Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
My new replacement laptop has arrived.. Week 32, LG panel... No yellowing issue anymore... :)

can you request an lg panel for a replacement?
i don't know what to do with my mbp, i don't know if i have to send this back to my reseller, because, i'm afraid,of what i've read that some have their replacement that have worser cases, like much yellower or with dead pixels, the other thing that bothers me is that i only noticed the yellow thing when i read this forum, maybe, this is ok? but since, i can't stop thinking about this anymore, please help me decide, please,,.... please take a look at the photos below, i had no camera with me, so i took the pictures with my n70 so the photos are not so clear, please help me decide...

http://img529.imageshack.us/img529/7485/90231745ai8.jpg

http://img170.imageshack.us/img170/6943/98665094wo3.jpg

http://img256.imageshack.us/img256/3317/26479812iq7.jpg

http://img206.imageshack.us/img206/900/33836916cw5.jpg

the last photo, i rotated vertically,....
 
Can someone tell me how to see who manufactured the screen?

Also, does Apple just switch out your computer if you're under the 14 days?

System Profile -> Display -> Colors -> Profile -> Scroll down to 13.

Those that end w/ 67 = LG i think
 
can you request an lg panel for a replacement?
i don't know what to do with my mbp, i don't know if i have to send this back to my reseller, because, i'm afraid,of what i've read that some have their replacement that have worser cases, like much yellower or with dead pixels, the other thing that bothers me is that i only noticed the yellow thing when i read this forum, maybe, this is ok? but since, i can't stop thinking about this anymore, please help me decide, please,,.... please take a look at the photos below, i had no camera with me, so i took the pictures with my n70 so the photos are not so clear, please help me decide...

http://img529.imageshack.us/img529/7485/90231745ai8.jpg

http://img170.imageshack.us/img170/6943/98665094wo3.jpg

http://img256.imageshack.us/img256/3317/26479812iq7.jpg

http://img206.imageshack.us/img206/900/33836916cw5.jpg

the last photo, i rotated vertically,....

Yours is a lot like mine, not sure if it's grainy.
 
hi Helfeather, what do plan to do? do you plan on returning your mbp? my only fear in returning, was that, from what i read here, some of their replacements, have had much worse cases like dead pixel or kernel panics stuff(which i never had with this one, yet) so i really like this to be a keeper, but i'm afraid the yellow thing will be bothering me...

and what bad does the yellow thing can do overtime? can it get much worser as in much yellower as time goes by? those are my fears, so i really don't know what to do, to return or not to return....
 
So what do you guys say when you take it back to the Apple store to get it exchanged? Looking at the black screen test with the two white boxes, the bottom one is definitely a little darker and has a very subtle yellow tint but it's such a small difference I'm thinking the Apple guys would just tell me to take a hike. ;)

I'm just outside of 14 days too. It's been about 18 days now.
 
hi Helfeather, what do plan to do? do you plan on returning your mbp? my only fear in returning, was that, from what i read here, some of their replacements, have had much worse cases like dead pixel or kernel panics stuff(which i never had with this one, yet) so i really like this to be a keeper, but i'm afraid the yellow thing will be bothering me...

and what bad does the yellow thing can do overtime? can it get much worser as in much yellower as time goes by? those are my fears, so i really don't know what to do, to return or not to return....

It's best you try consulting an Apple Genius.

Go to your nearest Apple Store.
 
Week 33, Samsung, Yellow

2.2 5400 MBP 15"
Samsung
Week 33

Clear but not obvious yellowing at the bottom third and high idle temp,
that means you dont need to use any test pictures and you probably wont notice it unless you have a full hight webpage with white background
you wont notice or think its normal, but it still shows yellowing. When
you scroll up the yellow becomes pure white.
 
