Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
An Intel Core i7 which requires a fan to keep cool is only 1.7x faster than a 2 year old A9X ARM CPU? Doesn't sound too impressive.

Eh, we don't know exactly which chip they used to obtain that benchmark or how it was configured. The 13.5 hour battery life claim comes from the i5 model, which is fanless, and being fanless, it's probably a very low power 15W, dual-core mobile i5 meant for tablets, so it doesn't really surprise me that it's only 1.7 times faster than an iPad Pro. There is a huge range of i series processors meant for different kinds of devices, so throwing out a blanket statement like "an i7 is only 1.7x faster" doesn't really make sense. Desktop and even laptop class i5s and i7s are a whole lot more than 1.7x faster than an iPad, but the Surface isn't using those variants of the i series chips.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: profets
While running real software instead of gimped apps coded specifically for that walled garden of an architecture? Yeah, it's damned impressive actually. That's the equivalent of my truck loaded up with the kids and camping gear going nearly twice as fast on gravel as your specifically tuned hatchback over a straight flat paved track on racing slicks.

Yup, because everyone needs an inefficient loaded truck to travel on gravel roads for camping day to day.
 
even Microsoft is destroying Apple today !

...and Tim continues his apology tour and SJW pandering
 
0 ?
With so much applications non touch ready... there are applications with workaround on iPad and no touch version on windows,
With control panel which still contain options that are not in the sertings application,
...

Huh? sorry I didn't follow your train of thought there, maybe a language barrier.

Apple don't need to spend money on marketing on this. To me, yhe Apple proposal is more relevant.
My MB has much better lapability, keyboard and trackpad than my SP2, and it is still true vs SP4,
My iPad air 2 is more enjoyable to use as a tablet, lighter, with better touch UI,
The data is perfectly shared between my devices, from my laptop to my phone.

What we discuss here are purely opinions, and nothing else. My opinion differs from yours. My surface pro 4 has better lapability due to the kickstand, which allows me to configure it in various positions. The touchscreen also makes it a better "lap"top IMO because you are not contorting your wrist/arm in an effort to reach the trackpad. On the flip side IMO the surface pro is a MUCH better tablet than the ipad. The ipads are not that much lighter than the newly announced SP5, and I never understood that argument anyhow, as if consumers held up their ipads in the air in order to use them. The touch UI IMO is worse on iOS, once again my opinion. I can also share data perfectly between my devices using either Microsoft or google services, and there are 3rd party services even beyond them which work well.

But once again we are just stating our opinions and differences of uses. I like being able to have a single device (and a smartphone) which can drive every single computing aspect of my life and never having to buy multiple devices again.
[doublepost=1495578735][/doublepost]
Good question, here's what I think "tablet" use is:
1. No mouse
2. No physical keyboard
3. Not plugged in.

Excellent!
My surface pro 4 can run
1. without a mouse
2. without a physical keyboard
3. unplugged
 
Did we really get anywhere with this thread today ...these sort of debates happen too often? See you guys next time to debate the surface pro against the newest Ipad in a week or two lol.....
 
  • Like
Reactions: JMacHack
This thread is about the surface pro, not the newly introduced surface laptop. Once again putting a full desktop OS with no compromises in a tablet is pretty darn impressive in my book.

Ah I got you now. I just don't really consider the Surface Pro a tablet. More of a laptop with touch capabilities like the rest of them. As a tablet, windows 10 is pretty lousy.
[doublepost=1495580011][/doublepost]
The processor.

Aren't there other laptops with the same processor out there running windows 10 with a touchscreen?
 
cause Apple is marketing it as a "Laptop Replacement"
I have the iPad Pro to use it as a tablet which is very good, but a laptop replacement? no way!

No they're not. One time Cook mentioned that it can be a laptop replacement for many creative people (graphic artists, etc). Certainly not for all people. That statement does not translate to an Apple marketing campaign. Still, some do like to trot it out to support the silly Apple is not serious about Macs anymore narrative.
 
It may well be "1.7x faster", but simultaneously it's 137.129x more of a compromise from an insecure company who don't know what to quote and what to copy. Additionally, 92.179% % of statistics used by marketing people are made up on the spot, off the spot, or somewhere approximately close to the spot.

