Some one who does not understand hardware keyboards at all.
While the res is kind of low the OS from waht I have seen is pretty promising and still holds true to the core of the OS.
As for the hardware keyboards RIM blackberry are the the gold standard when it comes to them. Touch screen keyboards have a lot of draw backs. One is ZERO tactile feel so you more need to look at the when typing on it. Also when the keyboard is in used on a touch screen it eats up a LOT of screen space to be used. The slider hardware gives the advantage of keeping all the screen space and still having a keyboard.
what you are seeing is the trade off of maintaining the keyboard interface, which is showing 2 major weaknesses and alluding to a 3rd.
1) no screen real estate (pixel wise)
2) weight and complexity of mechanics
3) likely a poor touch screen interface (why make touch accurate if you're not typing on it.)
4) 'promising' vs 'delivering' are always separate planes of capability.
typing: You can't argue it both ways... either you're looking at what you're typing on the screen (and you're only typing one character/word at a time), so your vision is locked on the screen anyway, or you're typing on the keyboard, and as a touch typist, you really don't need a screen at all (tactile response, remember?), so why argue that you need to see more of the screen?
MultiTasking?
Security? (removable RAM? are they encrypted?)
App Store?
GPS?
Accelerometer
Gyro?
Apps?
As far as I can tell,
- it's not a good web browser (webkit or not, the real estate will limit it, as well as the multi-touch accuracy)
- it's on the ATT network, which means it's hamstrung by the success of the iPhone (the network capacity is torqued).
Granted, if it does what RIM needs it to do (good enough browsing and a great RIM/BES experience), it will allow IT groups to continue to exclusive support of the Blackberry family... but for the average consumer, it's a 'meh' device, at a 'meh' price point.