2.2 5400 MBP 15"
Samsung
Week 33

Clear but not obvious yellowing at the bottom third and high idle temp,
that means you dont need to use any test pictures and you probably wont notice it unless you have a full hight webpage with white background
you wont notice or think its normal, but it still shows yellowing. When
you scroll up the yellow becomes pure white.

hi, maybe that is also my case, so you think it's ok to get it back to the store for a replacement? honestly eversince, i discovered this problem, i can't stop thinking about this, i don't know if this yellow thing can cause harm or can worsen in the long run. maybe i just want my macbook pro to be standard or normal just like it is supposed to be... so you plan on returning it? or you are keeping it?
 
hi, maybe that is also my case, so you think it's ok to get it back to the store for a replacement? honestly eversince, i discovered this problem, i can't stop thinking about this, i don't know if this yellow thing can cause harm or can worsen in the long run. maybe i just want my macbook pro to be standard or normal just like it is supposed to be... so you plan on returning it? or you are keeping it?

I will be returning this MBP as soon as possible, and if they give me any trouble as im within the two weeks rule I will be returning it to them for a refund. And then I just go and buy a new one and start all over unless they actually send me something that works out of the box.

I dont find this amusing having to explain to them that there are actually problems with the delivered MBPs and that they think im sort of a nutcase imagining things and being more petty about proving the fault and it being within spec.

It should be an exception not a rule that this happens to customers, even their great service doesnt take away the foul taste in my mouth, feeling distrusted, insulted and unsatisfied and thinking they are doing me a favour by replacing a faulty unit instead of forcing me to repair a brand new unit.

They aint doing me a favour if they are replacing it with another obviously faulty unit. They do what is supposed of them when they give me a working product and without unacceptable faults.

Its not like I care that its not perfect, I dont, but I would be more satisfied if it was, but there are limits to what I see as simple imperfections when they become faults, such as yellowing. I've had 5 MBPs not one of them was without some fault, banding, yellowing, backlight leaking and heat.

They do seem to have serious quality issues, not only did my have yellowing it also idles at 56-58 C and simple tasks like surfing and installing applications makes it go up 65 and above. The previous ones I had with problems were much cooler idle at 42-50 C and at simple tasks no more than 60.

This seem to go up and down in waves probably as they get new recruits that dont know how to apply cooling paste. Still not acceptable to me even if they think its within spec that a machine should run 10-15 C warmer depending on the quality of the employees want to put into their work. Because some factory employees dont listen or their bosses dont communicate instructions correctly or whatever the reason all the way to Steve Jobs.

Anyway, im returning this one and I will get a replacement if they dont want to give me one I will get refund and then I will buy a new and replace it until I get tired of it or they ship me one that is in acceptable condition and not needing instant repairs. Maybe that will make them think about quality issues when making products I really really want to have.

P.S. And im probably getting a refund this time, because they it will be to much of a hassle to get a replacement unit when they already sent me so many faulty ones. Just as well might be good to get a new history with them.

Also I argument with Apple representatives in a good manner and inform them of my point of view on matters. They want a sale and I want a working without faults computer. If I dont get what I want I just get a refund and decide later what to do with my money. I keep myself within the two weeks that way I have as much on Apple as they have on me.
 
hi fajm, thanks for the reply, good for you because you are still within the 2 weeks period, but mine is more than a month, you think, they will still replace my mbp if it is outside the two weeks period?

this is such a pain, i wish apple, didn't ship their macbook pro with the samsung lcd and yellowing issues, and now it's our problem... i really can't stop noticing the yellows on the bottom (now that i know of it) probably, i'll go to the service center here in our country,(philippines) to ask their opinion, but what if, they think i'm nuts imagining things?
 
hi fajm, thanks for the reply, good for you because you are still within the 2 weeks period, but mine is more than a month, you think, they will still replace my mbp if it is outside the two weeks period?

this is such a pain, i wish apple, didn't ship their macbook pro with the samsung lcd and yellowing issues, and now it's our problem... i really can't stop noticing the yellows on the bottom (now that i know of it) probably, i'll go to the service center here in our country,(philippines) to ask their opinion, but what if, they think i'm nuts imagining things?

I dont know, but they probably insist on you having to repair it. And when it comes to a third repair you can try get a new one. Just remember to makes photos of your MBP and ports before sending it off.