When all you have to crow about are fabric keyboards, interconnecting mechanisms, clumsy jog dials that sliiiiiide slowly down the screen on your ridiculously hideous and compromised Desktop and snake-esque screen hinges, people instinctively feel, whether they have the balls to say it or not, that you're SO lost in the woods that even a bloodhound couldn't sniff you out and rescue you.

What earthly use are all these hybrid toys, when the software you run on them are heavily compromised, crippled toy versions of REAL software? Candy Crush Saga, anyone? How about a "Universal" app with limited functionality with a hideous UI and no reason to exist? Yes, there are plenty of those.

Apple sell feature sets, not chipsets; when will these monkeys learn.
 
Last edited:
The entire industry needs to kill this hybrid tablet-laptop BS and just go back to making solid products. That includes the 12.9 iPad Pro and Microsoft Surface.

Whats next, combining a toaster and refrigerator and selling it to consumers?

Completely disagree with you. Why should I need to buy three $1,000+ devices to haul around with me (smartphone, tablet, and laptop). Have you traveled much? What I don't get is the 2in1 devices with a 360 degree hinge. They are way to heavy to hold as you would an iPad for tablet use, but the Surface Pro is very hand holdable when the keyboard is removed. You also can use it during take off and landing on planes (for now). I travel quite a bit and really love this category device. Give me this and a smartphone and I'm good for everything.

IKR? I don't know a single person who owns a Surface, yet I and everyone owns 1 to several iPads, Macs and iPhones! Meow!

I have several iPads that are in a pile on a shelf. They are big versions of my phone. When I went to the iPhone plus, that eliminated the need for me to haul around an iPad. The Surface Pro completes the picture so that if I really want a larger tablet experience I have it, and its lighter than the laptop I would otherwise haul as well. Perfect form factor for me.

Keyboard is still not included and they are even selling the pen separately for a higher price.

And 4G/128SSD for a base model is just tiny for any sort of task--similar to where 16G iPhones stand nowadays, except that they're not being sold anymore.

The reason they removed the pen from the box is because the pens are now colored like the keyboard. They had a choice. Do something stupid like Apple did with the watches and bundle a few combinations meaning to get what you want you have to potentially buy a watch band you don't want. Or, separate them so you can put together the combination you want. I believe they priced it down from the original Surface Pro 4 price accordingly. I'd rather they unbundle than make me pick a keyboard/pen color I don't want if I get an i5 vs. an i7.

Windows 10 is NOT stable.

This is ridiculous. I use it every day. Most of our company (tens of thousands of people) are on Windows 10. Windows 10 is pretty good and I like where they are going with it. In contrast, Apple continues to not do much interesting (to me) with MacOS, and what they are doing is in a walled garden that only works with Apple stuff. Microsoft is opening up to support an open collection of devices.

yes, the only "professional users" are those "rendering motion graphics in adobe after effects" .... or thats a far far less than 1% of users.

the delusion involved in convincing yourself that people using after effects on a tablet is even remotely a segment that needs addressed is mind boggling.

the ipad pro is exactly what it wants to be, a high end tablet that can do 99.9% of desktop tasks 99.9% of the world population need it to.

and frankly, if im going to be "RENDERING MOTION GRAPHICS IN ADOBE AFTER EFFECTS" id be more confotable on a macbook than a tablet. both cost the same. both weigh the same, the surface pro weighs double the ipad air 2 and 33% more than the ipad pro..

"man i wish my tablet weighed as much as a notebook so i could render motion graphics in adobe after effects." - no one.

There is no way that an iPad can do 99.9% of the tasks that 99.9% of the world does. Most of the business world lives on Windows and uses business applications. While an iPad can open a spreadsheet, I would shoot myself if I had to use it to do any complex work like pivot tables, macros, etc... There are also plenty of other products, Microsoft Project for example, that are used in the business world that won't work on an iPad. And I frequently need to have several different applications open to work on a project and move information around. Again, the hokey multitasking of iOS is not up to the task.

