosses fingers hoping they'll release Portal 2 for Mac.*)
 
Oh well, I don't quite agree with Apple's "Get a Mac" campaign (although I think most of them are hilarious) because I'm against companies that diss on other products to promote their own...
But to see Microsoft resorting to the same kind of "marketing strategy" is really funny because they're showing how desperate they really are!

I just hope it fails.
 
Oh yeah, to sum it up, you should hate windows. It's an awful operating system. Valve needs to get on the right OS before I'll resume playing their games. (*Crosses fingers hoping they'll release Portal 2 for Mac.*)


A case of PBK if ever there was one.
 
Well well well......the saga isn't over. Before I start ranting I do hope to see the ad soon and not be biased.....in another thread I suggested they use that PC geek they use in the Apple ad and make some fun at Apple yet making him (PC) look better....sense of humor guys..

up to now....combined with the "average guy" misstep with Seinfeld MS seems desperate!!!!! Why not REALLY innovate with some mind blowing ad concept and in the last frame wink at Apple by having that geek stick out his tongue or something like that.....gosh....bring out that ad already!

One good thing is, we're talking Microsoft on this forum.....they're infiltrating..:D
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.