You could argument and insist on that you should not have to repair a new faulty MBP that came with yellowing. Its not like you have done anything wrong except being a good customer and trying to live with a for you a horrible screen and you simple couldnt stand it anymore. And you didnt expect that you should be needing to repair a brand new MBP.

One month isnt much i´ve kept MBPs longer while waiting for the replacement to arrive. Depends probably allot for someone who has empathy for your situation or not, and they are pretty flexible they can exchange it if you present your situation and arguments in a good manner. If you get someone thats no good just hang up and call again =)

Hello,

me name,

I recieved a faulty MBP unit (good to say in the begining), sets their minds not for checking if its faulty, but "its faulty".

It has yellowing thats really bugging me and I cant stand it any more. The machine is good and im really satisfied except because for that yellowing. I'd like it to be replaced.

They say we can offer a repair...

You say, I feel bad about having to repair a _brand new_ machine that shouldnt be. Its not even my fault it was this way out of the box. Should I really be punished for my patience? and so on...


Be like this confident "its not my fault and I shouldnt take the consequences for Apple sending me faulty unit, I tried my best couldnt take it any more", not "hmm, I dont know, but like, I dont think it should be maybe me that should take the consequences for it", insist and be confident when argumenting and talking about your point of view. They are there to make you a satisfied customer even though they have serious quality issues. Something like that...im not native speaker nor do I know the american culture so improvise and prepare on paper points you'd like to bring up, and replys to what they might reply to you.

Its 5 AM here, sorry if this post is a little bit messy, and I have hard time finding the right words...as said not native speaker, it kinda limits the way you can "explain" yourself.
 
Display is perfect, no yellowing, no dead pixels

2.2GHz MBP 5,400rpm
LG Display - Glossy
34 Week

My computer did ship with a dead-as-doornails Magsafe power adapter, though. The genius at the Apple store swapped it out for a new one so I'm up and running and a happy camper. This thing is actually cooler and much quieter than the 12" Powerbook G4 1.5GHz it's replacing. No regrets.
 
I will be returning this MBP as soon as possible, and if they give me any trouble as im within the two weeks rule I will be returning it to them for a refund. And then I just go and buy a new one and start all over unless they actually send me something that works out of the box.

I dont find this amusing having to explain to them that there are actually problems with the delivered MBPs and that they think im sort of a nutcase imagining things and being more petty about proving the fault and it being within spec.

It should be an exception not a rule that this happens to customers, even their great service doesnt take away the foul taste in my mouth, feeling distrusted, insulted and unsatisfied and thinking they are doing me a favour by replacing a faulty unit instead of forcing me to repair a brand new unit.

They aint doing me a favour if they are replacing it with another obviously faulty unit. They do what is supposed of them when they give me a working product and without unacceptable faults.

Its not like I care that its not perfect, I dont, but I would be more satisfied if it was, but there are limits to what I see as simple imperfections when they become faults, such as yellowing. I've had 5 MBPs not one of them was without some fault, banding, yellowing, backlight leaking and heat.

They do seem to have serious quality issues, not only did my have yellowing it also idles at 56-58 C and simple tasks like surfing and installing applications makes it go up 65 and above. The previous ones I had with problems were much cooler idle at 42-50 C and at simple tasks no more than 60.

This seem to go up and down in waves probably as they get new recruits that dont know how to apply cooling paste. Still not acceptable to me even if they think its within spec that a machine should run 10-15 C warmer depending on the quality of the employees want to put into their work. Because some factory employees dont listen or their bosses dont communicate instructions correctly or whatever the reason all the way to Steve Jobs.

Anyway, im returning this one and I will get a replacement if they dont want to give me one I will get refund and then I will buy a new and replace it until I get tired of it or they ship me one that is in acceptable condition and not needing instant repairs. Maybe that will make them think about quality issues when making products I really really want to have.

P.S. And im probably getting a refund this time, because they it will be to much of a hassle to get a replacement unit when they already sent me so many faulty ones. Just as well might be good to get a new history with them.

Also I argument with Apple representatives in a good manner and inform them of my point of view on matters. They want a sale and I want a working without faults computer. If I dont get what I want I just get a refund and decide later what to do with my money. I keep myself within the two weeks that way I have as much on Apple as they have on me.