The iPad can do the light email checking and opening documents on the road, but I would never travel on a business trip without a real computer. So if I had an iPad, I'm hauling three $1,000+ devices. With the Surface Pro, I have my desktop computer and my tablet covered in one device.

And its not just business. I am a photographer and heavily use Lightroom. With an iPad, I again get a scaled down version of it. With the Surface Pro I can use the full blown Lightroom on the road. I can take the card from my camera, insert it into the Surface Pro, and begin working directly in Lightroom. When I get to the house and dock, I can continue with the 4K display and not miss a beat.

Correct. Microsoft actually deliberately calls it a laptop in their marketing. The word tablet is not anywhere. But they compare it to an iPad. What they should be doing is comparing it to both the rMB or MBA or 13" MBP simultaneously with an iPad. This is what the market would relate to. Much cheaper than having a laptop & tablet combo, but just as capable. Not that I agree, but that's the angle they should be taking...

There reality is Microsoft doesn't know what to compare it to because Apple has no comparable product. Apple would have to compare an iPad and MBP together to it. So add the price and weight of them together and compare that! Apple refuses to allow touch on a real full function computer, so they will continue to not have a comparable product.

When are Surface's gonna realize its 2017 and come with 8GB RAM and 256 storage MINIMUM??

4 GB of RAM is good for iOS, not Windows

That's simply not true. It depends on what you are doing, but many people work just fine with 4G and 128G in Windows.
 
This looks awfully good. A great ad too - highlighting all use cases for the pen, not just drawing like Apple does in its ads for the iPad Pro. I am seriously considering a Surface Pro for my next laptop/tablet purchase in a couple of years despite the fact that I would have to switch to Windows which I have not touched in years. Still, the fact is this can be a substitute for both a laptop and a tablet at once and an iPad can not. Right now I regularly use two devices for work: a 12.9 inch iPad Pro with Apple pencil for note taking, shared whiteboard and annotating and an MBA for everything else like LaTex. Have to carry both of them on trips. For me a Surface Pro would be good enough to serve as both a laptop and a tablet. can't beat that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sdz
The pen is no longer bundled with the new Surface Pro. It's a separate $99 purchase. Looks like Microsoft learned something from Apple. I wonder if it'll be able to draw straight diagonal lines this time around. That's far more important to me than 4096 levels of pressure sensitivity. I don't even know how many levels of pressure sensitivity my Apple Pencil has. I just know that it feels miles better than the Surface pen that I tried.

13 hours of Microsoft claimed battery life is going to translate into... I'm guessing 7 hours of normal use at best, which is actually not bad for such a compact Windows machine, but still less than the iPad Pro.

It's lighter but still somewhat heavier than the 12.9" iPad Pro which is already on the heavy side. That's fine for a laptop, but not so great for a tablet.

From what I've been able to dig up, the I5 version is using a 15 watt TDP CPU. Surely that's going to throttle in a bad way without a fan?!? I guess we will see people employ the Surface Pro 3 trick of using a USB fan to blow air across the back of the device. On the positive side, we won't hear all those horror stories from people having their Surface Pro turning into a hairdryer at an important meeting because Windows decided it was time to update.

To be honest, this is just another incremental upgrade that Microsoft is trying to turn into a bigger deal than it is. It's not really going to change anything. It'll still be a decent, if overpriced, ultraportable laptop and a very mediocre tablet. I still find the Macbook + iPad combo to be a much better experience, but some people obviously prefer the 'one device to rule them all' approach.

I may have missed some earlier comments similar to yours, but you seem to be one of the first people in 12 pages of comments to mention the REAL battery life of Surface tablets -- with the Surface Pro 4, it is at most 6-7 hours (probably more like 5.5 on average). A few of my friends own them, and I was curious, so I have regularly inquired...to see if there were any improvements due to software updates. Over the course of 1+ year of my asking, none of them has seen battery life improvements. I believe that Microsoft previously claimed 9 hours battery life for the Surface Pro 4. So that 6 hours instead of 9 hours life = 67% of the claimed battery capability.

Estimating the same 67% 'real-life' performance on this new claim of 13.5 hours...would give you 9 hours of battery life with the new Surface Pro! Still far less than I get on my iPad Pro's (minimum 10 hours, but usually more like 13-14 hours, depending on brightness settings; and this is with LTE/cellular always ON).