I have some backlight leaking as well, and yellow with certain profiles and when viewing from the side you can clearly see a yellow cast over the screen. The thing that worries me most is the heat. I am idling around 60 C with like one simple application open, and when I imported a few songs I was up to 80 C, I can't even imagine how high it will get if I try a game.

I doubt I will return mine but I am thinking about it and will certainly keep an eye on the heat.
 
I have some backlight leaking as well, and yellow with certain profiles and when viewing from the side you can clearly see a yellow cast over the screen. The thing that worries me most is the heat. I am idling around 60 C with like one simple application open, and when I imported a few songs I was up to 80 C, I can't even imagine how high it will get if I try a game.

I doubt I will return mine but I am thinking about it and will certainly keep an eye on the heat.

I dont really know how to procede with that kind of issues. My first MBP was kinda like yours but it started to be cooler by itself. I played games and used apps and then shut it down to cool down when I did other things. I my head it started to idle a little bit cooler, but it might also be something phsycological because I first watched the temperature then and then, and then more often as I grew more concerned and then less when I got bored.

If I had a good MBP with only bad paste job I would request a repair mostly because we have local authorized apple repair shops and I could probably watch them doing the job. Dont know about sending it off somewhere id probably live with it or do the job myself in the future after reading the documentation and doing it mentally a few times and get the right equipment.

Also as I understand it, its really hard to get Apple to do something about MBP overheating unless it actually faults (kernel panics, sudden shutdowns, logic board problems, ...) because of that. They just say its within spec, which it is by logic if you are petty since the machine actually works, thought not comfortable and it becomes a subjective quality issue.

The latest one before this replacement was idle at 50-<55C something it now idles when im using firefox, transmission, on a table and charging at 46C. Its kinda technical issue, depending on the pastejob (if its not that excessive), it might cool down in the future. Im no expert, and I really do not know anything about pastejobs more than I learned on throught these forums, but I recommend you play same games and let it heat up and then let it cool down, unless someone here says its dangerous and can explain why. The machine should never heat up so that it gets damaged and in the end it might run cooler in the future.

I hope you are pleased and your issues get solved the easiest possible way. How long have you had yours? If its below 14 days, and you got backlight bleeding why not ask for a replacement unit. If its longer than that you might consider repair and request that it aint flextronics (kinda have bad reputation around here) doing the repair. Make sure you document your laptop, photos of it and the ports.
 
SR MBP 2.4 5400

Week 33, Samsung, arrived yesterday


Got yellowing on lower third. Tied loads of different profiles still there. not a major problem but no good for colour accurate work.

Also when the screen is closed, it rises slightly on one side.

Called apple and told them about both things. The guy said the screen not shutting properly could be the cause of the colour cast.

Arranged for a replacement no problem, due to arrive 11th-17th September. Hopefully they will have gotten rid of all the samsung panels by then
 
week 33 , samsung screen , definate yellowing :(

I picked up a MBP in store yesterday in the Manchester Arndale Apple Store (UK) got it home , fired it up and even from the boot up screen i could tell.

15"
2.2
Samsung
Week 33
Yellowing bottom third!


Going to take it back tomorrow and hopefully ask to boot up and see the screen before i take it home.
 
I picked up a MBP in store yesterday in the Manchester Arndale Apple Store (UK) got it home , fired it up and even from the boot up screen i could tell.

15"
2.2
Samsung
Week 33
Yellowing bottom third!


Going to take it back tomorrow and hopefully ask to boot up and see the screen before i take it home.

Same exact experience for me. Second replacement MBP (both for yellow issue): 15" 2.4 Samsung Week 33 Yellow bottom. So bad you can even tell on boot screen that is grey.
 
Matte screen. 2.2 ghz, Samsung display, YELLOW at bottom, purchased from Amazon.com...the good thing is that it came with the newer, smaller power adapter. However, it's going back. Don't need a urine yellow screen.

They will make you pay a restocking fee, correct?
I'm trying to find a no-hassle place where I can just keep returning until I get a good one. I want to be able to create my own luck without shipping things back and forth.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.