I do think that the Surface Pro is an interesting and beautifully made product - if I really wanted a Windows machine, I probably would buy the NEXT iteration (when they call it the "5", if that's what they're planning). I think that no USB-C and their hideous wall-wart power block/connector are a real failure for a Windows machine and a laptop-replacement or alternative. USB-C would allow the use of power packs like we can use with iPads and Macbook/Pros thanks to the power source -- this is a real benefit to users, particularly if one does need to have some reassurance that you won't run out of power when there's no access.

Regarding the CPUs, the i5 and i7 -- are these the renamed M5 and M7 lines? or are they real i5 and i7s (prior to MS changing their naming conventions)?
 
How is the cost even remotely the same? Only the cheapest Surface Pro is in the iPad Pro price range, and it'll run Windows 10 like **** with those 4 Gigs of RAM.

I actually had the 4gb version and it ran w10 just fine.
 
A not so great keyboard..? Have you used a macbook? Dare I ask...have you used that thing Apple calls a keyboard for the iPad Pro?

I'll tell you caveman, that Surface Pro keyboard is bliss.

I think it is a matter of personal preference. To start off with, there are several keyboards available for iPad Pro. You can choose whatever look and feel you like.
 
Does it? Honest question. I thought there was a tablet mode on Windows.
One thing the iPad won't be able to compete is local storage. I don't think we'll see a 1TB SSD on an iPad anytime soon. Especially since they're pushing iCloud storage.

Yes, it has a tablet mode, but the vast majority of apps are designed for the standard windows interface they are not optimized for touch. They've just enabled a touch layer as an extra function.
 
Completely disagree with you. Why should I need to buy three $1,000+ devices to haul around with me (smartphone, tablet, and laptop). Have you traveled much? What I don't get is the 2in1 devices with a 360 degree hinge. They are way to heavy to hold as you would an iPad for tablet use, but the Surface Pro is very hand holdable when the keyboard is removed. You also can use it during take off and landing on planes (for now). I travel quite a bit and really love this category device. Give me this and a smartphone and I'm good for everything.



I have several iPads that are in a pile on a shelf. They are big versions of my phone. When I went to the iPhone plus, that eliminated the need for me to haul around an iPad. The Surface Pro completes the picture so that if I really want a larger tablet experience I have it, and its lighter than the laptop I would otherwise haul as well. Perfect form factor for me.



The reason they removed the pen from the box is because the pens are now colored like the keyboard. They had a choice. Do something stupid like Apple did with the watches and bundle a few combinations meaning to get what you want you have to potentially buy a watch band you don't want. Or, separate them so you can put together the combination you want. I believe they priced it down from the original Surface Pro 4 price accordingly. I'd rather they unbundle than make me pick a keyboard/pen color I don't want if I get an i5 vs. an i7.



This is ridiculous. I use it every day. Most of our company (tens of thousands of people) are on Windows 10. Windows 10 is pretty good and I like where they are going with it. In contrast, Apple continues to not do much interesting (to me) with MacOS, and what they are doing is in a walled garden that only works with Apple stuff. Microsoft is opening up to support an open collection of devices.



There is no way that an iPad can do 99.9% of the tasks that 99.9% of the world does. Most of the business world lives on Windows and uses business applications. While an iPad can open a spreadsheet, I would shoot myself if I had to use it to do any complex work like pivot tables, macros, etc... There are also plenty of other products, Microsoft Project for example, that are used in the business world that won't work on an iPad. And I frequently need to have several different applications open to work on a project and move information around. Again, the hokey multitasking of iOS is not up to the task.

The iPad can do the light email checking and opening documents on the road, but I would never travel on a business trip without a real computer. So if I had an iPad, I'm hauling three $1,000+ devices. With the Surface Pro, I have my desktop computer and my tablet covered in one device.

And its not just business. I am a photographer and heavily use Lightroom. With an iPad, I again get a scaled down version of it. With the Surface Pro I can use the full blown Lightroom on the road. I can take the card from my camera, insert it into the Surface Pro, and begin working directly in Lightroom. When I get to the house and dock, I can continue with the 4K display and not miss a beat.



There reality is Microsoft doesn't know what to compare it to because Apple has no comparable product. Apple would have to compare an iPad and MBP together to it. So add the price and weight of them together and compare that! Apple refuses to allow touch on a real full function computer, so they will continue to not have a comparable product.



That's simply not true. It depends on what you are doing, but many people work just fine with 4G and 128G in Windows.


I think your average Chromebook user would disagree with most of this, let alone the people who are using iPads for an increasing number of use cases.

That being said, you made some good points. But since my employer supplies me with a laptop for the road, I would want my second device to be a small and light (yet useful) as possible. Hence, the iPad Prol
 
And I wonder how many people complaining about the capabilities of the iPad are even interested in using it as a tablet, as a consumption device. Laptops have been getting thinner and lighter while more powerful. Why complain about iPad when what what they really need is a laptop?

Well the iPad is getting better at productivity but it is dependent on developers. But I would agree the vast majority of iPad users use it as a consumption device.
 
Huh? sorry I didn't follow your train of thought there, maybe a language barrier.



What we discuss here are purely opinions, and nothing else. My opinion differs from yours. My surface pro 4 has better lapability due to the kickstand, which allows me to configure it in various positions. The touchscreen also makes it a better "lap"top IMO because you are not contorting your wrist/arm in an effort to reach the trackpad. On the flip side IMO the surface pro is a MUCH better tablet than the ipad. The ipads are not that much lighter than the newly announced SP5, and I never understood that argument anyhow, as if consumers held up their ipads in the air in order to use them. The touch UI IMO is worse on iOS, once again my opinion. I can also share data perfectly between my devices using either Microsoft or google services, and there are 3rd party services even beyond them which work well.

But once again we are just stating our opinions and differences of uses. I like being able to have a single device (and a smartphone) which can drive every single computing aspect of my life and never having to buy multiple devices again.
[doublepost=1495578735][/doublepost]

Excellent!
My surface pro 4 can run
1. without a mouse
2. without a physical keyboard
3. unplugged


1. Surface Pro can work without a mouse, but even Windows 10's tablet mode cannot compare to a touch-first UI like Android or iOS.
2. How often do Surface Pro users REALLY use the Surface Pro without a keyboard? It comes with a keyboard with a trackpad by default and that's how people tend to use it.
3. The version Microsoft just announced might be different, but previous generations of Surface Pro didn't have nearly the battery life of an iPad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6foot5foot
They're charging $2,700 for the top model that doesn't even have a dedicated GPU. :D

You could spend $2,700 and get a powerful desktop and a lightweight ultrabook/2-in-1.

And you'd get the best of both worlds... with both computers doing the best they can.

Instead of the "jack of all trades... master of none" Surface Pro. :)
 
No they're not. One time Cook mentioned that it can be a laptop replacement for many creative people (graphic artists, etc). Certainly not for all people. That statement does not translate to an Apple marketing campaign. Still, some do like to trot it out to support the silly Apple is not serious about Macs anymore narrative.
They did that in multiple iPad Pro ads, google them :)
 
And iOS is based off the Mach Kernel and OS X. Point?
Responding to Poster who said Windows 10 was designed from ground up as Mobile UI
[doublepost=1495584634][/doublepost]
1. Surface Pro can work without a mouse, but even Windows 10's tablet mode cannot compare to a touch-first UI like Android or iOS.
2. How often do Surface Pro users REALLY use the Surface Pro without a keyboard? It comes with a keyboard with a trackpad by default and that's how people tend to use it.
3. The version Microsoft just announced might be different, but previous generations of Surface Pro didn't have nearly the battery life of an iPad.
It works fine as a tablet; its touch repsonse and UI is every bit as good as an ipad. I use as an art tablet almost exclusively--yes, without the keyboard. It is a very popular art and design tablet. But, whatever.
[doublepost=1495584778][/doublepost]
Good question, here's what I think "tablet" use is:
1. No mouse
2. No physical keyboard
3. Not plugged in.
Look up hybrid in the dictionary
 
  • Like
Reactions: jase1125
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.